Back in 2009, retailer Peltz Shoes made the decision to label its entire product selection with RFID tags in order to increase the efficiency of its warehouse an in-store operations. On paper, it sounded like a sensible decision, but Peltz has announced it is abandoning its RFID tryst, saying that RFID has caused more work than it saved.
Peltz was using the tags not just for location data, but also to provide detailed label information on its shoeboxes such as price, brand, color and size. At the time, the company envisioned the tags increasing inventory management efficiency and more importantly the inventory accuracy.
But Peltz has now announced that it found the tags resulted in a high labor cost to apply the tags, that the tags had a high per-unit cost, and ultimately led to inaccurate inventory levels – at $0.11 per Monarch EPC Gen 2 passive RFID label, plus the cost of the printers and scanners.
As each box required a label, every location required an RFID printer and the supplies to keep it running, expanding the system to keep up with a growing inventory was expensive – leading to the unexpected situation where an efficiency measure was hamstringing expansion.
One of the main problems was that the RFID printer used would print unactivated tags that were not undetectable until after the inventory cycle counts had been initiated – compounded by the issue of employees occasionally putting the wrong label on a box.
As a result, the inventory would be miscounted, and this would cause an unexpected labor cost to amend the issue. However, this does sound like a workflow issue rather than an issue with the technology itself. From the Peltz announcement, it’s unclear why the company couldn’t check the tags were activated before attaching them to the boxes – avoiding the issue entirely.
Again, it’s not clear if there was an underlying reason that meant such a validation was impossible, or just that the system was built on the assumption that the printer would work correctly and that it couldn’t be rebuilt or rectified. However, the other end of the system, the RFID scanners, were also problematic.
Peltz found that the scanners used by its employees were accurate about 99% of the time, and operated very quickly. However, “they often missed labels as well, with the 1% that were missed causing a big increase in labor. If canning 300,000 pairs of shoes, 3,000 of them would need to be manually verified for accuracy. The time and effort involved to correct such inaccuracies did not warrant the extra costs when compared to the low expense and accuracies of hand-scanning the entire inventory.”
As a result of its findings, Peltz has moved back to a barcode system for its inventory management, which it says has resulted in better counts and reconciliation levels.
Despite this, the company says that TFID is a great tool, but one that would be a lot better if manufacturers began applying the tags inside of the product itself. Peltz says this would “increase inventory accuracy straight from the factory, but would also have the added benefits of preventing mismatches and theft.”
Nonetheless, the firm says that due to all the inaccuracies and associated costs, RFID won’t be a viable solution until manufacturing undergoes a significant change at the wholesale level.
This is a pretty fair comment, given that manufacturers are best placed to tag the items as part of the process of creating them in the first place – although the counter argument will be that this is another cost and task for the manufacturer to carry out, which they may well wish to avoid.
But pre-integrating an asset management tool and service could allow these manufacturers to charge a higher price for their goods, and act as a valuable differentiator in the years before such a process becomes standard in the industry.
While we can’t be sure that Peltz’s experience is an anomaly, or at least uncommon, it is good to see some transparency from a business – especially when it involves admitting a mistake. RFID asset management has huge potential in the retail and logistics sector, and stands to account for multiple billions of IoT devices. As such, if Peltz isn’t at fault, its openness should hopefully ensure that its problems can be solved, and hopefully help other businesses thinking of adopting RFID.
A year into the project, Peltz reported that the system had saved it some 1,500 man-hours labor and noticeably improved its customer service. A wheeled-cart was used to capture and track the inventory levels of its stores and warehouses, and feed the data into a system that could automate replenishment of popular items and phase out unpopular ones. It seems that expanding to the current six physical locations from the four used in 2009 may have been the root cause of the issue. A 1-year progress report from Peltz can be read here.