Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 September 2011

AT&T $6 billion kill fee looks like mostly propaganda ‘ Now Sprint sues

The AT&T T-Mobile deal has been something we are vaguely following, because of its ability to influence fixed line services, U-Verse in the US and Deutsche Telecom in Europe, including its acquisition of pay TV operators.

Now it transpires that AT&T only pays out the $6 billion kill fee to T-Mobile under certain conditions, and one of the outcomes which avoids this is interminable hold ups in the deal getting approval, according to Reuters. If the Antitrust trial lingers on then this would be the likely outcome with no payment going to T-mobile.

There are two bodies of opinion, one that AT&T will get T-Mobile by making concessions, perhaps losing as many as 25% of the customers and this seems to be the dominant idea going around, and the other that the deal will get called off. We cannot remember a single deal where someone tried to buy their way to a virtual monopoly and they got to just shy of a monopoly figure by buying part of the target. That logic won’t wash in legal circles.

Anyway we happen to believe that the deal should be called off, but in the US nothing is that simple and AT&T hopes it can lay hands on the T-Mobile customer base by making concessions. Today Sprint followed up the Justice Department suit with one of its own (see below).

The tone of the Justice Department comments, whereby it raised anti-trust concerns, suggest that it’s not in the mood for negotiating, but instead wants to block the deal ‘ for the right reasons ‘ it’s unhealthy for consumers.

But T-Mobile US has already suffered considerable customer losses since it froze its strategy after the deal was announced. It lost some 99,000 customers in the first quarter and another 50,000 in the second, but lost way more than that in contract customers. But if that $6 billion compensation is never paid, and the deal IS called off, T-Mobile is in a terrible position.

Hands up how many of you thought that the $6 billion figure was deliberately put out there as a disincentive to investigate this. The penalty on one of America’s biggest customers was held out there like a taunt, saying ‘we dare you to interfere, it will bring down public scorn and derision.’ Well it now turns out that this outcome was never true and it was part of the propaganda war to get everyone onside, a war that AT&T has almost won, as it still has investor support for the deal. The Department of Justice surprised everyone last week when it initiated an anti-trust legal action to block the deal.

The Judge allocated to the anti-trust case has ordered a status hearing for September 21, and urged that all parties be prepared to discuss the prospects for settlement. The judge’s order talked about ‘the just, speedy and inexpensive determination of all pretrial matters and the trial of this case,” which sounds like he too is willing to give AT&T a chance to expedite matters.

Just as we were going to press, Sprint launched its own Anti-trust suit, one that won’t have to be heard separately because it is attached to the current case. This just gets sprint a day in court. Usually anti-trust cases from a commercial organization, not a government source are heard separately by different courts. AT&T was quick to denounce the Sprint interference, but we think it is unlikely that a court can rush through this case, and this is a systematic attack on the deal, designed to slow it down to a crawl. There may be other suits lined up in case either or both of these fail and then getting a negotiated settlement with the Justice Department won’t help.