Earlier this month we saw Qualcomm responding aggressively to antitrust claims by its major rivals, and extending its patent royalty claims from its traditional CDMA platforms to GSM. Never a company to take the safest path, the chipmaker followed up that daring attempt to broaden its intellectual property revenue base with another act of defiance, reiterating claims that it would see royalties on the Chinese 3G technology, TD-SCDMA, which is heavily backed by the country’s authorities and expected to be adopted by at least one operator when 3G licenses are awarded next year.
There is a far clearer intellectual property trail from TD-SCDMA to Qualcomm than there is from the GSM data mechanics over which the US company is suing Nokia, but the statements – coming at a time when the eyes of the mobile world and the EU and US antitrust authorities are firmly on Qualcomm’s patent policies ‘ are provocative, given that China, like Korea, is seeking to reduce its dependence on paying royalties to western vendors in general and Qualcomm in particular. This is one reason why China has been so keen to create homegrown standards.
‘We definitely have essential patents in TD-SCDMA, just like in all CDMA related technologies. We have 60 licensees worldwide for TD-SCDMA and W-CDMA, although we don’t have any licensees in China on TD-SCDMA,’ said Frank Meng, president of Qualcomm China. ‘Once it gets to the stage of commercialization, then we will work with the Chinese companies to get licensing agreements.’
Yang Hua, secretary-general of the TD-SCDMA Industry Alliance, said he believes that its members own ‘most of the core and essential IP’ needed in TD-SCDMA, and those patents have been cross-licensed among members. Johan Pross, CEO of T3G, a TD-SCDMA chip company backed by Philips, Motorola and Samsung, believes one of the key advantages of the platform for Chinese operators will be that it will almost certainly involve far lower levels of royalty payments than CDMA did in China.
Amid all the political manoeuvring around intellectual property, it is easy to forget that Qualcomm is not a patent hoader but one of the most creative companies in silicon, with its famous patent store largely built on genuine innovations. It continually refreshes its technology program with an eye to supporting new services that will keep the operator profitable and loyal to the CDMA platform. Last week saw the latest roadmaps for CDMA200 EV-DO and for Qualcomm’s implementation of HSDPA outlined, showing what customers could expect up to 2010, a critical time point at which EV-DO and HSDPA could be expected to be coming near the end of their investment cycles and broadband wireless or 4G technologies starting to gain the upper hand ‘ with or without Qualcomm in an influential role.
Qualcomm says its two new platforms are based on three aspects ‘ standards-based enhancements to CDMA2000 and W-CDMA, as defined by the 3GPP2 and 3GPP bodies; its own techniques for improving capacity and speed, which do not require
changes to current or proposed standards; and chips and software to enable multiple radio links, including OFDM and CDMA, to work concurrently and in a way that is backward compatible with existing equipment.
‘Qualcomm’s DMMX and HMMX platforms encompass an array of advancements being made in CDMA and a broad range of other wireless technologies, enabling operators to expand their service offerings to support consumer desires while improving their business models,’ was how Qualcomm’s recently elevated CEO Paul Jacobs described the new roadmaps. ‘Consumers may not care about the technologies underlying the amazing new services they want on their phones, but to deliver these services profitably, the wireless operator does.’
Qualcomm knows that such an outcome will increasingly depend on mixing different networks rather than hoping carriers will remain CDMA-only forever, and it will integrate GPS, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and OFDM audio/video encoding into all its technologies in a bid to ensure it retains its influence even in a multi-protocol world. The goal is multitasking convergence that allows simultaneous multiband, multifunction operation ‘ for instance, GPS tracking, internet mapping software and a phone call could happen at once, plus VoIP and Web-based groupware functions.
So while DMMX (DO Multicarrier Multilink extensions) and HMMX (HSDPA Multicarrier Multilink extensions) promise many enhancements such as improved price/performance and raw data rates, and better battery life and voice quality, much of Qualcomm’s focus was on how they could be combined with these other. It noted that, for instance, a signal from its OFDM-based MediaFLO TV system, transmitted in the 700MHz band, could be combined with an EV-DO reverse link, while HSDPA could be used with assisted GPS. ‘As more features converge in handsets, more radio links will have to operate concurrently to support them,’ said the company ‘ a statement that shows exactly why it needs to broaden its technical base with moves like the acquisition of Flarion and creation of MediaFLO, and also its intellectual property reach.
The key feature of DMMX and HMMX is to use multiple transmission protocols in multiple frequency bands, simultaneously, and Revision B of EV-DO will support multiple carriers to increase peak data rates, and scalable bandwidth. The latter enables a carrier to bond multiple 1.25MHz CDMA channels over contiguous or non-contiguous spectrum channels of up to 20MHz. This will result in huge speed increases ‘ Revision B specifies a download speed, from the network to the terminal, of up to 73.5Mbps and an upload speed of 27Mbps, according to the industry alliance supporting it, the CDMA Devlopment Group. Current EV-DO networks support download rates of around 2.4Mbps and Revision A, which will be deployed next year, will increase this to 3.1Mbps.
This is a clear strike against scalable bandwidth broadband wireless, supporting WiMAX-size channels and high peak data rates for applications such as video on demand, and would support operators gaining new spectrum allocations with wider bandwidths in future.
The detailing of the enhancements for EV-DO and HSDPA may serve to remind the world that Qualcomm will be aggressive about expanding its technology base as well as its patent portfolio, but its success as a chip vendor outside the CDMA platform is less assured than its ability to collect royalties ‘ but more crucial to its future. Last week the company’s president, Steve Altman, in an interview with Dow Jones, admitted the company needed to sign up a tier one handset maker if it is to have a chance of meeting its self-imposed targets of 50% market share in W-CDMA.
“It will be difficult. There’s a lot of competition,” he said. Such comments may have been partly designed for the antitrust regulators’ ears, reminding them that Qualcomm does not have a near-monopoly position in the broader 3G market, but they also reflect a major challenge to the chipmaker’s hopes of maintaining its current growth and value. According to IDC, the company had only 6.9% market share in W-CDMA chips last year, behind most of the companies, notably Texas Instruments, that are suing it. However, this situation will improve for Qualcomm, particularly when Vodafone goes ahead with plans to launch six 3G handsets based on the company’s silicon. Samsung and LG do use Qualcomm chips, but it is not their primary supplier for W-CDMA.
By showing off such an advanced 3G roadmap, Qualcomm will hope to generate new interest in its chips from major handset and infrastructure makers. It also shows a company that, despite its CDMA heritage, is adapting quickly to the shift to multiple networks and is demonstrating its habitual insight into operator needs.