Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 July 2011

NAB says chunks of US broadcast TV will go dark if FCC plan goes ahead

The US Federal Communications Commission has a bit of a war on its hands regarding the recycling of spectrum currently used by US broadcasters, with the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) claiming there is the possibility of a catastrophe and a variety of cellular organizations crying foul at the NAB claims.

The FCC has said that broadcasters who do not use some bands of spectrum can give up their local spectrum in auctions on a voluntary basis, in a campaign to unearth 120 MHz of wireless spectrum for mobile broadband services. So taking the FCC at its word NAB has calculated that in order to find 120 MHz, more pressure MUST be brought to bear on broadcasters because this amounts to 20 TV 6 MHz channels in every territory. The association argues that it can’t be done and in the absence of the FCC pointing out how it wants it to be done, it has done calculations of its own.

It reckons that 40% of existing broadcast channels would have to be vacated under the US National Broadband Plan and that as a result of that some 672 markets must be cleared and moved into other spectrum. The NAB says that as a result of this 210 TV stations would go off the air permanently.

The hostile reaction of the cellular community was immediate and pointed out that this is a purely voluntary action and that the NAB is deliberately misunderstanding it to draw a reaction, the CTIA in particular pointed out that participation in the auction is voluntary and that repacking costs to move to other spectrum would be reimbursed.

Well they are both right. The amount of cash that cellcos might offer at auction for such packages will be dependent upon widescale coverage, but if enough spectrum does become available to make it worthwhile, then future auctions, with some of the money going to the FCC and some going back to the original spectrum holders, would likely yield more profit than any of the stations can generate by sticking to using the spectrum for broadcast TV. The truth is that throughout the civilized world cellcos can extract far more money from most spectrum than broadcasters can. As a result of that, the incentives, once clear and well understood, would lead to investors, boards and policy makers pushing harder and harder to get the weaker broadcast spectrum holders to sell out. The FCC would not have to make it mandatory, but the NAB is right, this will lead to a thinning of its numbers.

However that’s a bit disingenuous. Broadcasters can fit more programming into less and less spectrum, for instance targeting multiple ATSC M/H mobile channels within one 6 MHz slice of spectrum, and also condensing their most popular programming into a tighter number of channels. They get much of their money from advertising and the rest from cable carriage fees of local programming, and where they are carrying a national broadcast channels, their costs are almost entirely affiliation fees with some program making costs for local programing. Will the financial formula of these operations really change if they broadcast less channels? And what may be the effect of offering more mobile channels?

An astute broadcaster with more than one slice of spectrum might find a way to have his cake and eat it, by cleverly managing spectrum rights and selling off some spectrum as well. Any anyway repacking is only about taking other unused segments of spectrum in other markets and pushing the channels into those, using slightly different broadcast equipment. They don’t really need to go off the air, and would only die if it wasn’t worth keeping them alive.

NAB points out that during the analog switch off two years ago, only 174 stations had to be cleared from channels 52-69 and forced to move to a new channel. Now it is talking about finding new homes for 672 out of the 1,735 US full-power TV stations in channels 31-51. It’s almost a four times bigger logistical problem than the US faced at switch off.

‘If the FCC’s National Broadband Plan to recapture 20 more TV channels is implemented, service disruption, confusion and inconvenience for local television viewers will make the 2009 DTV transition seem like child’s play,’ said NAB President Gordon Smith. ‘NAB endorses truly voluntary spectrum auctions. Our concern is that the FCC plan will morph into involuntary, because it is impossible for the FCC to meet spectrum reclamation goals without this becoming a government mandate.’

NAB reminds us all that 46 million Americans are still relying entirely on over the air broadcasting for all their TV. Interestingly many of them are the poorest US citizens, and taking OTT services to them is impractical, because we would bet that the overlap between those without Pay TV and those without broadband (or decent broadband) is likely to be considerable.

It’s true that a great imponderable would be retuning every TV in all the homes of those 46 million Americans so that the new TV channels were still an option to watch. This might take time and genuinely in some cases may never happen and advertising revenues could fall through the floor during such a period and stations would close. So that has to be calculated into the price that the broadcasters get for the spectrum. But you can see why some marginal operators may decide not to begin broadcasting once again, so perhaps 210 channels would go off the air as NAB claims. But would that be such a bad thing?

NAB adds that Americans living in cities along the Canadian border would bear extra burdens because of international treaty obligations designed to minimize interference between Canadian and US cities, so that all Detroit TV stations could go dark and similar situations may emerge in Buffalo, Seattle, Syracuse, Cleveland, Spokane, Rochester and Watertown, NY and Flint, Michigan.

What the NAB wants is for the FCC to make public its own analysis of the National Broadband Plan’s negative impact on viewers of free TV. It is perhaps looking for even bigger free handouts in order to play ball with the spectrum plan.

“We’ve waited patiently for over a year for FCC data on how the Broadband Plan impacts broadcasters, and more importantly, the tens of millions of viewers who rely every day on local TV for news, entertainment, sports and lifeline emergency weather information,” said the NAB’s Smith. “Even Congress can’t get information from the FCC. All we are seeking is more transparency. We have but one chance to get this right if we are to preserve future innovation for broadcasters and our viewers.”

The truth is that no-one who is in the decision making chain gives a hoot for preserving future innovation for broadcasters. This is purely about money, and right now if you have a broadband service, all you need to do is hold up a sign and customers will come. It’s not the same for broadcast revenues.

Which is why the three top trade associations from the wireless community have all waded into the argument in the form of the CTIA, the Consumer Electronics Association (CEA) and Wireless Communications Association International. Each one had its own strongly worded statement out denying the NAB claims.

Legislation to allow the FCC voluntary auctions of TV spectrum is still being passed through government, but we’re betting that the US lobby groups of the cellcos are substantially bigger than those of the broadcast industry, and this will go through on the nod, and we also think that some Broadcasters will make a killing out of these auctions and still find clever ways to survive and even thrive.