Irdeto says that it has bought the self-protecting digital content system usually referred to as DB+, and written by Cryptography Research , which it sold in 2007 to Macrovision, a company that has since become Rovi. The idea is to merge what is a fairly revolutionary video defense system with its own ActiveCloak for Media, and pitch it at the emerging multiscreen video market.
DB+ is one of three defenses of Blu-Ray disks and relies on an exceptionally secure virtual machine which also has extensions which reach out into the surrounding environment to see if any actions which might support piracy are processing. The other two defenses are the compromised AACS (Advanced Access Content System), which it little more than an updated improvement to the original CSS (Content Scrambling System) used in DVDs and so easily beaten, and ROM mark, a serialization technology to prevent mass production.
Irdeto’s Said Rahmani Khezri, SVP of Corporate and Business Development talked to us about merging the two technologies, BD+ and ActiveCloak for Media, ‘When Cloakware first came out of a group we acquired in Ottawa in Canada, it had many similarities with Self Protecting Digital Content (SPDC) but it was sold as a set of licenses to compilers and algorithms and while many companies decided to use it, it wasn’t really a set of products until about a year ago. Now once again many companies are starting to work with it, even though we only really announced it as a product in February. The only companies that we can mention that are using the technology are Netflix, Sony and Adobe.’ More are expected soon.
‘BD+ was included by studios in their Blu-ray disks and Irdeto found itself called in to see if we could help with BD+. On its own SPDC allows for renewing security and revoking any players which are abusing it, but this was happening too often to be manageable. The studios needed one more step to make piracy that little bit more uneconomic.’
‘Using Cloakware we showed how it can be done, and now we have to spend the next 9 to 12 months building that out into a set of products and a service for Hollywood studios. Initially we offered our help through Rovi but in the end it made more sense if we simply bought out the BD+ part of the business.’
Rahmani confirms that deals are already in place with a number of studios to add this technology to their Blu-ray disks once it is ready.
It’s tough to imagine just how the two products will come together, but this is all about protecting video throughout the playing eco-system, and he talks in terms of the video being mathematically obfuscated (sounds a bit like cryptographic hashing, but obviously it’s a bit more complex). It can do this anywhere there is processing power to undo it prior to its use and mathematical transforms operate right down to the point where data is about to be sent to the screen says Rahmani.
Cloakware is doing this protection, so it’s not just the protection of encryption keys, but of the whole video pipeline, including internal buses and the whole playback chain. It will close the analog hole right down to where you can only film the screen in order to make a copy, and that results in dramatic quality loss.
The combination of the two tools will update into all media players, both in the Blu-ray players and also in other multi-screen software clients and be used to protect games and video, both as a set of license products, but also with a service element where Irdeto can watch over the various elements, taking care of revocation, renewal and license replacement. This will include the BD+ elements of attack analysis, where it looks for activity within the same operating environment of things such as debuggers and screen scrubbers and it will switch them off before it plays any video.
Back in December 2004 we talked this system through with the head of Content Protection at CRI (the rest of the company has since been sold to Rambus as recently as May this year for $342.5 million). The BD+ element was sold, along with the team that invented it, to Macrovision in 2007 for $45 million.
The BD+ system is based on a virtual machine that can be implemented in both hardware and software, or in software only, initially based on a stripped down DLX processor with the floating point removed and a few APIs added to improve security. The original DLX is a 32-bit pipelined embedded RISC CPU architecture that came out of academia from the designers of MIPS and the Berkeley RISC chips, and was originally designed for teaching, not too unlike the ARM RISC core.
It can be built in hardware or expressed in a hardware language like the Verilog Hardware Description Language and was first available in a reference implementation of C. Perhaps we should think of it as Java for the DVD player.
SPDC then sits securely inside this virtual machine and does a number of tricks. It writes a few bits of player specific data into each version of the content it plays out, rather like a dynamic, player specific watermark, and it can revoke, remove or replace license data and allow multiple DRMs to operate above it and control it.
If pirated content is found in the wild, the player that made it can be identified, and a subsequent release can be issued from the studio to act as a trigger to revoke decryption licenses. These instructions will be carried on all subsequent DVD disks issues by that studio. But given that most BD+ players are now online, it could be that this could be done over the internet by now.
SPDC content can also be programmed to dynamically query playback environments and even way back then included some attack detection logic, which runs while the content is playing, to decide if someone is trying to make an illegal copy or not.
Any system like this is only as secure as the virtual machine that it all plays on, which is what stops the casual pirate from being able to break into this set up, professional pirates are another matter and this was not originally aimed at them, though Irdeto thinks it can be. If we add Cloakware to this, it may well be possible to foil most professional pirates, most of the time, by increasing the effort that it takes them to break, which it could be enough to make it too uneconomic to bother.
There has been little publicly about how Blu-ray disks have been faring in the piracy world since, a few weeks after they came out predictably the AACS encryption system was broken, which was, after all, just the first line of defense. But clearly the Blu-ray group suffered less embarrassment here than on DVDs, as it was not fully hacked, and using SPDC, it will have been possible to contain many other casual hacking attempts.
There was no value placed on the division of Rovi that has gone to Irdeto, but we imagine a large part of it is future revenue related, but that it will recover the amount spent at least, so more than $45 million eventually, although it may not be very much up front. We will look out for it in Rovi’s next financial results.
Rahmani said, ‘This type of service really IS Irdeto’s future. We have had a good 20 years protecting broadcast assets using traditional conditional access, but online digital asset protection is what is required going forwards. This system, once it comes out is going to make us a lot more visible. Imagine if a studio comes out with a new movie release and there is no hacked version of it on the internet for weeks or months. That studio is going to make more money than all the others, and that’s what we hope to demonstrate.’ Now that really would throw attention on Irdeto.