Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 June 2011

Qualcomm Atheros has three way WiFi/WiGig chip first ‘ in samples now

The Atheros partnership with Intel Centrino refugee, Wilocity, announced last July has borne fruit far earlier than we expected, with chips ready for sampling, almost immediately, which have 2.4 GHz, 5.0 GHz and the Wilocity 60 GHz, all on a single device.

By putting all three channels together on a single chip, the AR9004TB, it means that video signals can deliver across a room at multi-gigabit data transfer speeds, while the traditional WiFi signals can still work around the whole home with devices like tablets, PCs and smartphones.

True to the what Atheros says it is typical approach of waiting for standards to come out and then jumping on them early, this could pose a dramatic question for all Consumer Electronics TV makers ‘ whether or not to offer 60GHz WiFi, usually referred to as WiGig, in their TVs. Most of them have publicly supported many standards for TV connectivity, with all of them supporting Ethernet, and Sony for instance also backing both Wireless HD and a rival standard from Amimon called WHDI (not in 60 GHz at all). It has also expressed some interest in WiGig, but nothing definitive.

So although there remains little clarity on which fixed line TV connectivity will win out in the global market with both MoCA and HPNA backed initiatives making ground, the wireless market seems poised for unanimity.

The critical decision was back in May when a variety of WiFi groups including WiGig, the WiFi Alliance and the 802.15.3c committee all agreed on a common standard in 60 GHz, a move which convinced WirelessHD player SiBeam to build a chip that supported both its WirelessHD signals and WiGig, effectively conceding that at least the market would be split.

By April SiBeam was sold off for a fraction of its investment costs for $25 million to Silicon Image, a company steeped in HDMI, clearly planning to use the 60 GHz head start SiBeam had to enter the TV wireless connectivity market.

Earlier this week Silicon Image came out with the SiI6300 a family of third generation 60 GHz chips (the first was Wireless HD only, the second had both Wireless HD and WiGig). This is both a transmitter and receiver set, supporting WirelessHD 1.1 features including 1080p/60, 36-bit Deep Color video and all 3D formats. So clearly it has not yet given up the ghost on WirelessHD, but could switch to WiGig at a moment’s notice if the market force it to.

This puts Silicon Image as the last holdout against WiGig and it’s going to come down to volumes and pricing eventually. Silicon Image says the SiI6300 family will be more cost-effective and lower power and a smaller form-factor. Each chipset will include a Network Processor and an RF Transceiver and there are two variants, one for PCs, notebooks and smartphones and another for Blu-ray players and digital TVs and projectors.

WirelessHD 1.1 offers a new medium rate PHY so the signal is more robust and a number of low rate PHY channels. The system offers a bi-directional 1Gbps data link.

‘Silicon Image continues to expand its 60GHz wireless solution for audio, video and now data transmission with robust third-generation, WirelessHD-compliant chipsets,’ said John LeMoncheck, vice president and general manager, wireless division at Silicon Image.

There are no indications yet of pricing, but if Atheros and other major WiFi adherents such as Broadcom, put the 60GHz WiGig capability into their generalized WiFi chip sets, price is never going to end up being a problem, though it might offer a glimmer of opportunity to Silicon Image to sway CE TV makers in the early market. That’s why it was so important that someone like Atheros got to market swiftly with its 3 channel WiFi chip including WiGig, which it figures will unseat this plan (see separate story).

The announcement of the Atheros WiGig chip disingenuously was described as having less interference problems than 2.4 GHz and 5.0 GHz, which is of course nonsense. All three are in unlicensed spectrum but in 2.4 GHz there is a problem that many other devices, including baby monitors and garage doors remote controls, sit in this spectrum. Because 2.4 GHz signals travel so far, for instance through concrete walls, this means other people using it can become an interference issue. Of course the reason this can’t happen in 60 GHz is that no signal that begins outside the room would get in, because it cannot penetrate walls. This is a big issue with 60 GHz as a person moving around a room will block the signal unless MIMO antennas are used with beamforming, so that a route can always be found to reach the receiving device. You would have to have two competing 60 GHz transmitters in a single room to have what Atheros describes as interference.

But in this issue lies the fundamental problem with devices built around 60 GHz ‘ they have to have a way of bringing signals into the room. That necessitates one of two things, either you terminate the broadband signal to the home in the same room as the home’s main TV set, or you offer devices which use backhaul.

That means that either WiFi is used for backhaul itself, which has problems with lost packets unless it has a specific bridge architecture which secures a couple of channels for itself, or it would need to rely on another backhaul. This is either a wired technology, so we come back to a choice of MoCA and HPNA or a powerline technology, so we come back to HomePlug versus G.hn.

That set of decisions often makes itself, where many pay TV operators are concerned, based on local prevalent building practices (can WiFi act as a home bridge or are the walls too thick) and the amount of Coax already installed in certain territories, as well as the quality and topology of power line cabling.

So what Atheros is really doing here is giving out a message to TV makers that it’s safe to install 60GHz receivers in TVs and kind of promising that down the road, with its preferred combination of Ethernet, MoCA and HomePlug AV, it will solve the rest of the home network issues, of how to get a video single to the living room and output it in 60 GHz to the TV.

It will be interesting to see IF any new device designs come out immediately with this chip in, and if so what other technologies they incorporate.

The fight for a home backbone may be between coaxial cable, twisted pair and power cables, and there may be a different winner on each continent, but we can’t help thinking they are playing for a smaller piece of the pie, once wireless signals within a room become resolved for carrying HD.

Atheros says that new fast session transfer technology in the AR9004TB will drive seamless transitions between multi-gigabit in-room performance to whole home wireless coverage. But to us, what it won’t do is delivery wireless HD signals in another room, without more of the puzzle being revealed.

In a way more of the puzzle has been revealed in the past few weeks by a very busy Atheros and all of it is going to be on show this week at Computex in Taipei, the annual jamboree for attracting Taiwanese and Chinese CE players to this technology or that.

First it has come up with a chip which is its first specialist video WiFi chip which use both 2.4 GHz and 5.0 GHz, optimized for video, as well as a software hardware combination called Hy-Fi, which supports the combination of Ethernet, HomePlug AV and WiFi, where the system can choose any of the three routes to deliver video ‘ effectively a seamless bridge which lets the video travel over the best HD route available at the time. (see separate story this week about Celeno).

But Atheros has to win over home gateway manufacturers to use these chips, as well as get Consumer Electronics business to incorporate the 60 GHz element inside their boxes. As we said before, that last step will rely on pricing of its 60 GHz chip versus those of Silicon Image, with its Wireless HD offering and we suspect that initially at least, this advantage may go to Silicon Image.

So in the Atheros world you can use HomePlug AV, MoCA or WiFi to deliver signals around the home and now that can be a seamless process for an equipment designer, and in the end the enterprise pull of WiGig may drive down chip costs to make it attractive as an all-purpose wireless medium, suitable for video. Qualcomm will not make the 60 GHz option available in battery constrained mobile devices, but will stick to bulk standard, low-power, WiFi, which of course the Atheros home network chips can still speak to.

But the management of such a network sounds like it is fraught will multiple points of failure and likely unexplained performance issues as data flows around a home from one protocol to another.

All of which may mean that Wireless HD or WHDI still have some legs in them as technologies while the world is being convinced of the Atheros position, and while device makers get themselves familiar with this new order.