Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 August 2011

The slow pace of US TV Everywhere has Fox pulling content from Hulu

We now hear that DirecTV has gone lukewarm over the idea of buying Hulu. Not much of a surprise if you read our discussion last week which paralleled Hulu to a perennial orphan about to be taken into care. And now, in a story breaking this week about Fox pulling some of its shows from Hulu, we begin to see just how precarious the future of Hulu is, and it will suffer, as we always thought it might, from its individual parents putting their advertising needs first.

This is being widely seen as the reason for Fox Broadcasting pushing back content at least 8 days on Hulu, although allowing it to run on TV Everywhere cable authenticated systems and on Hulu Plus. In each case Fox wants to be sure that someone, somewhere, is paying it money to watched its leading programs.

Dish Network has agreed to add Fox shows to its TV Everywhere service, which as far as we can see is a hybrid, part TV Everywhere web based service, part placeshifting. Fox isn’t even showing its own shows at Fox.com for at least 8 days, during which time it can be seen on Hulu Plus and on any TV Everywhere service which has included Fox programming.

On the Fox.com site instead of the programming, Fox provides a notice and a table of suppliers to tick and a form letter to sign, all online, so that their voice can be heard telling their MSO to cut a deal with Fox. Fox presumably wants advantageous access to advertising revenue from its deals with MSOs, which is perhaps why it hasn’t signed many MSOs as yet.

Clearly then Fox will have control of its own destiny, a combination of paid delivery and advertising, around its top programming, with no-one getting free access to catch up content.

But the net result is a weakening of Hulu content, which will slow its own advertising momentum, which if it happened more often with other broadcast networks, would damage its own advertising pull and cut its revenues. It would be interesting to see the contracts which allow a supplier to just suddenly pull a major chunk of content? Perhaps it relies on content on its own web site also being on Hulu, which is perhaps why Fox has pulled it from both, since it can monetize its own website advertising, and has control of that as a resource. But if it has to mirror content availability on Hulu from its web site, then it may have been necessary to pull it from its own site.

There is no progress in the news this week that Hulu is up for sale, but if there are more stories along this line it could find itself dismantled through death by a thousand cuts, rather than sold off with a firm content mandate from its parents and contributors.

Fox has complained that the industry has been slow to move toward a TV Everywhere environment, which must be galling for Fox, itself owned by News Corp, which in turn has seen the process work well in the UK through Sky TV (where it has been available for five years) and which has just added it at Sky Germany.