Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 September 2011

Amazon has to be radical in tablets, but will Apple dare sue?

Hewlett-Packard proved one point with the fire sale of its discontinued TouchPad tablet – the high market demand for a non-iPad model, provided the price tag was sufficiently low. So popular were the $99 and $149 TouchPads that the vendor agreed to make one last batch to address pent-up demand (or to use up excess component inventory and keep partners happy, depending which angle you take).

Clearly, the $100 tablet was a loss-maker for HP, borne of an abrupt and poorly managed decision to change its device strategy. But some companies could actually base a business model around a low cost iPad challenger, chief among them being Amazon. The retailer is expected to unveil its own Android tablets soon (and could even prove a new home for HP’s webOS, whose future remains uncertain). It is hotly tipped to be the most impactful non-iPad launch to date, because – unlike pure hardware makers – it does not need to make a profit on its devices, as long as they drive sufficient consumption of its digital content products.

This has been proven by Amazon’s first foray into own-branded devices, with the Kindle ereader. The price of that product has steadily fallen, and in some cases it is given away for a nominal price with a content commitment such as a newspaper subscription. Some innovative pricing, and bundling with content or cloud services like Amazon’s music and video streaming offerings, could enable it to undercut every tablet on the market while keeping the hardware specs within the Apple ballpark. And apart from Apple itself, no other supplier understands quite as well how to create a simple and appealing web user experience, designed to encourage greater consumption of digital media.

The current ‘iPad killer’, the Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1, remains overshadowed by the risk of injunctions as a result of Apple’s frantic lawsuits, and it will be interesting to see whether the Cupertino lawyers start to throw their weapons at Amazon once its slate appears. The two companies were once allies but are now going head-to-head in a variety of areas – from their disputes over in-app purchasing in the App Store to their cloud content services. In the former respect, Amazon will be one of the most powerful companies in pushing users to replace downloaded apps and content, the cornerstone of Apple’s revenue model and subscriber/developer control, with HTML5 web services. And in the latter, the retailer has so far stolen a march in cloud content, but Apple’s iCloud will soon debut a music streaming offering to expand the iTunes offering into Amazon’s heartland.

Most of the Apple-Amazon battles are commercial rather than legal at this stage, apart from a lawsuit against Amazon’s use of the term ‘AppStore’, which Apple claims to have trademarked, for its Android shopfront. But the fights could shift to the law courts on the appearance of the tablet, the most head-on assault on Apple’s mobile dominance to date. A distinctive shape or design could keep Amazon safe from the claims of design patent infringement which are causing Samsung grief in many courts, but although the retailer is expected to create a unique user interface on top of Android, it will presumably use some of the basis elements of the Google OS, which are the subject of patent attacks from Apple and Microsoft, against Motorola, HTC and others, including the other major ereader player, Barnes &
Noble.

Despite all this, Amazon may be a bite too far for Apple’s legal team (and funds), given the intense anticipation of the tablet in the key US market, and the power of the web giant’s brand. But the threat to the iPad will be real. Analysts at Forrester Research believe Amazon will sell 5m tablets in the fourth quarter alone, and researcher Sarah Rotman Epps wrote in a blog post: “Amazon’s willingness to sell hardware at a loss, combined with the strength of its brand, content, cloud infrastructure and commerce assets makes it the only credible iPad competitor in the market.”

Pricing will be vital of course and Amazon probably needs to undercut the iPad by about 50% to make the maximum impact without venturing into ‘cheap and cheerful’ territory and devaluing the device (or risking confusion with the Kindle). “If Amazon launches a tablet at a sub-$300 price point – assuming it has enough supply to meet demand – we see Amazon selling 3-5m tablets in Q4 alone,” Rotman Epps added. The Amazon tailwind would also boost the number of tablet optimized Android applications, which has remained disappointing in Android Market at only about 300 items.

So how will Microsoft fare, as it hesitates while Android rivals leap ahead? The Windows giant is firmly on the back foot in the fashionable tablets sector but, at a developer event in New Zealand, it offered a glimpse of a quad-core slate, which could be the flagship for a new assault on this space when Windows 8 launches next year.

Spotted by ZDnet, the slate could get a higher profile introduction at the upcoming Build conference. Microsoft has been virtually a no-show in tablets, despite a few Windows 7 slates being launched, because it has kept WP7 off the large-screen format. This was partly to avoid the problems Android encountered on big displays before it had a tablet optimized version in Honeycomb, but it has frustrated some OEMs and wasted an opportunity to showcase WP7’s innovative user interface on a larger screen and in a market where the battle lines are not firmly set yet.

With Windows 8, Microsoft will have an OS that spans PCs, tablets and smartphones; ARM and Intel architectures; and touch or conventional displays. Previews and even some beta release elements of the OS are expected to be offered to developers at Build, and there is now speculation that attendees will get the quad-core slate prototypes to run the test build. Even if the product is not due for commercial release for many months, it could help to keep Windows developers loyal and to build confidence among OEMs and other partners that Microsoft will be tablet player in the second wave of the market.

According to IT consultant and TechEd attendee Alan Burchill, Microsoft’s Patrick Hevesi, its enterprise technology architect, told the conference that quad-core Windows slates with eight-hour battery life, 10-inch HD screens and 1080p playback would make their debut late this year. These would presumably run Windows 7 and be W8-ready, and the description sounds similar to products promised by Asus (with its Eee Pad Transformer line) among others.

As for the processors, the first Windows/ARM products larger than smartphones could run on silicon from Nvidia, Texas Instruments, Qualcomm or even ST-Ericsson, all of which have promised quad-core around the turn of the year. Nvidia is already stealing a march on its rivals in the ARM/Android tablet space, and analysts at Strategy Analytics estimate it has almost 35% share of the non-iPad segment which itself accounted for 39% of total tablet volumes in the first quarter of this year.

The researchers say Nvidia seized the advantage with its Tegra 2 dual-core processor, which pipped similar platforms to the post in the Honeycomb market, running on the ARM Cortex A9 platform. Analyst Sravan Kundojjala says he estimates that Nvidia’s non-iPad tablet apps processor share increased to 48.6% in the second quarter, with Tegra 2 appearing in the Motorola Xoom, Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 and 8.9, Dell Streak 7, LG Optimus Pad 3D, Acer Iconia Tab 500 and Asus Eee Pad Transformer. The rest of the top five outside Apple is made up of Qualcomm, TI, Samsung and Intel, though the last of these was confined to Windows and so notched up only 5% of the total. Intel is expected to support Android tablets from later this year.