GigaEurope is the new brand for CableEurope, and like other cable-focused bodies like the US-based R&D arm CableLabs, it will extend its remit to cover a broader range of telecoms platforms and services as its members also become more heterogeneous. At its online rebranding event last week, the idea was to have influential policymakers and operators outline a vision for how private-public investments and industry consolidation will spearhead superfast speeds. Technical issues that almost led to the event being abandoned all but hampered those plans, leaving us to pick up crumbs of information about Europe’s potential giga-policies from the remaining time.
We see no coincidence that organizers placed members of the European Parliament and European Commission alongside executives from VodafoneZiggo and Telenet, given the recent comments from Liberty Global CEO Mike Fries, describing a potential cross-country merger between the two operators as having “compelling logic”. We can see Telenet being rolled into VodafoneZiggo as the first act of consolidation that GigaEurope and its members will pursue.
Jeroen Bronselaer, CEO of Telenet, defended consolidation by arguing that in Belgium, there are three MNOs and a plethora of MVNOs, describing it as a “quite vibrant market” with a robust HFC (hybrid fiber-coaxial) access regime and a strong investment-focused incumbent (Telenet).
“We benefit from a lot of density here and can deliver the same service to a regional rural customer as a city customer. If we do take a platform-agnostic and technology-agnostic approach, we’re seeing emerging technologies – particularly in wireless – that can overcome the tyranny of distance. It’s important that the market be allowed to work in this area. We’ve been able to strike interesting public-private partnerships,” said Bronselaer.
Pushing for a democratic approach was a consistent theme throughout GigaEurope event, as operators like Telenet and its parent Liberty Global, as well as the Dutch joint venture VodafoneZiggo, repeatedly emphasized their desire to work more closely with governments and local regulators. This collaboration, and ultimately cross-country consolidation, GigaEurope claims, is pivotal to building the networks that will define the next decade.
Anthony Wheelan – a digital policy adviser for the Cabinet of European Commission President von der Leyen – was on the panel. His view was that the role of public funds is not just to top up the pot when investments are insufficient, and so future network upgrades should pursue public-private partnership approaches.
“An awful lot of public authorities can do things to make the investment case easier and reduce the cases where public money is needed to close the gap. We do need progressive updates of networks, preferably before demand accumulates,” declared Wheelan.
Circling back to the recurring theme of consolidation, he added: “We apply the same rules to consolidation and try to apply rules to the facts. It is always easier to do consolidation across borders from a competition point of view, but for those cases where companies are looking for in-country consolidation, we have seen that the European Commission is scrupulous in looking at whether the competitive landscape is sustainable. Where it concludes that is not the case, then it draws a conclusion from that.”
VodafoneZiggo CEO Jeroen Hoencamp was waving the flag for mobile on the GigaEurope panel in a similar vein to his Telenet counterpart – with whom he might be working more closely if Liberty Global CEO Mike Fries gets his way on a Dutch-Belgian merger. “We have three nationwide mobile networks and two nationwide fixed networks. We need incumbents and challengers to invest,” he said. “The Dutch model has proven to be effective. We are delivering 100Mbps down to virtually all households and we are close to delivering targets set by 2023 today. Going forward, it’s very important to be regulation and technology-agnostic. This is not about fiber or 5G, this is about different technologies together.”
On the fixed side, Hoencamp added that VodafoneZiggo is “very capable” of rolling out gigabit infrastructure to cover the whole of the Netherlands in 12-18 months via HFC network upgrades, though technology detail on such upgrades was non-existent.
However, Hoencamp admitted there could be challenges in GigaEurope’s technology-agnostic approach, with particular concern on the mobile side due to there being more regulatory uncertainty in the wireless sector, and therefore a lack of investment security.
Hoencamp voiced his exasperation at countries, including the Netherlands, lagging behind on making spectrum available that is seen as crucial for increasing 5G network speeds, specifically the 3.5 GHz band that will be auctioned off in the Netherlands in 2022. “Are countries on track to acquire spectrum? No. The Netherlands was too late. To be able to drive speeds that 3.5 GHz mobile can drive, this spectrum needs to be unlocked,” declared Hoencamp.
Back on the fixed network side, Telenet’s Bronselaer is not convinced that regulators have their priorities right when it comes to fiber infrastructure, as he credited the core cable infrastructure for being the hero of 2020, despite the apparent technology agnosticism that GigaEurope is driving.
“We’ve been able to reallocate and refarm capacity for upstream, which is something that emerged from the lockdown period. It is clear that HFC upgraders have a roadmap that takes us well into the future, and we are looking at 2.5Gbps speeds into 2025 and beyond. Certainly, local regulators have been over-enamored with fiber, while HFC has really delivered in this time,” continued Bronselaer.
Bronselaer added that national regulators have received good guidance from the European Union on various important transactions, but, in the case of Belgium, he claims differential regional regulation is hindering the opportunity to move forward in 5G. “We have a role to play beyond getting a signal to the modem – and we will continue to double down on that responsibility as we move forward,” he concluded.