Our usual annual catchup with the Industrial Internet Consortium (IIC) takes place at MWC, but obviously, this was not to be the case this year. Instead, President of the Object Management Group (OMG, the organization that houses the IIC), Bill Hoffman, who also holds that title in the IIC, took our call, to give us the lay of the land.
Now, the biggest takeaway came much later in our discussion, but it is worth stressing at the top. In all of the testbeds that the IIC runs, which then feed into reference documentation and architectures that can be used by members to advance the collective IIoT, not a single one is using 5G technologies. The testbeds are very aware of the technology, but none see any business value in implementing it.
This popped up when we asked Hoffman about how the organization gets the word out about the success of the testbeds, where he noted that C-Level types are looking for proof that there investments will pay off, and that they want to effectively see the whole product in action before committing.
So, the testbeds work on their chosen focus area, most concerned with industrial factories, where things are not moving, and therefore have no need for the mobility aspects that the 5G ecosystem likes to harp on about. Hoffman said that to this end, you do not need 5G, and therefore any impact the technology has on the sector is going to be years away. He noted that there is currently an expectation that 5G is going to solve problems, but thinks that this belief isn’t going to win out in the long run.
This is only emphasized by the fact that the testbeds are ahead of the curve, typically pushing the envelope in their choice of technologies to play with. Therefore, the absence of 5G is very apparent, and as far as Hoffman can tell, there’s not exactly any rush to see how it plays with the current box of toys.
Another notable takeaway was the status of the Trusted IoT Alliance, a group set up to explore how to use blockchain in the IoT that we were pretty skeptical of from the off. Unsurprisingly, given that it launched in 2017 when the tide was turning against blockchain enthusiasm, the alliance seemed doomed to fail, and so the IIC absorbed it a couple of months ago.
The IIC has much better reach, and already has the supporting and development infrastructure needed to pull off what the TIoTA was trying to do. Similarly, there was sufficient membership overlap to make the merger easy to pull off, with Dirk Slama of Bosch (an IIC member) now representing the TIoTA on the IIC board.
After the merger, some of the TIoTA projects have been rolled into IIC testbeds, but all have a focus on using private blockchains – and not a single public ledger for all IoT vendors. We mentioned the IOTA Foundation as being a better candidate for that goal, something that Hoffman agreed with, although both noted that the ongoing IOTA Tangle outage was not a good look.
As for the current state of the IoT, behind the curve that most predicted, Hoffman said that the industry had unrealistic expectations – that solving hard problems with difficult solutions takes a while, and is only complicated by multivendor jurisdictional environments. However, Hoffman stressed that this wasn’t a new thing; that he had seen the same journey take place when he was at Symbolics, an AI computing specialist, back in the Eighties.
At the time, it was clear that business plans were never close to reality, and in the current era, the IIC has focused on publishing white papers and reference architectures that show that the IoT is not a panacea – that it takes longer than expected but that it is very achievable.
In the past year, Hoffman has seen a number of members rejig their business plans, and the emergence of some return-on-investment numbers has been promising to see. However, there’s a risk that once promising approaches are found, members will get quiet, as they realize they now have a competitive advantage and don’t want to talk about it much. As such, the IIC ensures that it gets the word out, as much as it can, to get the ball rolling.
This brings us on to the recently published testbed results compilation paper, which outlines the findings of each of the pilots – warts and all. We asked what were the most surprising elements discovered, with Hoffman saying that it was still the case that a high level of trust, usually backed by some sort of legal contract, was needed. This is mostly due to the continued need for partnerships, as it is very hard for a single company to pull of a digital transformation on its own. The tension in creating and reconciling business value was also prominent, in terms of calculating accurate RoI figures.
As for the main themes in the testbeds, there were several common horizontal challenges. Getting a project off the ground, specifically getting management to approve funds for an IIoT investment was most prominent, and dealing between the cultural and human differences between IT and OT was cited too.
Human factors were also named, mostly relating to managing expectations regarding risks, as well as fears about job relevance – automating themselves out of a job. There were also a number of other typical roadblocks found, such as choosing the best technology, resource constraints, uncertain timelines, trying to implement trials in live production environments, integrations, and dealing with analytics models.