Apple passed Exxon as the world’s most valuable company this week and closed down the world’s largest retailer’s online music operation. Back in 2008, Walmart made some of its customers angry by nearly shutting down some DRM servers for its music service that could’ve left its customers in silence. Walmart ended up relenting and keeping the servers up and running, but that was the last time most people thought about the Walmart Music Download Store until this week.
Walmart’s MP3 downfall comes from never catching up to Apple’s iTunes and the market shifting toward streaming services like Spotify and Pandora. Walmart has announced that after eight years the company will close its service on August 28, 2011. ‘All content in the Store will be disabled and no longer available for download,’ the company said.
Walmart will continue to sell physical CDs in its stores and online plus its streaming music service Soundcheck. Walmart will even keep up those old DRM servers so its customers don’t lose access to their music. Walmart sold MP3s for 88 cents, 11 cents cheaper than most of its competition, but it has never gained much ground, even despite being one of the few early competitors to iTunes.
Walmart never developed an easy, coherent way to manage and organize purchased music or even the purchase process. Users had to enter their credit card information and download destinations with each purchase, and Walmart provided no support for integrating these tracks into their existing music library.
It seems that in digital music a coherent platform like iTunes is more useful than a small price difference. Let’s hope it has better success with its Vudu online video service.