When Samsung cited the movie ‘2001: A Space Odyssey’ and the British TV series ‘The Tomorrow People’ as evidence that Apple did not invent the iPad-style tablet form factor, the current patents saga moved on to a new stage of surrealism. But the fight over every last millimeter of a product’s shape ‘ even to the extent, it is said, that Apple has doctored photographs to make the Galaxy Tab look more like the iPad ‘ show just how much is at stake for the mobile vendors, and the lengths to which they will go to defend their ground.
Because Android is at the eye of the current patents hurricane, it is easy to assume that all the legal actions directed against it are the same. But in fact there are two distinct issues at stake here. One is the aggressive use of patents to disrupt a rival platform, either by claiming steep royalties (Microsoft) or trying to shut products down (Apple). This war has sparked the recent IPR arms race, as the major players seek to gain the upper hand in deployable weapons. In many ways, Android is perceived as the ‘innocent party’ here, because most of the actions have been instigated by its pressurized rivals, and because its backers are generally the underdog in IPR terms.
The other issue casts Android in a less friendly light, and that is the one highlighted by Oracle’s lawsuit against Google, and by various critics from the Linux and open source communities. These varying criticisms add up to the overall charge that Google has used its market power to establish a supposedly open platform but then broken many of the rules of open source, even while making it virtually impossible for other open platforms to compete.
Google has, indeed, tried to steer a difficult middle path between the free-for-all of the open source ideal and the control of Apple or Microsoft. Yet, from very early on, it seemed to be tapping into the free efforts of the open source community while often refusing to give it very much back. From the start, its own sourcecode changes have often been released tardily or, as with Honeycomb, to only a few partners. Android strayed so far from its Linux roots as to be relegated to a ‘fork’ (a variant that is rejected by the mainline community) in February 2010, when its driver code was deleted from the Linux kernel. This made Android incompatible with the project’s main tree, unlike ‘purer’ mobile implementations like MeeGo. Forking is not necessarily a bad thing, but combined with poorly communicated updates and an early shortage of native Linux tools, Google is increasingly accused of betraying the open source ideals it professed to support. This, in turn, may lay its developers open to hidden complications in terms of licensing terms and charges.
For instance, Peter Vescuso of open source management firm Black Duck Software told the LinuxCon developer event that, while Android is offered under the Apache and GPL open source licences, the OS has components referencing a total of 19 such licences. Even single projects used within Android, like Bionic or WebKit, can have more than a dozen licences attached to them, some of which may not be certified by the Open Source Initiative, said Vescuso, as reported by NetworkWorld. The obligations in these licences apply to device makers and independent developers, not just Google.
“The issue with open source software is technical decisions have compliance and legal obligations that you need to be aware of,” Vescuso said. This highlights what the legal battles over Android have already made clear ‘ that compliance and licensing issues in open source are often more complex than in controlled environments, despite Google’s promotion of Android as being cheap, open and simple, compared to a platform like WP7.
Examples cited in the presentation included the apparently well-known open source condition that, if anyone modifies the licensed code, they must make those changes available to the whole community. Many are ignoring this, deliberately or through negligence, argued the speaker ‘ and some, of course, claim Google plays hard and fast with open source rules itself, by releasing its own code enhancements on a selective basis, most notoriously with the staggered sharing of Honeycomb. “My sense is many of the lawsuits in the open source community have been around the most basic compliance,” Vescuso said. “You change the code, and don’t make the sourcecode available.” The Linux Foundation is trying to ease the pain by creating a new specification for tracking licence compliance.
One of the ways in which Google chose to follow a non-mainstream course for Android ‘ thus keeping control to itself ‘ was in adopting its own Dalvik virtual machine rather than the mainstream Java VM from Sun (now Oracle). This led to many tensions with the Java community, and the platform which had, before Android, had the best claim to span a wide variety of mobile devices. This helped lead to the lawsuit by Oracle against Google, the only Android-related action to target the search giant itself, and one of the most threatening to ordinary Android developers, as opposed to large OEMs.
This week, Oracle has fired its latest shots in a bitter war of words, with chief corporate architect Edward Screven claiming that Google has prevented Java from competing effectively on smartphones by adopting a different VM and therefore fragmenting the platform. In papers filed as part of the ongoing litigation, he used this argument to justify the actions against Google, insisting they were not aggressive, but designed to remove restrictions on Oracle’s own ability to compete in the smartphone segment with Java.
Google executives have accused Oracle, Apple and others of creating a concerted, unprovoked and hostile legal attack with the express aim of killing Android. Whatever the truth of that for Apple and Microsoft, Oracle says that, were it just using the law courts as aggressive competitive weapons, it would have sued Apple too ‘ but ‘Apple did not create a fragmented and infringing implementation of Java’.
Instead, Screven argues that Android “has basically foreclosed” any successful move by Java from its featurephone base into smartphones. He writes in the filing: “I don’t believe that there is a strategy that we could adopt at this point… to displace Android given that they’ve sucked all the air out of the room for Java on smartphones.” He adds: “They’ve now shipped on millions and millions of handsets. That’s going to make it difficult for Oracle or anyone else who wants to ship a licensed Java implementation for smartphones to succeed.”
Of course, the fact that the smartphone base has split between Dalvik and JVM is not the only reason why Java has not repeated its low end handset success on smartphones. Oracle has been repeatedly accused of paying scant attention to the mobile platform since acquiring Sun and Java; Java was highly fragmented long before Google came along; and Sun was far less effective than Google in galvanizing its community to keep the platform fully current with the requirements of the modern mobile software world. Screven put his finger on it when he said during his deposition: “Sun built some great technologies, but they weren’t particularly good at bringing them to market’, adding that Oracle was, by contrast, ‘very focused on making money’.
However, the ambivalent policies of Google ‘ and, to be fair, Microsoft ‘ towards mobile Java have given it less latitude to regroup and emerge as a cross-platform environment for the high end mobile devices. And if the success of Android can be shown to have built partly on technologies patented and copyrighted for another open source offering, Java, then Oracle’s case will certainly be raising more deep-rooted and important issues than the spats between the handset makers.
Those spats hit the headlines far more than the more abstruse arguments over software code that may or may not have been stolen or copied. The coming month will be a critical one for the smartphone business. Apple and Samsung are to fight it out in the German courts, and if successful in winning an injunction, could exclude its rival from the entire holiday period in Europe. Already, a Dutch judge has granted a temporary ban on the Galaxy S, S II and Ace, which is the first EU-wide patent ruling against Android, and so carries deep significance ‘ even though the vendor can work around it (for now). The two giants are also battling at the US International Trade Commission (ITC), where this week will also see the start of hearings between Microsoft and Motorola Mobility.
The first of the Motorola-Microsoft suits to hit the ITC concerns Motorola’s alleged infringement of nine Microsoft wireless patents, a complaint filed in October 2010, and is scheduled to run from August 22 to August 31. A judge will make an initial ruling in November, but that will not be binding ‘ though the preliminary judgements are often important indicators. However they are only enforceable if the full ITC committee confirms them, a decision likely to be taken next March. Unlike federal IPR cases, there are no countersuits at the ITC ‘ each complaint is treated separately.
In general, Microsoft has sought to destabilize Android by demanding licensing fees for the IPR it claims to hold in the OS, via its Linux patents. In particular, it has announced such a deal with HTC and is chasing one, rumored to be about $15 a handset, for Samsung. As well as creating a revenue stream, this makes Android less attractive by adding to an OEM’s costs, killing the notion that it is a ‘free’ operating system, and removing one of its key advantages over Microsoft’s own WP7. But the software giant has been more aggressive against Motorola, following its October complaints (at the ITC and in federal court in Washington state) with a further suit, related to wireless and video codec patents, in November. This one, filed in the Western District of Washington, alleges that Motorola failed to comply with RAND (reasonable and non-discriminatory) licensing commitments which the phonemaker had made to standards bodies such as the IEEE and ITU.
Motorola filed three lawsuits of its own in two federal courts, and Microsoft hit back with further counterclaims, made in southern Florida in December (subsequently transferred to Washington) and covering a further seven patents. Patent analysts say the venue change is not just a technicality ‘ it gives Microsoft ‘home ground advantage’ and delays the hearings so that no federal decision will have been taken before the ITC’s final ruling in March.
A victory for Microsoft would add to the burdens that Google will acquire along with Motorola Mobility, though that sale is unlikely to be finalized before the ITC decisions. It certainly indicates why Microsoft was reportedly keen to purchase the Motorola patents itself, to weaken Android further. However, an even more important indicator of MMI’s true value to Google will come from decisions in its fight with Apple. That battle centers on 18 patents, within a portfolio of over 17,000, which analysts see as the crown jewels for Google ‘ especially if they secure victory in court over the iPhone maker.
These 18 assets are the stars of the collection, patent lawyer David Mixon of Bradley Arant Boult Cummings told Bloomberg. They cover location services, antenna design, email transmission, touchscreen motions, application management and 3G. The last category may be especially worrying to Apple, which does not have major stores of wireless specific IPR and lost a case against Nokia, also centered on such patent areas, earlier this year.
Motorola Mobility sued Apple in October when it filed three lawsuits and an ITC complaint targeting the iPhone 4, iPad, AppleTV and MacBook Air. Motorola also won a case against RIM last year, involving four of the 18 star patents. Apple countersued at the ITC and in federal court in Madison, Wisconsin. And it filed a civil suit in March accusing MMI of ‘a pattern of unfair, deceptive and anti-competitive conduct’, claiming ‘ in an echo of the Microsoft allegations ‘ that the handset maker demanded higher licensing fees from Apple that from other competitors over three years of talks.
A more immediate impact on the mobile industry will be felt from the Apple-Samsung spats, and the German court at the heart of recent developments, the Dusseldorf Regional Court, will start to hear oral arguments this week. This body had granted Apple a temporary injunction against sales and marketing of the Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 across the EU, but it then reversed its decision a week later on the grounds that it only had authority to impose such a ban in Germany.
That was followed this week by a ban imposed by a Dutch court on imports of the Galaxy S, S II and Ace smartphones (not to the Galaxy Tab). This is a significant blow to the wider Android defence against Apple’s aggressive patents lawsuits. While many of the Galaxy actions focus on ‘design patents’ rather than technological IPR, this ruling centers on an Apple patent related to scrolling actions and the browsing gallery. The court rejected all Apple’s other claims, including those that Samsung violated registered designs, copyrights and style imitation. Nevertheless, this is the ‘first enforceable software patent court decision worldwide against Android devices’, argues intellectual property analyst Florian Mueller on his FOSS Patents blog.
The Dutch judgement bars sales of the three smartphones across the European Union from October 13, on the basis that one of the Apple patents in question is likely to be infringed by “one or more of the applications that ship with Android and without which the usefulness of Android would be impaired’. It is not clear whether that patent is also implicated in the recent preliminary ruling against HTC, in Apple’s case at the US International Trade Commission (ITC), where it is also suing Samsung. If upheld, that injunction could prevent the Taiwanese vendor importing its Android smartphones to the US.
The Dutch ruling, while important in its implications, does not represent immediate disaster for Samsung ‘ it applies to certain Dutch subsidiaries of Samsung, and so the Korean giant can reorganize its logistics, and says it will work to ensure a consistent supply across the EU ‘ though with Holland being a major distribution hub for the firm, this will not be a simple task.
A Samsung spokesperson said in a statement that the ruling against Apple on design was ‘an affirmation that the Galaxy range of products is innovative and distinctive’, and added: ‘With regard to the single infringement cited in the ruling, we will take all possible measures including legal action to ensure that there is no disruption in the availability of our Galaxy smartphones to Dutch consumers. The ruling is not expected to affect sales in other European markets.”
Samsung South Korea which can still import its devices anywhere in Europe except The Netherlands, and, in the case of the Tab, Germany, after the previous ruling. That was overturned because of doubts over whether a German court could impose such a decision on the whole EU, when the vendor was not an EU supplier. And it remains unclear whether the pending German decisions on patent infringement will apply across the EU’s 27 states. A ban that extended over the region through the holiday quarter could rob Samsung of at least 10% of its projected tablet sales for 2011, say analysts. Courts in EU member states can issue certain IPR-related rulings that affect the whole region, but the scope of the Dusseldorf judgement will only be finally decided once the court announces its decision, expected to be about three weeks after the hearing on August 25.
The key complication is that the law allows for a pan-EU ruling against Samsung’s German unit, but not necessarily its Korean parent firm. Magnus Hirsch, an IP lawyer at SKW Schwarz in Germany, told Bloomberg: ‘You can sue a non-EU based company if it has a subsidiary here. But Samsung’s German unit was set up as an independent company so it probably doesn’t count.’
Apple’s fall-back plan will be to sue separately in each major market (as it has in The Netherlands). It may also seek an EU-wide injunction in a Spanish court, where the agency that registered the design patent is based. Apple won the temporary ban originally by invoking a so-called EU design (because it was registered with the European trademarks and design office in Spain). It is generally easier to revoke an EU design than a US design patent, although as the Dutch decision shows, technical patents usually carry more weight. Samsung, experts say, missed a trick by not disputing Apple’s design filing back in 2004, a fairly routine process in the EU. ‘A tablet is flat and has a touch screen. It’s difficult to picture how you can make one that looks fundamentally different,’ said one lawyer ‘ but Apple’s case may be strengthened by the fact that its rival had not previously challenged its design filing for a tablet shape.
It made similar points in a new filing against Apple’s attempts to get a US injunction from the ITC. This is where it refers to personal tablets used by astronauts in the 1968 film ‘2001: A Space Odyssey’, which are seen to have ‘an overall rectangular shape with a dominant display screen, narrow borders, a predominately flat front surface, a flat back surface ‘and a thin form factor’ ‘ in other words, rather like an iPad. Samsung also cites a scene from the 1970s TV series ‘The Tomorrow People’ depicting a tablet computer as prior art because it has a similar shape and appearance to that outlined in the Apple design patent at the heart of its case.
It may not be long before we see Samsung starting to deploy its own impressive arsenal of wireless IPR more aggressively against Apple, not because these would be like-for-like IPR, but because it could pressurize the iPhone maker (whose weakness in wireless specific patents was seen this year in its Nokia climbdown) to call off some of its legal dogs. Generally, though, the Samsung-Apple case is unusual because it centers mainly on design rather than technology patents. The other handset litigations are more conventional and will be decided largely on the balance of power that the combatants can amass in terms of patent power.
Hence the recent bubble in valuations of IPR-heavy companies and the race to acquire new assets. Nortel, Motorola Mobility, a clutch of IBM patents and several small firms have already gone on the block, and the next big prize may be InterDigital, a giant of 3GPP-related intellectual property. The firm will be disappointed that it did not secure the Google billions, but it is still in play, with Nokia and Qualcomm possibly among the stalkers. According to the Reuters news agency, these two wireless patent powerhouses are part of a long list of suitors for InterDigital, and an auction is set to be held just after Labor Day. The date has reportedly been put back from next week to give interested parties more time to conduct due diligence.
Some analysts think Google could still bid, and it has not yet withdrawn its statement of interest. However, a purchase would surely be overkill on top of its $12.5bn Motorola Mobility takeover and its previous acquisition of a range of IBM patents. Apple and Samsung are also in the frame, say observers, for obvious reasons given their current legal stand-offs.
InterDigital, Qualcomm, Nokia, Ericsson and Motorola were the dominant owners of essential IPR in 2G and 3G standards, though their influence is likely to be diluted in LTE, where Samsung, Huawei and others have a greater stake. If Nokia or Qualcomm were to succeed, either would enhance their position in wireless specific IPR, though not in the software and user experience technologies that increasingly drive mobile power. A Nokia win would indirectly hit at Apple and Android because of the firm’s closeness to WP7 and Microsoft.
Qualcomm would be neutral in terms of the current IPR wars, and it is a sign of the new mobile order that the prospect of its victory seems appealing, because if would help halt the escalation of the Google-Apple-Microsoft landgrab. In the past, any addition to Qualcomm’s massive patent power was viewed with widespread suspicion, but it has been strangely quiet during the recent IPR dramas, and now appears as a voice of reason, a company which works with all handset camps and, at least, uses most of its patents to innovate, not only to hurl at rivals.
Patent activists are stepping up the campaign to hit back against purely aggressive IPR activity, and in particular to place restrictions on how Apple and others can exploit the IPR they acquired in Nortel’s bankruptcy sale. The lobbying is being led by the Open Invention Network (OIN), whose head Keith Bergelt is asking the Department of Justice to impose the same kind of conditions that it did over Novell’s patents.
Bergelt is calling on developers and users to create a barrage of communications to the DoJ to indicate the strength of industry nervousness about the current patents arms race in the wireless world, especially the $4.5bn purchase of Nortel’s arsenal by a consortium including Apple and Microsoft. The pending sale is currently under regulatory scrutiny but the group hopes to close the deal by the end of next month.
The key issue is how aggressively the new owners might deploy the patents to weaken Android and other open source mobile platforms, by spreading fear and doubt among supporters and raising licensing charges. Bergelt believes that Microsoft and Apple aim to use their new IPR assets to create a “tax” on open source mobile platforms, pushing Android charges beyond those for WP7.
“The license fee is $15 for WP7. These companies are looking for $30/$40/$50 of licensing ‘tax’ to try and change the behaviors of device makers and carriers. There’s a point where Android becomes uneconomic,” Begelt told attendees at the LinuxCon event, as reported by NetworkWorld. He argued that the $4.5bn price paid for the patents is far more than the licensing revenue they could generate and therefore the only motivation to buy them must have been aggressive. Apple reportedly contributed the largest part of the price, at about 50% of the total, while RIM injected $770m and Ericsson $340m.
In April, the DoJ limited the extent to which Microsoft could exploit its newly acquired Novell patents by making them subject to both the GPL and the OIN open source licence terms. This in effect converted them into defensive patents only, as patents covered by the OIN cannot be used to collect royalties. Bergelt argues that a similar decision for the Nortel IPR would mean that their purchasers would be able to use them to innovate but not to go after rivals aggressively. However, infringement suits ‘ Apple’s key tactic, rather than revenue collection ‘ would still be possible.
Bergelt wants to broaden the submissions to the DoJ to cover developers’ experiences of any instances where the buyers have allegedly misused their patent position. In particular, he is looking for reports of ‘threatening, illegal behavior’ such as threats to developers that they could lose authorized status if they supported Android. In his speech, he said Microsoft prefers “working hand-in-hand in a conspiratorial fashion with companies they understand, like Apple. They would rather have a duopoly then have the gross uncertainty of open source.’
The conditions attached to the Novell patent sale set a new precedent for the DoJ, which has given hope to campaigners like Bergelt. Previously, the agency had only taken action reactively, when fair competition rules had already been breached.