Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 June 2011

Cablecos prove disruptive force as European 4G auctions pile up

The European economies are really getting into the swing of LTE auctions now, with France and Spain the next major sales. In these countries, as in Benelux and elsewhere, cablecos are proving the most disruptive force, looking to seize spectrum to launch quad plays and reduce the mobile power of the cellcos.

This was seen in Belgium, which has yet to sell LTE assets, but has awarded its fourth 3G licence, opening the way for two cable operators to steal a march in 4G ‘ a pattern also seen in neighboring Netherlands last year. The only bidder for the spectrum was a consortium called Telenet Tecteo Bidco, made up of two cable operators (Telenet and Tecteo). It paid €71.5m for the license, which also brings options on GSM spectrum.

Telenet is a subsidiary of the US public company Liberty Global, with around 2.3 million cable homes, split roughly 50:50 digital and cable; while Tecteo is the second largest cable operator there with 1.2 million TV homes. This move mirrors the one whereby UPC (also Liberty Global) and local cable roll-up firm Ziggo, the number 1 and 2 cable operators in the Netherlands, who bought spectrum just over a year ago there.

Bidco has bought two blocks of 14.8MHz in the 2.1GHz band and says it will exercise its option to buy two blocks of 4.8MHz in the 900MHz band, along with 2x10MHz in the 1.8GHz band ‘ it will pay €31.5m for these two assets in 2015, which most analysts see as a bargain, given the desirability of sub-1GHz spectrum.

The group is likely to deploy LTE in the technology neutral spectrum even though specific 4G licenses, in 2.6GHz and 800MHz, are auctioned separately. Like Iliad in France, it plans to steal a march on more established leaders with low cost tariffs combined with advanced data services.

Telenet already runs an MNVO with over 200,000 customers and said it would now improve its ‘challenger position in the mobile market and will allow for the roll-out of high-speed mobile data networks such as LTE’, though it also made it clear it was keeping its options open, hinting at possible trading of its assets in future.

This would fit in with the behavior in the Netherlands where Ziggo and UPC execs have been cited as saying it is unlikely they would build out their own spectrum, but more likely to find a 2nd or 3rd placed cellular partner and contribute the spectrum to a joint venture.

In Spain, no fewer than 11 companies have signed up to bid in the upcoming auction of 58 blocks of spectrum in the 800MHz and 2.6GHz bands, plus some additional 900MHz licenses. The sale will take place in the coming weeks and it seems that several non-traditional firms will take part, challenging established cellcos Vodafone, Telefonica and Orange. The list is not public, but is likely to include cablecos, as in other countries.

Last summer, a quartet of cable providers – Euskaltel, Telecable, ONO and R, announced a joint plan to acquire spectrum to support voice and mobile broadband. A statement from the four hopefuls said that the government had ‘the opportunity to improve the competitive balance if they assign an effective and efficient radio spectrum, and factor in the development of competition in the market.’

Current reports omit TeliaSonera’s Spanish subsidiary Yoigo. This firm recently acquired new licenses in GSM bands 900MHz and 1.8GHz ‘ which have been presented by the Spanish regulator as the first spectrum platform for LTE and which allow Yoigo better roaming capabilities. The attractive combination of 900MHz for rural coverage and 1.8GHz (an increasingly prominent LTE band) for urban capacity may mean that Yoigo will stay out of the LTE-specific auction. Market leaders Telefonica and Vodafone were barred from bidding for the first round of 900MHz and 1.8GHz licenses, which went to Orange and Yoigo for a total of €168 million in total and will give them a 4G headstart. Further GSM licenses then went under the hammer for LTE refarming.

In France, TV provider Iliad/Free has also been creating ripples around a quad play to challenge incumbent Orange, but the closely watched auction may be delayed by legal disputes.

The country’s telecoms regulator, Arcep, will auction 2.6GHz and digital dividend (800MHz) licenses this year but is facing legal challenges from third cellco Bouygues Telecom. The operator has petitioned the French supreme court to intervene over the terms and conditions attached to the auction, claiming the proposals could cost mobile operators up to €1.7 billion.

According to local newspaper Le Figaro, Bouygues has submitted its complaint to the French Council of State, amid concerns that winners of the 800MHz licenses will have to pay compensation to any viewers of digital terrestrial TV, who suffer interference from mobile signals.

This objection could halt the whole auction process and even force France to postpone the sales, in an echo of the serially delayed UK 2.6GHz spectrum sale, which has also suffered legal challenges, mainly over redistribution of sub-1GHz assets. UK regulator Ofcom will be watching the result of Bouygues’ action carefully, since it has stated that ‘the majority of the costs’ of coexistence between mobile broadband and digital TV ‘should be borne by future 800MHz licensees’.