Round the world, carriers are cutting costs and integrating services, in a bid to fend off new competition, often from cablecos moving into a quad play. France Telecom has recently made a string of cuts and changes in preparation for the launch of Free Mobile by broadband provider Iliad. Sprint has long hoped to be the ‘fourth arm’ of the US cablecos, pooling quad play efforts to wrongfoot Verizon and AT&T ‘ but doubts over Clearwire may fatally disadvantage this alliance as a quad play boom appears in sight. US carriers should look over the border, where Carlos Slim is reintegrating his Mexican telecoms empire to defend it against Grupo Televisa, a powerful cableco which is entering the mobile space.
Slim, one of the world’s richest men, split the mobile and fixed arms of his company Telmex a decade ago, spinning off the cellular activities under the name America Movil. Movil is now Latin America’s largest wireless operator, and engaged in a head-to-head with Telefonica. It has offered about $6.5 billion to take control of its former parent, buying the 40.4% it does not currently own. This would pave the way for massive efficiencies, according to the firm, and for even deeper integration than Slim achieved when Movil acquired a majority stake in Telmex last year. CFO Carlos Garcia- Moreno said the companies would cross-sell service and share retail outlets and customer service facilities.
For Movil, however, there is the downside of taking on a fixed line business which is losing sales to mobile operators, including Movil itself. But the group believes the benefits of efficiencies outweigh this as there will be a single quad play network across Mexico, a strong counterpoint to Grupo Televisa’s plans to add mobile services to its cable-based TV, internet and phone offerings.
Slim is making a long term bet on future demand for quad play services, which could affect all his Latin American footprint. Jorge Lagunas of Grupo Financiero Interacciones in Mexico told Bloomberg: ‘In some point in its history, we could see news about quadruple play from Telmex, or something like that, that could help boost profit at America Movil itself.’ Mexico is not the first country to indicate the trend ‘ America Movil has already started to offer fixed/mobile bundles in other territories, notably Colombia, as it has already taken on Telmex’ fixed line operations outside Mexico, as part of Slim’s first integration deal in early 2010.
As well as the usual quad play advantages of efficiencies and a greater share of a customer’s media/communications spend, America Movil believes integration will boost its ambitious multiscreen content and apps plans, although investors have sometimes balked at the capex leap involved ‘ capex will peak at $8.2 billion this year, about $2 billion more than previously outlined, with more than $1 billion a year of that budget going towards pay TV and triple/quad play services. At the end of September the operator had 216.8 million wireless customers in 17 countries across Latin America and its US MVNO. It aims to have 300 million by 2014.
Even these figures do not make its fight with Telefonica an easy one. The Spanish company has been investing heavily in Latin America, its key growth area as its European markets saturate and its home Spanish market suffers from deep recession. Its roll-out program for 2009-2013 will involve spending at least $20 billion on expanding and upgrading its networks in the region. It will phase out CDMA to get the economies of a single GSM/HSPA platform, plus it is trialing LTE in some markets. Last year it acquired full control of Vivo, the largest Brazilian cellco, buying out 50:50 venture partner Portugal Telecom. Both Telefonica and Telmex are also active in acquiring 3.5GHz or 2.5GHz spectrum for fixed and converged broadband use.
Telefonica is the market leader in Venezuela, Chile, Peru and Brazil (in its Vivo joint venture with Portugal Telecom). It has been extending its reach across the whole region over the past few years, and bought BellSouth’s Latin American assets in 2004. BellSouth’s activities had been in Argentina, Chile, Peru, Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, Uruguay, Guatemala, Nicaragua and Panama, and they gave Telefonica 40.5 million additional mobile subscribers.
Slim acquired control of Telmex from the government in a 1990 privatization sale and spun off America Movil in 2001. Movil bought its 59.6% stake in Telmex last year for $23 billion, also gaining ownership of Slim’s other fixed line networks in South America. Movil is currently appealing a $1 billion fine imposed by the Mexican regulator for alleged anti-competitive practices in charging interconnection fees to rivals.
AT&T, which holds an 8.5% stake in Telmex, said it will accept America Movil’s offer for its shares, which will be valued at about $1.37 billion. The US operator also owns about 9% of America Movil and is part of a group, with Slim and his family, that controls the company’s voting shares.
Not that quad play is proving to be a golden egg for all cablecos. Time Warner Cable, one of the US cable providers partnering with Sprint (for voice roaming) and Clearwire (for mobile broadband and coverage extension), admits the results of its wireless efforts have been ‘not terribly exciting’. CEO Glenn Britt said the company would continue to experiment with new combinations and services, which it would reveal in the coming months, but so far ‘our results in terms of actual [wireless] customers are not terribly exciting. So, the evidence so far is that it’s not a big market for the quadruple play. We’re not ready to say that this is a non-starter, maybe we’re just not doing it right, but we’re also not ready to make huge additional bets.’
However, by 2016, according to forecasts by Strategy Analytics, 13% of US households will take a quad play service, a fourfold increase on 2011 levels ‘ highlighting the impending battle between the operators, as the number of individual subscriptions falls, but each one includes more services and higher value. Today, 57% of US households take two or more media or communications services from a single provider, which is already one of the highest rates in the world. ‘Quad play bundling has had a slow start in the US but we see increased momentum over the next five years,’ commented report author Ben Piper. ‘US quad play subscribers have a far higher value for money perception and are significantly less likely to churn.’
Such trends mean that the cablecos, and the telcos, must build their strategies, but the US situation is complicated by the doubts over the future of Clearwire. The major cable operators ‘ Comcast, Cox and Time Warner Cable, plus Brighthouse Networks ‘ have a long history of collaborating with Sprint to add mobile capabilities to their portfolios. They have all worked together periodically on buying spectrum and using Sprint’s CDMA network ‘ despite the failure of an ambitious joint venture called Pivot, these cablecos continue to rely on simpler Sprint MVNOs for their 3G offerings. Such alliances have a dual benefit for Sprint ‘ boosting the wholesale aspect of its business, which is increasingly important to its growth (and arguably should be its only activity); and strengthening the cablecos, the most effective counterweight to Sprint’s main rivals, Verizon and AT&T.
Reaping the full benefits of these mutual interests requires something more than MVNOs, though, so Pivot was quickly followed by an even more ambitious project, the Clearwire joint venture, in which Sprint and all its cableco partners except Cox took stakes, and agreed to use the WiMAX network to underpin their own mobile broadband offerings. That gave them all a 4G headstart on Verizon and AT&T, but the venture is now at a crossroads. While the WiMAX/3G services and devices have contributed significantly to Sprint’s performance, mobile broadband has delivered less than impressive results for Comcast and TWC, as Britt’s comments indicated. These are early days of course, and as Strategy Analytics suggests, a quad play boom may be on the horizon. But now Sprint has muddied the waters by raising question marks over its future commitment to Clearwire.
We may believe that, in the end, Sprint will continue to support Clearwire ‘ reducing its costs via network sharing, pushing it towards LTE, perhaps acquiring it outright ‘ but the cablecos are living with the possibility that it will replace Clearwire with a combination of LightSquared and its own LTE roll-outs. Since none of them would have the motivation to buy Sprint out ‘ even collectively ‘ they have to consider other options. Britt told analysts on TWC’s earnings call: ‘It’s tricky for us to say anything about Clearwire. … Suffice it to say, we are not obligated in any way to make any additional investment.”
Of course, Comcast and TWC could transfer their current arrangements to Sprint’s new network and/or LightSquared, and cash in what was left of the value of their holdings in Clearwire. Their quad play activities are at a sufficiently early stage to make transition reasonably trivial in device and customer relations terms. It has even been suggested they could sell their AWS spectrum holdings to Sprint in return for an equity stake, bolstering the capacity of Network Vision and supporting their wholesale activities.
Another option may be to go it alone and build their own wireless networks, although network sharing and wholesale relationships look set to be the main flavour of 4G rather than new builds. Cox Communications recently pulled back from rolling out 3G itself in its own spectrum and will rely on its own MVNO deal with Sprint instead. TWC is also an investor in SpectrumCo, a group of cablecos which spent $2.4bn on AWS spectrum licenses during the 2006 auction. “As I think you know there is a fairly a long time period for build-out associated with that spectrum,” Britt said. “So, we’re going to keep trying to find out if there is some formula for quadruple play that works. If we find the magic formula, we’ll go from there. If we don’t then we’ll take some other action.’
“One thing they have to do is make contingency plans … in case Clearwire unravels,” said analyst Craig Moffett of Sanford Bernstein, who is negative on the idea that LightSquared will get regulatory clearance any time soon. All will become clearer in the fall ‘ the FCC should make its LightSquared decision in November and Sprint is likely to reveal more about its own 4G choices in October. But the longer the cablecos live in confusion, the more likely AT&T and Verizon are to push their LTE and fiber roll-outs and take the quad play crown. As Slim’s decisive actions in Mexico indicate, this is not a good time for would-be quad play operators to hesitate.