This has been a week to sell off Netflix, take profits and then buy the stock back, with the share price having a $30 fall at one point after its results came out, down from $285 to $255 off 12%, but it has already bounced back to $270 and may well go higher and shortly reclaim its previous highs.
We think this is because the results were tough to understand . Quite simply the announcements of the past few weeks, where Netflix has separated out DVD rental and online streaming rental, have absolutely no bearing on this quarter, or if they do it is entirely negative.
The quarterly revenue announced for last quarter was $788 million with 68 million in Free cash flow and net income of $68 million, its largest to date, with the addition of 1.8 million net new customers.
What would be expect here? Well some customers in the process of signing up may hold fire and think again or cancel, but since the quarter had ended before the announcement, that didn’t happen in this quarter. Realistically we would except the first month or so of the coming quarter to have virtually ALL the bad news in it. Some marketing efforts, geared up to the old situation where subscribers could get both online DVD rental and streaming in one package, will turn sour. Some people won’t renew. But by the middle of that quarter new marketing efforts which are appropriate to the two product lines ‘ DVD based and online only ‘ will cut in and the shape should start to come back into the Netflix business.
This means that at the end of next quarter Netflix in the US still expects to have 25 million subscribers (perhaps up half a million over the quarter), with 10 million streaming only customers paying $8 each and the 3 million DVD only customers also, for the most part paying $8 a month each. The 12 million in the middle will be paying at least $16 a month, maybe more. If you multiply that out, the company’s run rate will be at $888 million a quarter by the end of the quarter but its guidance is far more circumspect, at just $805 million, partly because it must ramp to that new run rate, and partly because it’s not sure just how bad the price rises will hit, so it is overdoing them in its forecast.
Netflix also says that in the fourth quarter its previous pattern of year over year growth will come back. Let’s hope so.
So this is not a case of the landgrab being over, but more a prudent approach that says, ‘If we still want to be growing in a few years from now, we need the margins to be high enough so that we can spend cash on new content, competing with the HBOs of this world.’
Investors that hate any element of uncertainty during transitions may wait this out, but by the time Netflix reports the next quarter one of two things will happen. It will then KNOW how bad the fallout is from the price rises, and it will have had its first month of invoicing those clients who do not cancel for both online streaming and DVD rental, and it will have a good idea of whether or not the new bigger invoices shake out more customers. Its guidance at the end of next quarter is likely to be more confident and therefore, we reckon, a little higher.
Netflix says that Q4 will be the first quarter with a clean separation of the costs for DVD and streaming services so that come January, the company will be able to report separately with US and international, streaming and DVD rental cost breakdowns including margins. By then all the smart money will be back in Netflix and as the final piece of evidence that its service separation has worked will come too late for investors to take note of. By then it will all be in the price.
Netflix also confidently predicts that Q4 will be its first billion dollar quarter, driven mostly by a strong US performance.
All of which makes the fact that Netflix disappointed this time with slightly lower revenues than analyst had predicted, almost irrelevant. Already it has nearly 1 million streaming customers in Canada and in one of the next two quarters will begin to announce its Latin American sign ups. Although we have been critical of its choice of Latin America ahead of Europe as an international launch pad, this is not a serious error of judgment and the enthusiasm which South Americans have for video entertainment may make this every bit as good in the short term, despite our concerns that leaving Europe until later allows Amazon time to build a head of steam there.
The rest of the Netflix comments were taken up listing all the new content and device deals it has done, and talking about its continued belief that US viewers are not cord cutting and that Netflix remains a complementary service alongside TV Everywhere services from pay TV operators, and that its real rival is HBO and companies like it.
Finally, and here is the reason for its overriding optimism, it wrote off both Hulu Plus and Amazon pointing out that Hulu Plus only added about 325,000 subs in Q2; compared to its 1.8 million. It insists that since Hulu is likely to be sold in the near term, it is unknown who will run it and how much they will invest in the subscription part of the service. But management re-assured investors that Netflix isn’t planning to bid on Hulu because most of its revenue is from providing free ad-supported streaming of current season TV shows, which is not the Netflix focus.
And despite Amazon adding thousands of films and TV shows to its online services and providing them as a free service to subscribers as part of its Prime shipping service, Netflix has far more streaming content, available on more devices and so far it hasn’t detected any impact at all on its business from Amazon Prime.