Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 October 2011

Kroes pounces with new consultations on broadband price and sharing

Telco operators have a wonderful habit of neither listening, nor being rational, when local loop unbundling is ever mentioned. The reactions, spread across the European press, to the two consultations announcement by Neelie Kroes, European Commission Vice President for the Digital Agenda, mostly accuse her of being mad, and her ideas unworkable.

But if anyone actually goes to the European Commission web site and looks them up they are quite straightforward and not too strange at all. The essence is that European incumbents, and in particular those which used to be Telco monopolies, will not get a break from opening their networks to rivals just because they install fiber, as she has laid out details of how regulators should go about the transition from copper to fiber.

We burst out laughing at the point where she pointedly addressed the issue of how new fiber services should be made available, especially when it meant tearing up copper, or switching over copper backhaul to support fiber. Those paragraphs suggested a scenario where incumbents would deliberately fail to complete negotiations for sharing fiber, and then blithely cut off the customers of wholesale or unbundling partners who are on copper, by supporting only fiber in the area. The fact that Kroes feels she has to address this so precisely implies that telcos really thought that was going to be a fair way to compete.

It also says that the entrenched telcos still feel like they have a right to have sole access to customer homes, approach ducts and exchanges, ahead of the new generation of rival suppliers who are making broadband so competitive in the modern era.

The other issue that Kroes has addressed is merely the re-iteration of just how existing copper access should be shared. She is worried that many EU regulators have not approached it accurately and that it is still difficult in some parts of the EU to provider unbundled ISP lines.

Now we know that US readers will feel appalled at unbundling, since it was killed by US courts for their incumbents ‘ and this is seen as right and proper by all right thinking Americans ‘ but it has worked in Europe, and is working in many parts of the Asia Pacific, in fact anywhere but the US, where not doing it has not worked. These countries have better, more widespread broadband than the US ‘ and more fiber direct to homes. Interestingly in the US there was also a moratorium on piggybacking on fiber, where it goes within 500 feet of a home, and that’s what triggered, back in 2004, the fairly aggressive US fiber expansions in the biggest case of corporate blackmail we have ever witnessed.

Now incumbents here are talking openly of the EU approach being crazy, suggesting that it means that any fiber that it invests in will benefit rivals, and will immediately be under price pressure. At the same time voices have been raised suggesting that Kroes’ request to take a deeper look at whether existing unbundling principles are actually being adhered to across Europe is in fact a cut in copper attachment prices. In some cases it will mean this of course, but not in the established unbundled economies, such as France and the UK.

The over-arching principle is fairly easy to grasp ‘ that incumbent retail offerings should not be offered local loop access or wholesaled access, any cheaper that the incumbent could offer it to another retail environment. This involves taking a detailed look at the costs of the copper in the ground, the cost of maintaining that copper, the cost of adding new backhaul and new access lines, and adding a premium so the telco can make a margin.

In the US the incumbents convinced a court that the FCC could not do this, by proving as far as the court was concerned, that the price the FCC had tried to impose was below cost. It’s unlikely that it was. Net result is that the US has a monopolistic fixed line network, and European telcos are jealous of the privileges of Verizon and AT&T.

The bleating seems to say, ‘either give us freedom from connection (like the US) for our fiber, so we can make back our investment or let us continue to charge excessive amounts for copper broadband, to fund the laying of fiber.’

Either way consumers will continue to pay high prices for broadband (though nothing like as high as the US). What’s laughable is that the telcos who are making money hand over fist on slow copper broadband are still saying that even with all that profit, they don’t have enough money to invest in fiber.

Over the past few months Vivendi, Deutsche Telekom, and Alcatel have pushed a strategy for accelerating faster deployment of high-speed networks but this included ‘investment incentives’ like the US, where there would be a limit to some regulation. They had thought they were about to get their way, so the arrival of yet another consultation process which seems to point to an identical regime for fiber as was put in place for copper, was something of a surprise.

The statement from the EU said that the consultations are part of commission efforts to boost the single market for telecoms services by ensuring consistent and coherent approaches to regulating telephone and broadband networks in all Member States.

The first consultation is about non-discriminatory access for alternative operators and the second is about the way national regulators calculate prices operators have to pay for wholesale access. The results will help the Commission draft Recommendations which it can later enforce through local regulators.