The time has come for the global telecoms industry to separate the short and long term impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic on traffic levels and demand for given services. Some indicators have come from financial results and statements issued by leading players, such as infrastructure conglomerate CommScope, which has just posted a mixed bag of figures for its Q3 2020.
With over 20,000 employees CommScope has become a major force in network infrastructure even if it is a long way behind say Cisco, having grown up in copper and fiber optic cabling since its formation in 1976. It entered wireless almost through the backdoor through its $7.4bn acquisition of the Arris Group announced November 2018, which had earlier acquired Ruckus Wireless for $800m. This has given CommScope a strong position in WiFi, particularly for venue and campus networks, which has led to significant efforts to help operators of these withstand the battering of their business by the Covid-19 pandemic.
CommScope Q3 revenues were $2.16bn, down 8.9% year-on-year but up 3.1% sequentially over Q2, reflecting the pandemic’s profile with some bounce back after initial lockdowns. On this basis Q4 would be in the balance because the impact of renewed lockdowns in many European countries would be offset by economic recovery as measures are relaxed in a number of major Asia Pacific economies.
Of greater interest here were some of the nuances relating to campus and venue deployments of WiFi. Net sales in CommScope’s venue and campus networks business division were $511.8m for Q3, down just 2.4% over the same three months of 2019 and in that case almost entirely due to decline in the indoor copper enterprise unit. These were almost offset by growth in the WiFi 6 business, which in Q3 accounted for 25% of all access point (AP) sales, driven by a rise in indoor traffic.
But the firm noted with some justification that sales to venues and campuses held up surprisingly well given the collapse in revenues resulting from absence of large gatherings and also switch towards home working. CommScope believes that this in part reflected efforts it has made to help large venues in particular prepare for a return to normality through various actions both to comply with possible measures and restore confidence among their audiences, customers or visitors. Such measures come under four headings.
First is the connectivity itself, which must be robust, flexible and scalable to the possible traffic levels that could be generated by a larger crowd. CommScope believes that 5G is not ready for that yet and so requires a combination of WiFi and wired connectivity for backhaul or redundancy, configured with both low latency and high availability in mind.
Second come sensors and other mechanisms for capturing relevant data, such as infra-red readings of body temperature and distribution of people around the ground, with a range of inputs required to monitor behavior of groups and individuals within a crowd. There may also be sensors for air quality, tracking of relevant assets, and geofencing, as well as contactless payment systems.
Extending from this is the third category – location and analytics systems harnessing both local and cloud based machine learning to adapt to changing situations, possibly exploiting low power IoT wireless protocols such as Zigbee and BLE (Bluetooth Low Energy) alongside WiFi. These could add value by complementing WiFi, or for that matter 5G, in various ways. For example, BLE can be used with hardware transmitters called beacons that enable ultra-local applications, such as sending messages relevant just to a given area of a venue within the proximity of particular restaurant, stand or seating zone.
The fourth category of venue technology promoted by CommScope is application software feeding off analytics for higher level decision making or management processes, for example to notify venue operators of impending issues. These could in the first instance be Covid-related processes, such as monitoring for congestion and conformance to distancing guidelines, with ability to issue warnings within the ground when thresholds are breached. Such thresholds could take account of duration people are within given distances of each other, as well as densities.
Some venues may be reckoning this sort of application will become a permanent requirement. More generally, enterprises of all kinds, as well as mobile service providers, want to know just which changes in consumer behavior and data traffic profiles are transient and which are permanent, with shades in between. The most comprehensive study we have seen so far taking account of how these have evolved over the course of the pandemic and not just at the beginning, was published in October 2020 for the Internet Measurement Conference (‘The Lockdown Effect: Implications of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Internet Traffic’. In Internet Measurement Conference (IMC ’20), October 27–29, 2020, Virtual Event, USA https://doi.org/10.1145/3419394.3423658)
This is an annual conference focusing on Internet measurement and analysis, sponsored by the Association for Computing Machinery’s (ACM) special interest groups on Data Communications, and Measurement and Evaluation, in conjunction with USENIX, an association supporting operating system research.
This study took as a starting point the now well-known observation that overall data traffic volumes rose by 15% to 20% in the first week of widespread global lockdowns in March 2020. This growth was disproportionately focused on sectors associated with home working or social activity, such as residential fixed broadband coupled with WiFi, as well as on associated applications like web conferencing, VPNs and gaming.
Conversely, some enterprise and academic networks experienced steep declines in traffic, except for those parts associated with remote working or distance learning.
The study then probed deeper and considered how the average user’s profile had changed, both temporarily and permanently, defined in terms of bandwidth usage, communications medium and traffic destination. This has evolved constantly over the history of personal communications during the mobile era, but accelerated since lockdowns began.
It shifted for example from peer to peer applications entirely over fixed lines in the early 2000s to content delivery and then streaming applications in the 2010s. More recently in the later 2010s it has slanted towards mobile applications, both cellular and over WiFi backed up by fixed broadband. Then Covid-19 has without doubt exerted a once in a generation impact on Internet user behavior.
The ACM study points out that the Internet as a whole stood up well to an onslaught compressed in time from years to a few weeks, although its assertion that this was unexpected is debatable. One reason the Internet stood up was that the traffic was more evenly spread out in a “weekend” pattern. At normal times, weekday traffic tends to follow a workday pattern where residentially it peaks in the evening.
But after lockdowns, traffic shifted towards a continuous weekend pattern with momentum growing steadily towards 9am to 10am and then being sustained around that level most of the day. Had traffic instead still been concentrated in the evening, the Internet probably would have failed to cope, along with many broadband networks feeding it. Some relief was also afforded by major streamers such as Netflix cutting their video resolutions from HD to standard definition.
The study then found that as pandemic countermeasures were widely relaxed in May 2020, this weekend-like pattern became less dominant during weekdays, but crucially some of those changes persisted. Levels of traffic for remote working and education, including VPN and videoconferencing, remained at around triple the levels seen before the pandemic with a particularly steep increase upstream. There has also been a switch from what the study calls ‘hyper-giant’ traffic generated by the Internet and streaming giants towards emerging applications associated with remote working, such as Zoom and Microsoft Teams.
Apart from the obvious recommendation that traffic engineering should take account of a permanent shift towards more symmetric traffic less biased towards the Internet giants, one conclusion was that while the Internet did hold up well, this was not always the case in remote regions and also developing nations where fixed broadband coverage is poor. That is why 5G can be expected to come strongly into the picture.