The agreed merger announced a few days ago between T-Mobile US and Sprint is a blessing in disguise to the US cellular market, and at Faultline Online Reporter we think it will go through regulators almost unopposed.
Hilariously, when we called the AT&T Mobility merger with T-Mobile as anti-competitive in 2011, most US publications laughed at us and told us it was “a done deal,” and public markets were shocked when AT&T was rebuffed by regulators and had to shell out $6 billion in cash and spectrum to T-Mobile, in a move that fueled T-Mobile with renewed competitiveness and led to the Uncarrier strategy that has proved so successful.
But as this was announced, all the US news outlets this week focused on the idea that regulators might castrate the deal, restricting it dramatically with “remedies” to protect consumer pricing, so that it is almost not worth doing. We feel that this is unlikely to happen and there is strong reasoning here.
Had AT&T merged with T-Mobile back in 2011, it would have created a “de facto” market leader in cellular revenues, numbers of subscribers and profits, attached to a company that already had US strength, if not dominance, in fixed line broadband and telephony.
That would have left three tiers of cellular players, with AT&T at the top, and Verizon playing catch up and Sprint unlikely to survive, especially as it has almost no fixed line access to build backhaul on. This new deal does nothing of the sort. Instead it puts all three businesses on a cellular level playing field at just over 100 million customers apiece, with AT&T the largest, but only by dint of its DirecTV acquisition and its long lines business, and 16 million broadband customers.
Verizon has neglected its broadband business for the past decade and as such it needs a shot in the arm here, installing some fiber, but not everywhere and ignoring the rest. And it has been talking about buying Charter as a basis for better fixed line access, a deal which is now definitively off after Charter has partnered with Comcast on cellular.
Those MVNO deals with cable, cut by Verizon also makes the US cellular market healthier, and provides the “fourth force” which regulators everywhere are keen to see in place – so far Sprint has filled that role. A report this week suggests that most Comcast customers were for the most part previously Verizon customers, a fact that will slowly deplete the Verizon share price, as predicted by us, but which will also fuel a sense that the US does not need 4 competing cellular players, but it now has a fifth force with the two cable players.
Now we are starting to see the conditions for the move that everyone has felt was unthinkable – Verizon falling into the partial control of both Comcast and Charter, by dint of a huge share swap and shares purchase to cement the MVNO partnerships – complete with seats on boards and a combined strategy – but without a full takeover to present regulators with more opportunities to intervene. It was one of our long-term predictions over a year ago.
The two big voices then which will be against the Sprint T-Mobile merger might be AT&T and Verizon. It’s bad enough having an eager rival like T-Mobile which is half the size, creating market havoc, without having someone that can represent just as big a voice in 5G as they each currently have.
Any voices against the deal will suggest that it will lead to decreased competition and higher consumers prices, when they know that this means “increased” cellular competition and a more rapid race to the floor in pricing – all good for the consumer. AT&T may in fact see the writing on the wall and come out in favor of the deal, knowing that it will tie T-Mobile management up on a transition of many Sprint customers to the T-Mobile network, and lead to a period when T-Mobile management will be at a disadvantage over jobs, terms and conditions to customers, and a temporary period of increased churn as customers settle down post-merger.
In the end AT&T has the content through both DirecTV and Time Warner, if that deal goes ahead, and will feel less threatened by an enlarged T-Mobile than Verizon.
The two test hurdles are does it create a “monopoly” with pricing power (Department of Justice) and is it in the public interest (FCC) – and we think that if they look at the alternative, with Sprint failing and being reduced to 3 operators anyway, those regulators will see this as the best of all outcomes.
This then raises concern of what will be the next round of maneuvers, whereby the combined T-Mobile Sprint will need fixed line support, which it may achieve though fixed wireless – currently a strong plank in both AT&T and Verizon’s 5G roll-out, or which may be achieved by chasing Comcast and Charter, who can then pick who they partner with, out of Verizon and T-Mobile for the long term. Of course, Altice has already chosen its MVNO partner in Sprint and it will fall to the T-Mobile side of that divide.
An issue will also be content, and T-Mobile has shown its willingness to partner and acquire around content, through its Layer 3 TV purchase, but will remain at a disadvantage for some time to come. We’re sure they will revisit the acquisition of Dish Network, but we feel that T-Mobile’s CEO John Legere is more likely to build out TV offerings which are “Mobile First.”