Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 August 2011

Siano and Chinese chip maker Innofidei make friends, play nice

Chinese fabless chip designer Innofidei has settled what we always thought was a weak patent infringement case, in its native China, against mobile chip leader Siano Mobile Silicon

The case spilled out of China into the US last November when Israeli specialist Siano filed an action in the US District Court for Northern California, against the Innofidei CEO Tom Zhang and CTO Stanley Wang.

Innofidei had effectively been running a smear campaign in China, frustrated that Siano has managed to snatch the majority market share in the growing CMMB mobile TV chip business there. Innofidei began telling major customers that it was planning an intellectual property legal action against Siano, which it launched in May 2010, aimed at politically damaging it in the eyes of Chinese authorities

In China every company has to have a card carrying government member on its board, keeping an eye on the political correctness of the company under Chinese law. Get the wrong side of such a character and you can lose your license to carry out business. So Siano decided to counter sue in California where Innofidei took $10 million in investment from BlueRun Ventures in California to fund R&D.

Now the patent infringement suit and the counter move by Siano have both been talked through and various promises made to keep the peace, and all actions are dropped. Although the release says that this is out of mutual respect for each other’s Intellectual Property Rights, the design of CMMB, the Chinese mobile TV chip technology belong to SARFT (the Chinese State Administration of Radio Film and TV) and Siano has far smaller, lower power chips than any other specialist in this market, about half the area of the Innofidei chips, so we’re not sure what it might have copied.

The statement said that ‘Innofidei and Siano have acknowledged and expressed respect for each other as viable and important suppliers of MDTV receivers for the CMMB market and other markets. Siano and Innofidei acknowledge and recognize the Intellectual Property Rights independently developed and owned by each other or licensed from third parties. In addition, both companies have reiterated their commitments to combating unfair competition.’

All disputes in China and the United States have been resolved, including the patent infringement lawsuit started by Innofidei against Siano and Garmin in May 2010 in China, and the patents invalidation applications and appeals by Garmin and Siano before the Patent Re-examination Board, and Siano’s lawsuit against Innofidei in California for anti-competitive behavior.’

When we last looked shipments of devices with CMMB mobile TV chips in them were running at about 1 million a month, and Siano claims a majority market share at around 50%.