Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 August 2011

Adobe Edge builds bridge to HTML5, but codec war still rages

Last week it closed down its Flash apps store, now Adobe has made its biggest step yet towards HTML5. Flash will be a long time dying, but the company knows it needs to carve out a role in a world where HTML5 provides the main cross-platform web environment. And its new Adobe Edge is a move in the right direction, geared heavily to the mobile world.

Edge certainly stops well short of replacing Flash, but it provides an HTML-based web animation system ‘ though, as yet, only for simple animations such as those in adverts. But it does support HTML5, and therefore the iPhone and iPad, and will get more sophisticated over time ‘ rapidly so if the web community really does sort out its differences over video codec standards and start to squeeze Flash’s market presence. The tool has a built-in WebKit browser and creates interactive graphics through HTML elements styled with CSS 3. Users will see a user interface familiar from Flash and After Effects.

There is a sense of unseemly haste as Adobe releases the technology in preview mode, as a free download from Adobe Labs. This hints at the pressure it is feeling from the unexpectedly rapid uptake of HTML5 browsers, especially on mobile products. The firm said in a statement: “Because of rapid changes around HTML5, the company is adopting an open development methodology for Adobe Edge and is releasing the software on the Adobe Labs site much earlier than normal in the development process, before it even reaches beta, in order to allow user feedback to help shape the final product.”

One of Adobe’s missteps with Flash was to take too long to bring full functionality to mobile devices. Instead it gave Apple its weapon by relying on the stripped-down Flash Lite, which ‘ as the iPhone maker always claims ‘ became increasingly inadequate as smartphones became capable of PC-class video. Full Flash Mobile did appear, but only after industry attention was drifting to HTML5 ‘ as shown by the failure of the app store, which was meant to make Flash the main instrument to span the conflicting mobile operating systems.

By contrast, Edge has been designed primarily with mobile devices in mind. Adobe says it was “designed and tested to work reliably on the iOS and Android platforms, WebKit-enabled devices and popular desktop browsers’. The quality and functionality is the same, from day one, on all these platforms, it insists.

Adobe also released its Flash-to-HTML5 conversion tool, codenamed Wallaby, in March. Wallaby is an application to convert Flash Professional CS5 files (.FLA) to HTML5.

Not that HTML5’s victory is quite as assured as many assume, and by allowing Flash to live side-by-side with the newer standard, Adobe may be hoping to remain the most pragmatic option for cross-platform rich media, while the purer HTML5 community fights it out ‘ especially now that the other candidate for the role, Microsoft Silverlight, has been effectively sidelined by its owner in favor of HTML5.

Among several critical disputes over key elements of the fledgling standard, the row over video codecs is perhaps the most destructive, with H.264 ‘ supported by Apple, Microsoft and others ‘ up against Google-backed WebM. Google claims its preferred technology is more open and is free ‘ it is based on the VP8 codec Google acquired last year but then placed in open source, while H.264 is licensed by the MPEG LA patent pool. However, several reports indicate that H.264 still has far greater traction, because it is more mature and because of the influence of the iPad on web video. According to MeFeedia, in July 69% of online videos were available for HTML5 viewing in H.264 format, up from 25% just 14 months earlier. In July, by contrast, only 2% of videos were in WebM format.

WebM is starting to get broader support on devices, which should drive adoption. Most importantly, and riskily, Google removed H.264 support from its own Chrome browser in the latest release, while it has made it available on all Android devices running Gingerbread or Honeycomb. WebM is also implemented by Firefox and Opera and is starting to acquire key features like hardware acceleration.

However, it may also be the latest Google ‘open’ technology to be hindered by patent wars. As has become painfully clear in Android, ‘open source’ and ‘license-free’ do not necessarily equate to ‘free from patent royalties’. And Apple will resist this latest Google attempt to derail its favored platforms, using the IPR weapon if necessary. MPEG LA claimed recently that 12 different companies have come forward with patents “essential” to the VP8 codec which underpins WebM, and says it is in discussions with them about forming a patent pool. Google claims all essential patents in VP8 were held by On2, the company it acquired in 2010. If MPEG LA can indeed create a pool ‘ or if some of the dozen IPR holders take out lawsuits ‘ that would rob WebM of its chief appeal against H.264. Most seriously, H.264 cannot be incorporated into HTML5 standards for native video, as the W3C standards body does not accept royalty bearing technologies.