Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 September 2011

Google TV not just coming to the UK, but destined for everywhere

As usual the tabloids and the cut and paste brigade took the best quotes out of Eric Schmidt’s MacTaggart lecture at the Edinburgh TV Festival this week and told us that Google TV was coming to the UK. But there was a lot of insight into how Google thinks in that lecture, some good, some not so good in our view so we took a look through the whole thing. What we see is that Google TV is still at the forefront of Google thinking, that it is expected to be every bit as successful as Android has been in handsets and that Schmidt expects an out and out victory in TV.

So yes Google is coming to the UK. It was after-all a UK targeted speech, but what Schmidt actually said was to Europe and he simply said that the UK would be one of the early targets. What he didn’t address in any detail whatsoever was whether or not this would be version 2 of Google TV, taking in all the criticisms that have seen it virtually laughed out of stores in the US, or whether it would simply be the same interface. Our bet goes on a revamped product.

What he did say about it was that Google TV was an attempt to offer an open platform so that the next generation of TV can emerge. And earlier in his address he pointed to two concrete things that Google ‘might’ do. He mentioned Google+ (GooglePlus) the company’s new social networking rival to Facebook, and said that watching TV in a Google+ ‘hangout’ was almost designed for watching TV. In a hangout, which is a one click invite to a multimedia conference, people can talk to one another while watching TV, as well as send instant messages and any one of them could grab the TV controls at any point in time to pause, rewind or replay.

He also mentioned the company’s view that given a users’ permission Google could develop a TV recommendation system almost as a single, perfect TV channel. Schmidt is saying that by having a record of everything you watch (and like), a far better recommendation system can be built ‘ which of course is true. Interestingly Google doesn’t keep a track of all your searches (Err yes it does) and then use them to improve your Google search responses (Oh, well no it doesn’t), so why should it do this to improve your TV recommendations?

Of course software which offers to help in the choice of a TV program is asking you to commit upwards of an hour to the decision, so knowing more about what you like might come in handy. Google can’t do this for textual web searches for the simple reason that it HAS to be able to demonstrate that each search brings the same result to ALL searchers, or it risks losing its biggest revenue plank, search advertising.

If different people were to get different results from a Google text search (at the same point in time), how would anybody know that they were getting their money’s worth when they use search advertising or if their SEO strategy was going well?

We have a problem with this, the suggestion that algorithms can help us choose TV programming better than our friends can. Right now Facebook is the place to drive TV recommendations, through friend contact, not through algorithmic calculations based on what you have seen in the past. Okay, both is perhaps even better, but there are other issues.

What happens if you have just spent two days watching rugby with your mates and now you want to watch something with your girlfriend, boyfriend or granny. The recommendation system will need to be able to discount certain prior activities, and then switch them back on again. Effectively moods need to be catered for, or what Google calls Circles, in this case viewing circles. Your TV recommendation viewing needs to be associated with a circle of friends and another set of recommendations within different circles.

Whatever, Schmidt is not going to be talking about this at a highly publicized media event unless this is a route down which Google wants to go. And he would not have raised it in the same discussion with Google TV, if the next version doesn’t come with all this included. So expect that to hit Europe early next year.

TV Hangouts drawing on some form of recommendation system for the entire group has got to be tricky, but Google is probably the right company to take that problem on. Would it end up taking us down the route where filters become so narrow that we end up living in a bubble of our own prejudice, he asks? No claims Schmidt, because even algorithms can have serendipity built in. So whenever you get a TV recommendation on a future Google TV box, which just makes no sense, think of it as Google inflicted serendipity. That’s like calling a bug in a software program an ‘undocumented feature.’

Either it brings you what you want to watch or it doesn’t. Perhaps it would have a Serendipity button a bit like that ‘I’m feeling lucky’ button on the Google home page that no-one ever presses any more.

If we add all of this to the fact that Motorola has just acquired the dominant US cable TV set top supplier in Motorola Mobility, then you can see that there is a significant amount of IPR that can be taken from such a Google TV system, and transplanted lock, stock and barrel into the existing US cable TV paradigm, without taking the core proposition, which is that Google TV allows the consumer to search for, find and view any video anywhere on the web. Cable operators may not like the core proposition from Google TV, but accessing algorithms that allow for really smart integration with social networking, as well as individual and group recommendations, that might attract them.

Of course Facebook right now is ahead in this quest since Google+ is so new, and nothing like so widely used as Facebook and as much as we like it, may never be. So what someone like Comcast might be interested in are algorithms which offer recommendation alongside Facebook friends’ suggestions. Maybe Google will have to find a way to integrate with Facebook for now, while it grows the Google + base. We would say that’s almost a certainty in the next Google TV.

Schmidt lampooned the red button approaches of YouView and HbbTV, ‘The red button is pretty limited, consumers want real interactivity now.’ And he added that everything in the future is going to be mobile, local and social and reminded everyone that we are scarcely at the end of the first internet age with many more changes and ages coming.

He did throw in some howlers which we can thank his research team for. Broadcast linear TV will last forever, look there has been no dent in it from the humble DVR (citing highly contentious figures from Nielsen which claims that 90% of TV is still watched ‘live’). Of course Schmidt is wrong about this, and whoever helped him write that speech hadn’t realized how much of a vested interest Nielsen has for this to be true, so much so that it can disregard quite a few of the facts.

Much of the rest of the Schmidt speech was so much confetti, sucking up to the broadcasting industry and the UK generally. He said how talented they all were, and how if Google staff were to create content, it would be a huge collection of bad sci-fi ‘ but he did hit on one key argument, whether or not the internet in general was a force for good.

Schmidt is convinced that it is, but he acknowledged that many businesses, the media industry included, seem to have come off worst for wear after their initial run-ins with the internet. But in reminding us that in less than 30 years (most of which is down to the last 10 years) the internet has reached 2 billion people from zero. He claimed that the internet had added £100 billion to the UK’s GDP, some 7% of its total, in what was one of many slips into the highly local market of where he was speaking. Yes but how many jobs have been lost to US services delivered over the internet? He never went there ‘ it’s just progress.

Companies that work with the internet grow 4 times faster than those who don’t he said, but since every company works with the internet, whether they like it or not, that’s sort of rubbish Eric ‘ think about it.

Our biggest problem with Google in general is that search rankings take into account how big a company is, how long its internet history is, where it’s servers are based and how many people are currently going to its web site regularly. This tends to mean that older businesses are better supported by Google and companies on US servers are also better supported by Google search. This is actually an anchor weighing down innovation, since most new business these days comes from the web. So if it takes a company 7 or 8 years to build a web presence which Google finally ranks high enough to be seen, it takes forever to build a business. At Faultline we call this the Google tax. In order to get Google on your side in search, you have to spend money to get it there, but first you have to make money without Google’s help in order to pay for the SEO adventure that will get you higher on Google. Less talented, but older companies get all the hits already so it becomes a tax on innovation.

Another area that Schmidt touched on was how currently, it is some anonymous scheduler who makes decisions about when TV programs are shown, and how this is going out of style and how this is a nanny model.

What perhaps he hasn’t quite realized is that this is all about advertising. A TV channel offers an expensive and highly popular program to attract audiences and then puts less expensive programming on afterwards to throw advertising at those people who cannot be bothered to switch to another channel. It’s not a nanny model, but a model built to milk the audience and get the most advertising cash from the lowest content spend ‘ all of which explains why good content is so sparse on TV. But in a Google TV world that should be a thing of the past.

Think about that for a minute. If you only ever watch good programs, then all of those cheap programs, just designed to soak up couch potato eyeballs, they just disappear. If a tool like Google helps you channel hop to good programming, then there is no residual viewing on the rubbish programs which are put on after blockbuster programming in the linear environment. That would be good for viewers, but it points to a radical upheaval of broadcast content, and a dramatic rift between the richest and poorest TV programs.

In such a world the TV audience stays the same size but more of them watch quality programming and less watch poor or cheap programming. That will lead to a huge number of TV programs no longer being made. But he’s right, that will take years and years, potentially decades, but it IS coming. So back to that ‘the internet is a force for good’ argument ‘ yes for the consumer, but whole industries will be swept aside in the process. Painful even if it is inevitable.

Schmidt has been quoted, since he gave the MacTaggart Lecture, by Canadian newspaper the Globe and Mail, saying that both Sony and Logitech remain ‘on board’ with Google TV and that it has ‘many more’ partners coming on board which will be announced imminently, and that Google TV would move from a standalone set-top box to being incorporated within all brands of TV sets within five years. ‘Virtually all the TV manufacturers on their very high end will eventually adopt Google TV… or perhaps one of the competitors that will emerge,’ said Schmidt.