Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 October 2005

Google and EarthLink bring internet model to municipal telecoms

The booming US metrozone market is starting to attract major players from the internet space, alongside the traditional wireless ISPs. Internet service provider EarthLink, for instance, has won the contract to build the Philadelphia citywide network, and now search engine giant Google is bidding to create a free hotzone for San Francisco.

A city network with free access for residents has been demanded for the past year by Mayor Gavin Newsom, who sees internet access as a ‘human right’. However, progress has been slow, with the city facing the normal dilemmas that afflict plans for municipal roll-outs ‘ how to fund and run them. Google would address that by building the network and funding it through advertising, offering a best effort service of 300Kbps, which should not be too taxing on the likely equipment, 802.11g Wi-Fi mesh.

Google’s proposal rests on installing 20-30 access points per square mile, on lamp posts, which would offer access to 95% of the city outdoors and 90% indoors. This is estimated to cost $15m-$20m to build.

Google says it will create the network with no charge to residents or the city, with revenue coming from advertising using its AdSense program for placing web-based, contextual ads. The search specialist would also provide authentication services using its recently released Google Secure Access, a free VPN client designed for hotspots. And it will use the network to test other services, such as its mapping functions for location-aware search ‘ a route also being explored by Microsoft.

Google already sponsors free Wi-Fi in San Francisco with partner Feeva in Union Square, as well around its Mountain View headquarters close by. It also sponsors free access in New York City’s Bryant Park, leading to speculation that it would seek to do a similar deal there, something that the company denied. However, rumors have been circulating for almost a year that Google eventually aims to create a national wireless service, using Wi-Fi or even WiMAX for the last mile and hotspots. These were fuelled last year when it started buying up unused fiber capacity, which would serve as backhaul.

The moves by internet portal players into offering free or low cost wireless services, to bolster their brands and the range of services with which to secure subscribers, presents a major challenge for the established telcos. Recently, eBay bought free VoIP player Skype and Microsoft expanded its own moves into VoIP services for MSN. And in other areas where Google has launched free consumer offerings, such as its Gmail email service, it has stolen significant share from paid-for alternatives. Google has a market capitalization of $88bn, close to Verizon’s, but generates nearly all its revenue – $3.2bn last year – from its AdSense small advertisements. This is a very different model from that of the telcos, although with their business customer base and licensed spectrum holdings, they can fight back with quality services far superior to a 300Kbps best effort approach.

However, a company like Google with the cash and the ad-driven revenue potential to offer a municipal service at no cost to the city or the end user would be an effective way to get round state legislation that bars municipalities from offering tax-subsidized services on the basis of unfair competition with the telcos. And as such, Google should have a strong advantage in any city where it chooses to bid. The municipal networks would, in turn, give the search engine company a toehold in the service provider sector, and a chance to expand the reach of its adverts and, importantly, add in location awareness to those ads so that visitors to a city are greeted with relevant advertising about local attractions.

Speaking on Monday, Mayor Newsom, who became famous for last year’s campaign to legalize gay marriage in San Francisco, said he considers wireless internet access to be a ‘fundamental right of all citizens’ and that he is ‘bracing for a battle with telephone and cable interests, along with state and US regulators’.

He said that, since announcing intentions to create a free hotzone last year, he had received 24 proposals, including Google’s, plus one from EarthLink, the victor in Philadelphia and with a strategy to create metrozones in a many major cities as possible; and another from cellco Cingular Wireless. Other bidders included hotzone start-up Metro-Fi, and many equipment vendors including giants like Ericsson, Motorola and Nortel, plus specialists like Alvarion, WiLine and Gigabeam.

The successful bidder is likely to be named within six months.

As San Francisco was announcing the bidders for its metrozone project, Philadelphia was making public the winner of its own contract, to build and run a city network that has become the most high profile in the ongoing conflict over municipal Wi-Fi.

EarthLink has won the deal, and a significant boost to its ambitions to become a major metrozone player in order to diversify its revenue streams and bolster its brand. From an initial shortlist of 12, the ISP had been left in contention with just one other, Hewlett-Packard.

It will be the prime contractor, using mesh equipment from Tropos and Motorola Canopy for backhaul. Its scheme will include a revenue share with the Wireless Philadelphia non-profit organization, which should save the city $10m-$15m, according to city CIO Dinah Neff. EarthLink will also put up the initial financing for the network, whose build-out is expected by Neff’s office to cost around $10m.

The revenue stream will help Wireless Philadelphia subsidize low income families to receive access at around $10 a month. It is estimated that 42-55% of the city has no internet access at all and 174,000 households have just dial-up, which is now priced by Verizon at $15 a month.

EarthLink recently created a municipal wireless division, aiming to enter most of the major US cities where metrozones are planned, and it has also submitted a bid to supply the San Francisco TechConnect system, in competition with Google.

The company is positioning itself as a municipal Wi-Fi service provider and manager that will deploy and maintain the network in return for offerings its broadband services to the inhabitants of the city. This would be particularly appropriate in areas where cable rather than DSL is the dominant wireline access method, since EarthLink has few partnerships among the cable providers.

“We think we can play a vital role in helping these cities,” Garry Betty, CEO of EarthLink, said. “It would be a way for us to augment our offerings for consumers and not be so beholden to broadband network operators.’