Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 June 2011

Americans in love with eReaders, but confusion halts Tablet progress

We have come to trust the Pew Research Center Internet and American Life Project and its take on how Americans in particular, and by extrapolation the rest of the world, use internet connected devices. So this week when it came out and said that eReaders were the big growth item, not tablets, it has made not just us, but most other publications sit up and listen.

Its numbers, taken from a 2,277 person survey, suggest that tablet sales are flattening off when measured as the percentage of people who have them, and that eReader sales have perked up. This survey (which we trust) contradicts recent similar analyst reports (which usually ask their questions in a way which leads the consumer to give the right answers) which suggest Tablets are exploding.

Pew says that the percent of US adults with an e-book reader doubled from 6% to 12% between November 2010 and May 2011. In particular Hispanic adults, adults younger than 65, college graduates and those living in households with incomes of at least $75,000 are most likely to own e-book readers. Parents are also more likely than non-parents to own these devices.

Tablets have not seen the same level of growth in recent months. In May 8% of adults said they owned a tablet, just 1% more than those who reported owning one in January 2011 (7%), and represents just a 3% point increase in ownership since November 2010.

We have to ask if we are surprised at this or if this means that Tablets are not going to be the be-all and end-all of next generation computing.

Well first off we’re not surprised at this. The arrival of the Tablet and its pretense at being right for reading, in the same way as an eReader, has led to the prediction of the end of the eReader, when it fact the Tablets on the market are too heavy to use like a book, require an upright position to use, and can’t conveniently be read for instance laying down in bed, and the battery and sunlight issues of e-Ink (lasts for two months and can be read in direct sunlight) means that as people become more aware of the precise uses of the two device types, they are becoming more discerning. If they need an eReader they are now clear that a Tablet cannot do the same job for them and few are buying a Tablet by mistake, for reading books.

We are, of course, reminded of the arrival of the Personal Computer in its first iteration. The Apple II (yes we are that old) launching around 1977 for 1978 delivery, and the IBM PC was launched three years later in 1981 and most of the world got it in 1982. This did not kill off the dedicated Word Processor until around 1985. Yes it was a general purpose device which could do everything, including World Processing, but it took a while for the specialist eco-system of printers, print drivers and add on software to adapt themselves to the PC world and it took a while for the price and feature barriers to be slowly caught up by PCs, which were initially expensive, heavy and clunky and slow. In fact it wasn’t until Adobe established its PostScript page description language and memory prices fell for inclusion in printers, that this transition was truly on the way and it wasn’t until Windows 2.1 arrived in 1988 that the process was complete, because prior versions were delicate and crashed constantly and Word Processing documents were easily lost. Windows brought the cut and paste that WP relied upon, Postscript brought the printing capability of laser printers, but needed lots of printer located memory, so wasn’t really widespread until about the same time, although invented earlier.

So from 1977 to 1988 is 11 years, and we are going through a similar process now. The highly specialized eReader has a size, battery and screen requirement that Tablets aren’t currently matching. With improvements in the VLSI geometry and battery power and the creation of hybrid screens, this can be overcome, but it will take a long time. And what we find right now is that the rules of consumer product growth are being strictly obeyed in both eReaders and in Tablets. You have to want one, be able to afford one, and know someone who already has one. And for eReaders that is more likely than for tablets right now.

The first eReader was out years ago in 2006 and the first Amazon Kindle was in 2007, while the first true touch media Tablet was launched not much more than a year ago. eReaders have a 4 year head start in building up consumer momentum ahead of Tablets. We believe that the Tablet is the general purpose personal assistant that PDAs never were, because of the media aspect that allows you to take visual and audio content with you anywhere. But many of the problems of just ‘how’ content is licensed and delivered for Tablets have not yet been solved and won’t be solved for another two to three years. Technological improvements as we move from generation to generation of underlying chips and the natural operating system maturation process, along with embracing of new screen technologies, will all come together to make eReaders less attractive by 2015 or so. But even then, the price of eReaders will be so low that they will live on, while Tablets will continue to need the subsidy of LTE and WiFi operators to bring them to market in a commonplace way, similar to smart phones.

So yes, this IS what we expected, and when we put our numbers together late last year to predict Tablet market growth, this was one of the factors we took into account in our November 2010 report, predicting that eReaders would double adding 5 million customers in 2011 and add another 5 million in 2012 before sales flatten (a copy of the report can be bought from us, free exec summary at [email protected]).

The worrying thing about the Pew report is that Tablets almost appear to have stalled, but this is in response to the condition of the market. Apple is still on track but the rest of the market had a rethink before coming in against Apple and few of them have their marketing act together as yet and more work has to be done on the provision of Apps.

Pew reports that in May 2011, 8% of adults report owning an iPad, Samsung Galaxy or Motorola Xoom or other tablet. Before November 2010 tablet ownership had been climbing relatively quickly.

These findings come from a survey conducted from April 26 to May 22 among 2,277 adults ages 18 and over, including surveys in English and Spanish and on landline and cell phones in the US. The margin of error for the sample is plus or minus 2%, which, let’s face it, is quite a lot.

Both e-book reader and tablet computer adoption levels among US adults are still well below that of other tech devices that have been on the market longer. Cell phones are far and away the most popular digital device among US adults today, followed by desktop and laptop computers, DVRs, and MP3 players.

There is notable overlap in e-reader and tablet computer ownership ‘ 3% of US adults own both devices. Nine percent own an e-book reader but not a tablet, while 5% own a tablet computer, but not an e-reader.

So it looks like there needs to be another 4 to 5 years of multiple device ownership and that some people may end up with a Smart phone, a tablet, an eReader, a Tablet AND a laptop, though not many.

In this survey laptops are also as popular as desktop computers for the first time (in installed base, this has been true for a while in annual shipments). Laptops have already overtaken desktops in popularity among adults under age 30, and appear poised to do the same among older adults.

There was considerable growth in eReader ownership between November 2010 and May 2011 among college graduates, one-fifth of whom now own these devices. This group was already outpacing other adults in Pew Internet’s November 2010 survey. Similar demographic patterns of ownership exist for tablet computers, though parents are no more likely than non-parents to own these devices. However, in the case of tablet computers, men are now slightly more likely than women to own this type of device.

Between November 2010 and May 2011, the largest increases in tablet ownership have been among men when compared with women; Hispanic adults when compared with white and African-American adults; adults 18-29; those with some college or college degrees; and those reporting household incomes of $30,000 or more. Overall, the highest rates of tablet ownership are among Hispanic adults and those with household incomes of at least $75,000 annually.