Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 July 2011

Broadcom’s Palm Makes Overwhelming Case for P1905

Broadcom’s senior technical director Stephen Palm, one of the main drivers of P1905 development, made a presentation on P1905 at the HomePlug Technology Summit in Taiwan this week. He presented an overwhelming case for P1905 and provided an overview and schedule. The IEEE P1905 effort is intended to develop a bridge for Wi-Fi, HomePlug, MoCA and Ethernet.

Palm pointed out the serious shortcomings of current home networking:
– No home network scheme has 100% coverage in every room. Even Wi-Fi, coverage is dependent on the home’s construction and wall density. Part of the home may be on a different powerline phase, which decreases performance. Outside the States, few homes have coax in every room or on every wall where an outlet is needed.

Only 11% of homes had wireline Ethernet at the end of 2008. We suspect that the 11% number is high and certainly does not include every room ‘ or even the main rooms, which are living room/family room, bedrooms, office/library and porches/patios.

What’s needed, Palm said, is a way to bridge HomePlug, MoCA, Wi-Fi and Ethernet that’s reliable, has a high throughput rate (for multiple streams of HD video), low error rate, certain quality-of-service (QoS) for flicker-free video, easy to install and mobile.

The solution is to provide a scheme that combines two or more home network technologies to provide a whole-home solution. It will also balance the ‘payload’ between multiple data channels and allow multiple data streams to be managed more effectively.

Palm showed how the P1905 abstraction layer could be developed to ensure compatibility and coexistence between different home network technologies.
A single push button can be used to set up security on all the networks instead of having to do each network individually as is done now. Service providers can use TR-069 technology to diagnose remotely and in many cases fix performance problems.

IEEE’s P1905 technology, Palm said, could provide an ‘any device, anytime, anywhere, any media, any service solution.’ It will complete the home networking family, he said. Palm provided the prior and future schedule for P1905 development.

Several home network technologists we spoke to said P1905 development is progressing nicely and is expected to be relatively easy and painless to implement at a very small incremental cost.

Won’t service providers and consumers love P1905 ‘ one box that is a home network triple play! Plug it into an electrical outlet and get Wi-Fi, HomePlug AV and Ethernet. Plug it into a coax outlet and get Wi-Fi, MoCA and Ethernet!
If and when it’s ever embedded in CE gear that is sold in retail stores, consumers will be giddy.

We know that chip and STB makers are excited about providing P1905-compatible gear to pay TV and broadband service providers ‘ they can order large quantities of equipment for delivery on a fixed schedule.

The bigger market, we think, is at retail because by the time P1905 becomes available in products, millions will already have and will still be buying stationary CE devices with Internet connectivity like TVs, Blu-ray players, gaming consoles, surround sound systems and other devices that will need to be connected. All need the QoS, security and reliability of a wireline network, and all the home’s mobile devices like tablets and smartphones need Wi-Fi.

In the end, all the stationary Internet-connected devices should have a P1905 version home networking scheme built in. That’s a billion or more devices, figuring that the 300 million or so homes in North America, Europe and the Pac Rim will have three or more such stationary devices plus some more millions of homes in Latin America, China, Russia and India.

We say the case for P1905 that Broadcom’s Palm makes is ‘overwhelming,’ which one dictionary defines as ‘overpowering; so great as to render resistance or opposition useless: an overwhelming majority.’

Who could oppose P1905 except maybe someone who’s left out? Such as HommeGrid. They were all for it when they were trying to join in P1905. Homes need a unified mix of home network technologies to be pervasive throughout every part of the home.

The HomePlug contingent, led by HomePlug president Rob Ranck, also gave conference attendees an update on HomePlug AV2, whose appearance is coming soon. In addition to Broadcom, SPiDCOM, ST Microelectronics and Qualcomm Atheros also gave presentations.