Newsletters and Blogs have been quick this week to predict the downfall of Telecom Italia’s Cubovision, but we think they are both premature and possibly confused, although we concede that Telecom Italia is under pressure if it wants to remain a pay TV operator.
The stories were triggered by a press release on the Telecom Italia web site, which said briefly that responsibility for buying content was being brought back to the parent from Telecom Italia Media, effectively it bought back the contract with a final payment of €20.5 million
TI Media was responsible for conceiving, acquiring and planning the programming on both the original IPTV platform, which is no longer being sold to new customers, but which still exists and the new OTT service Cubovision which has really only just been started 11 months ago.
To us this looks like a change of plan rather than a service cancellation ‘ the whole idea behind Cubovision is barely laid out. The idea is to create a free service over the internet, using a retail proposition for a new kind of set top. The box was ordered from Amino in the UK, after an RFP which involved about 19 different platform suppliers and it is built around Intel chips and MeeGo. The roll out of things like Apps on the platform is only just in its infancy, and while it could be cut, the fact that continuing orders for devices are still being placed (one was reported in the last Amino accounts) suggests that this is a change of plan rather than a cancellation. The pricing for content, although only paid to a company within the group, was based on higher volumes ‘ so we have to accept that the volumes that Telecom Italia expected, which was in the millions, are not being met, and consequently it is paying through the nose for the content because it was set at those levels.
Right now Cubovision is an exciting experiment, run as a walled garden from servers owned by hosting company Matrix, which TI also acquired, for delivering back-end OTT content. But although Cubovision is predominantly an OTT served wall garden, it has recently been extended with the addition of YouTube’s ‘Leanback’ which runs using Flash 10.1 with a standard browser. There is the potential that Cubovision will be opened up to a number of other non-hosted video Web partners, simply because it is based on open standards and has a full web browser.
Currently the Cubovision portal offers around 1,500 hours of programming from 200 TV series, cartoons, documentaries, concerts and movies including Telecom Italia Media’s own La7.tv, and the set top takes these directly to home TV screens. Recently Samsung Smart TVs have been added on a single channel, so the company still appears to be both buying devices and trying new content options.
New Cubovision Apps are due to appear on the Apple App Store and Samsung TV Application Store, which will let tablets and smartphones access the programming.
Currently the devices cost €199 and the service costs nothing, or the set top can be rented for €5.50 per month.
The big problem is actually the customer landgrab going on in Italy between Mediaset and Sky Italia, with TI caught in the middle ‘ with Mediaset hoovering up the low end of the market using conditional access over digital terrestrial TV, averaging about €14 a month for each of around 4.4 million customers. Sky at the top end is getting more like €42 a month for a very high end service and has 4.8 million customers. Telecom Italia stopped pushing its IPTV Alice service by introducing Cubovision, and at the time had around 374,000 IPTV homes each paying around €18 a month, and will still have the bulk of these.
But Telecom Italia Media is really about owning its own TV channels and running 4 DVB-T multiplexes, as a direct rival to Mediaset. It was a shareholder in Dahlia TV, which was closed at the beginning of this year and is trying to build a media empire to rival Mediaset. The company was hosting many of the Dahlia TV channels on its multiplexes, which leaves it busy still trying to replace those, although it has already added CanalOne and says it has more coming. It gets much of its revenues from advertising on La7, the channel it owns.
If Telecom Italia was planning to diverge its content somewhat from TI Media’s, then it would make sense for the company to take over control of Cubovision content and perhaps do it for far less. For instance Cubovision has a number of DRMs and offers some pay per view, and could push premium content more aggressively, but might have to shop around for different content from TI Media for that. If TI really does decide that it cannot make it with Cubovision it will have failed as a TV operator, but will remain as a free to air broadcaster.
We would expect to see some more effort, more content and further app relationships in Cubovision before TI decides if it wants to bail out completely, otherwise, it could have fallen out of OTT before most of Europe has even started OTT trials. But if that did happen it would put pressure on Amino, because Cubovision provides a fairly hefty chunk of its set top revenues right now.
Meanwhile Telecom Italia has just said it will be offering the iPad2 in Italy, and if it does not have TV service on the iPad that would put it further behind Mediaset and Sky, which plans to introduce Sky Go in Italy shortly.