A small line from Apple filings in the HTC patent infringement case in the US, shows that Apple is not only thinking of suing Google directly, but individuals who work there.
Apple so far has preferred to fire legal broadsides against Android partners such as Samsung and HTC rather than take Google on head on, but now it’s saying that Android was originally conceived by one of its creators Andy Rubin, when he was employed at Apple in the mid-90s. Were pretty sure that won’t stick, but we’ll see.
The allegation was made in a response to the US International Trade Commission’s investigations of Apple’s complaint against HTC, but it has broader potential implications for Android than previous Apple statements, which have tended to focus on vendor specific implementations rather than the platform itself. In its deposition, Apple rages against Rubin, whose start-up was acquired by Google for the OS he created, and who now heads up Android activities at the search giant.
Apple said ‘Android and Rubin’s relevant background does not start, as HTC would like the Commission to believe, with his work at General Magic or Danger in the mid-1990s. In reality ‘ Mr Rubin began his career at Apple in the early 1990s and worked as a low level engineer specifically reporting to the inventors of the ‘263 patent at the exact time their invention was being conceived and developed.’
This patent, which may prove pivotal in the current legal battle against Android, is US No 6,343,263, and details a real time API and “signal processing system for serially transmitted data.’ (Tell me again how that defines an entire operating system?)
Apple now claims that the patent is infringed in Android, and adds: ‘It is thus no wonder that the infringing Android platform used the claimed subsystem approach of the ‘263 patent that allows for flexibility of design and enables the platform to be ‘highly customizable and expandable’ as HTC touts.’
IPR analyst Florian Mueller of FOSS Patents told ZDnet that, since Rubin never worked at HTC, these charges will carry no weight in the current action. But they show Apple putting a stake in the ground for possible future actions against Google itself. “Should Apple at some point sue Google directly over this patent, this background could have serious ramifications,” Mueller wrote on his blog. “Google (or a Google subsidiary like [Motorola Mobility]) would almost certainly be found to infringe the relevant patent intentionally, and wilful infringement would greatly increase Apple’s chances of obtaining an injunction as well as triple damages.”
We can’t agree and feel the Apple legal actions will backfire against it over time.