Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 May 2011

Liberty’s bid for Barnes & Noble may not be entirely financial

Over the weekend John Malone’s Liberty Media owned Liberty Capital pounced on Barnes and Noble, the financially stressed book store group, which has put itself up for sale. The bid offer ludicrously values B&N at just $1 billion, but that’s been the going rate for anyone that has considered bidding for it ‘ despite its sales running at $2.3 billion for the last quarter. A more likely stock market value if the company had positive cash flow would be $6 billion or $8 billion, less debt.

The problem is that B&N is juggling its finances in order to try to stay alive, and has just exchanged on a $1 billion credit facility which will reduce financing costs by around $10 million a year. Every penny seems to count, but everyone who is watching the company sees it as more valuable once it is out of trouble, and especially in light of its Nook Color ebook reader strategy.

In February, Barnes & Noble reported total sales of $2.3 billion for its fiscal third quarter 2011, a 7% increase compared to the same quarter of 2010. Bookstore sales for the quarter were up 7%, but Barnes and Noble.com online ebook sales were up some 64%. It is expected that B&N could become a serious alternative to Amazon and Apple in the online book market, as long as it can survive, and can partner outside of the US.

Interestingly this offer from Liberty Media is contingent on the chairman and founder Leonard Riggio staying onboard and keeping his minority holding. This sounds very much as if it is a genuine white knight offer, designed to make money for Malone and rid Riggio of corporate raiders which have hounded the stock for the past few years. If Riggio keeps all his shares, then Liberty will own 70% of the company.

Ever since 2008 B&N has been harassed by the corporate venturer Ronald Burkle through a group called the Yucaipa Funds, which has been built a stock position in an attempt to take the company over. In the end B&N chose to adopt a poison pill defense which expires in 2012, which keeps the Yucaipa holding under 20%. Yucaipa was buying in an environment where B&N valued at way under $1 billion.

Burkle says clearly that he wants to seek mergers and eliminate assets to get shareholder benefit out of B&N. Back in December hedge fund entrepreneur
William Ackman and his investment fund Pershing Square Capital Management, which has built a 38% position in Borders, offered to buy out B&N and merge it with Borders at $16 a share. That offer has simply gone quiet and perhaps was never formally made and the money was simply piled into Borders to get the capital into it. That deal was also supposed to leave Leonard Riggio, who bought the company back in 1971, in the management seat, with his stock intact.

A merged Borders and B&N would have almost $10 billion in revenues with Borders contributing $2 billion of that, plus 679 US stores and B&N closing in on $8 billion with 717 retails stores and 633 college based book stores. While that might add buying power, it does little to accelerate the transition from physical book stores to an electronic giant. It simply doubles the size of the retail problem, the diminishing side of the business, potentially tying to bricks together and asking ‘Now can they float.’ Amazon, by comparison, is on track for a $30 billion year and hasn’t got a single shop.

So perhaps Malone, by offering $17 a share is trying to save B&N from this fate, somewhat akin to being a book version of Blockbuster.

The company has yet to respond and is considering whether or not to recommend the deal to shareholders. From a shareholder point of view this is the company’s best offer yet, and it may not be bettered, but the fact that multiple bidders are involved, may act like a beacon, attracting more bidders to the fight. That’s what investors thought, and the stock jumped to almost $2 above the offer price on the news.

Other bidders are seen as more natural than Liberty and commentators are quick to point out that Malone is a purely financial investor, smart and able to spot a deal but unlikely to merge his operations with those of B&N. There are others who might kill for an ebook operation and the new Nook Color which is a general purpose tablet. Google is the most awry suggestion we have heard, and we feel the same about the list of major retailers, headed by Sears, who have been associated with the deal. They would mistakenly see the strong retailer presence of B&N as its main asset, when in fact it is the Nook that will define its future. Google can hardly acquire its own Tablet now can it, especially after what happened with its own phones.

The new Microsoft Nokia alignment would make a very good home for B&N, which would need to drive the Nook internationally as part of its rebranded and merged portal assets. But what would it do with the management of all that real estate? And isn’t the Nook Color an Android device which relies on Android market?

The trouble with B&N right now is that it is worth so much more than these bids, as long as it is subsequently given access to cheap finance. And that makes it just as likely for a company to buy B&N for asset stripping or simple re-organization as for synergies which the buyer may have with its Nook strategy. So it will attract both sorts of bids and may not end up in the right hands for the company and continued success of Nook.

But we would argue that this might be a much bigger play for Liberty than say its 40% acquisition of Sirius XM satellite radio. The Sirius deal appeared on the surface very similar really, with Malone loaning $530 million to Sirius and paying just $12,500 for warrants to grant Liberty 40% of its equity. That equity today would be worth $3.5 billion on the current market capitalization of $8.7 billion.

There is still $326 million outstanding as debt and Liberty could, in any merger deal, convert that to equity at the current share price and take even more equity. It has agreed not to take more than 49.9% up until March 2012 unless it makes a cash tender offer for the entire thing. So far the two companies have not done any business together, and this is seen purely as a financial transaction ‘ parleying $580 million of debt into $3.5 billion of equity, and still getting your money back, is a great deal for any corporate juggler. But there remain possibilities that Malone will buy the rest of the company, and join up the media dots.

Sirius mostly carries radio, but it does carry some video. More spectrum might turn it into a full-on mobile video or mobile TV play and that may make it a genuine asset in distributing Liberty Media’s TV content. The fact that Liberty also owns DirecTV means that it already has a great outlet for content under its control, but in a future world of portable video devices, it is just as well for Liberty to control at least one route to market for video that can be adapted for portable devices ‘ either with broadcast video or with OTT video. Currently much of Sirius content is available OTT as well as through the air.

But if you have strategy for audio and for video why would you not go the whole hog and compete across the board with Apple’s iTunes and with Amazon and also add a capability for eBooks and potentially with the Nook, add a portable device which might be adapted for all three major content types, and Apps too. That way there is the potential for a real threat to Amazon and Apple down the road.

And by just owning financial control of both Sirius and, if it wins this deal, with Barnes and Noble, it can continue to justify on them purely on a financial basis but consider cross marketing between them all. A Sirius device that can read eBooks or a Nook that can play radio and some video, may well benefit Liberty. And a US video capable Android tablet may well work with the now financially unconnected, sister company Liberty Global, the European pay TV operator.

The retail aspect of B&N might present a problem, in that Malone has no experience running a retail footprint. But the potential for cross marketing, selling Liberty content, DirecTV subscriptions, as well as Sirius subscriptions and devices, as well as Books, might just provide enough rationale for outright owning all of these businesses.

All of which makes the bid on B&N interesting, and potentially another multi $billion financial play which could be triggered as part of a wider content equation at any point in the future.