Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

9 June 2011

EchoStar offers cablecos Aria hosted OTT service using Sling and Move

Charlie Ergen’s Dish Network and EchoStar Technologies just can’t keep out of the news, and after its recent dust up and settlement with TiVo and Dish’s sudden improvement in finances, it has decided to help out the world’s smaller cable operators by positioning a series of its product acquisitions and technology licenses as a way forward in the Over The Top world.

EchoStar may easily find some traction with its new Aria approach both among smaller cable operators in the US as well as in Europe, as it offers up an eco-system which takes in its freshly purchased right to build Time Shifting DVRs, with its twin acquisitions, Move Networks and Sling Media

The core of the strategy is that smaller cable companies haven’t got the resources to build a modern Content Delivery Network in the manner of Comcast, Verizon and Time Warner Cable, and this is a fair point. The old way of delivering VoD was haphazard and relied on satellite delivery of minimal video assets. These days, as these companies push on towards making perhaps 25,000 video assets available at any point in time, and making them available both through QAM based DOCSIS channels as well as through the internet. And to do that they have all invested hard in CDN infrastructures which pushe video to the edges of their networks, and servers which can deliver in either format.

Fitting this type of architecture into a multi-device world, where Tablets are becoming the order of the day, is a real challenge to the smaller cable operator, and failure to achieve it rapidly will put them at a huge disadvantage compared to larger rivals. It’s true that there are now copious suppliers in this market and they all talk about delivering from existing infrastructure, to the internet. Many of these focus on the content protection side of things in both environments, a difficult enough task on its own; others talk about multiple encode sizes and adaptive streaming technologies, while others still offer CDN software and server capability. Meanwhile set top makers the world over, and here EchoStar is as good as many, have the difficult task of developing DVRs which can store both types of program, and keep both safe, while allowing them to serve multiple device types.

In the larger cable operators they also have begun the task of taking
Recommendation engines, search and discovery systems to the cloud, based on remote servers, raising another hurdle for smaller rivals to cope with, not to mention they must also create navigation on multiple devices in the UI, as well as the CDN side of things we mentioned before.

While EchoStar will always be regarded with suspicion by major US cable operators, it has major advantages in its own chosen strategy which suit smaller pay TV operators. It owns the intellectual property of Move Networks which has just been granted a patent for adaptive streaming and will begin chasing technology suppliers and operators for a license to this technology.

The patent language describes it as, ‘the encoding and use of multiple bit rate “streamlets” with the same time index, such that the aggregate set of streamlets, stored on standard web servers, independently yield playback of the original full length video. This is accomplished through intelligent requests of successive unique optimal streamlets sent by a client device.’

At some point, if this patent holds up, and we think it is likely to, EchoStar will have a rich license stream and potentially two way patent exchanges with some of the major streaming companies, such as Apple, Microsoft and Google. But that’s a long legal journey and for now EchoStar needs to turn this acquisition to a profit and offering slick streaming technology to smaller cablers is a neat way ahead.

The same applies to Sling Media, EchoStar paid far more for this than it has ever attracted in sales and licenses, with a technology which works by taking content out through the analog hole, and re-encoding it onto an IP stream, and throwing it over broadband to wherever you want to view it, on whatever device.

Effectively this means it is probably the only player than can avoid a number of clear pinch points in its OTT strategy. An operator that uses this has no need to offer as second set of internet servers for content, or a software based, on the fly translation, from existing servers to IP based protocols, because that can all happen in any EchoStar supplied DVR which has Sling capabilities. It happens in the home, not on a hosted server.

Content can come over the original cable route to the QAM device, and then be sent out around the home, or to remote locations using WiFi and broadband, as adaptive streams. Initially Dish used Widevine technology for this, and may persist with this, but now it owns Move it has its own streaming technology and may continue to use Widevine only for IP content protection, though it could opt for any number of systems.

So VoD can be delivered in a single format, and then distributed from the home, and this prevents another issue for these cablecos, their server traffic cannot be intercepted if it travels over a rival broadband network, by simply identifying its origin, because the video appears to anyone who carries it as encrypted user uploaded content.

Also these smaller cable operators will have none of the hassle that Time Warner Cable and Cablevision had when they have streamed content from central servers over the internet without fresh content licenses ‘ because with placeshifting, it’s not the operator doing it, it’s the user, and in the US this is protected under fair use law because they are only sending it over the internet to themselves. And besides, given Dish Network’s takeover of the Blockbuster assets, and its closeness to its sister company EchoStar, there is perhaps more clout here for negotiating content permissions, and potentially localized cross selling arrangements to be made using Blockbuster stores for local small cable operators.

There is also another possibility, and this is already part of the declared Aria product set, with EchoStar can helping with processing in the cloud for things like search, recommendation, content discovery, integration with social networks and anything else that sits better on a remote server. EchoStar has some of its own skills here, but will, post legal action, begin talking to TiVo, in our view the master of this technology, about potential areas where they might work together and that might add considerable weight to the Aria product line.

It’s not strictly necessary to work with TiVo, but adding the TiVo sheen to say its interactive advertising strategy, could give it a real leg up in this market at some point. The only problem here is that TiVo may see this as competitive, and not wish to partner with EchoStar. Perhaps the fact that Charlie Ergen has stepped down as CEO at Dish may lead the way for the new CEO to heal the rift with TiVo and head for partnership rather than competition.

EchoStar Technologies will unveil Aria on June 14 during a cable industry convention, the Cable Show in Chicago.

‘Our engineers have designed an economical technology platform that will allow smaller cable operators to deliver the premium television features and services most in demand by consumers today without the need to invest in new facilities, servers, data centers and additional engineering staff,’ said Mark Jackson, president of EchoStar Technologies, a business unit of EchoStar Corporation. Aria is engineered to perform on existing networks without a painful integration period, the company said.

Services that can be delivered as part of Aria include TV Everywhere, multi-screen any location services; widget based graphical user interfaces with ‘skins’ branded for the local cable TV operator; universal search across all of a consumer’s authorized content, including linear TV, VOD or over-the-top services; remote DVR timer setting; and HD VoD using adaptive bit-rate streaming. The system will also include mobile apps and use EchoStar’s Universal RF remote control

EchoStar said the service integrates middleware, content management, subscription packaging, billing, and digital rights management.