Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 August 2011

Cablevision supplier establishes core VoD patents in Verizon suit

It’s pretty much in the nature of companies as big and powerful as US telco Verizon that they will never give up a legal fight without taking it to the highest authority, so losing out this week to the tune of $115 million to Cloud TV specialist ActiveVideo Networks is likely to make Verizon reach once again for its lawyers and go for an appeal, rather than pay up.

It hasn’t said that much so far, but the story is relatively complicated and it’s really about dominating pay TV within its footprint, and the fight being put up by cable incumbent in the New York region, Cablevision, a company that ActiveVideo has supplied with technology in the past.

Verizon has sued for patent infringement to get Cablevision to stop supplying customers with VoD and pay TV, and has been more or less roundly seen off. The ITC this week found that a prior judgment was sound which said 4 of the 5 patents that that Verizon was using to sue Cablevision were not infringed, but said that it was infringing a fifth. That patent, No. 6,381,748 which applies to apparatus and methods for network access using a set-top box and television has recently been found to be invalid by yet another court, in Virginia, so if Verizon wants to keep its claims against Cablevision alive, it will have to go in for yet another appeal there.

The whole idea behind Verizon’s suit filed last year was to stop Cablevision using the same set tops that it used, made (and as far as we can see invented) by Cisco and the ITC is still said to be thinking about banning imports of those boxes or looking for some other remedy, but since the ITC decision has to be ratified by the full ITC board and the patent in question has now been invalidated (yeah right the idea of a set top was Verizon’s ‘ sure no prior art on that one) then its entire case is likely to fall apart.

We understand that the ActiveVideo suit was filed more or less as a counter suit to protect its own patents, and now a jury trial has awarded a $115 million penalty against Verizon.

ActiveVideo has four patents which define how cable companies can use technology to limit the effect on their overall bandwidth when implementing VoD while making VoD programs appear just like yet another linear channel ‘ in terms of ease of use. The detailed patent seems to be pretty specific and relates directly to an improvement in how cable HFC is wired up to media servers.

ActiveVideo believes it is now able to use the VoD interactivity in its patents to demand licenses from any company using cable VoD. The award was given in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia and applies to Verizon’s FiOS TV service.

‘We’re extremely pleased that the judge found that ActiveVideo intellectual property was valid and that the jury found that Verizon infringed on all asserted claims,’ said Jeff Miller, president and CEO of ActiveVideo Networks. ‘We are seeking immediate payment of the damages that have been awarded by the court; in addition, our legal team, Morgan Lewis & Bockius LLP, will be filing an injunction against Verizon to prevent any further unlawful use of our technology.’

The patents in question are patent numbers No. 6,034,678, 5,550,578, 6,100,883, and 6,205,582.

‘We are delighted that this verdict enables us to continue granting our customers unfettered access to the power of our CloudTV technology,’ said Jeff Miller. ‘Coupled with the court’s ruling invalidating Verizon’s 6,381,748 patent, this verdict provides further support for our customer, Cablevision, in their defense against Verizon’s injunction claims within the US International Trade Commission.’

ActiveVideo claims it pioneered both interactivity and VoD throughout the 1990s for the cable architecture and has a substantial and fundamental portfolio of patents dating back to the early 1990s. The ActiveVideo CloudTV platform is currently deployed with major cable system operators, including Cablevision. It offers solutions for video on demand navigation, interactive games, and many other interactive services.