Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 October 2011

Qwikster PR disaster derailed, but Netflix share slump goes on

A lot of people are going to make a lot of money out of Netflix in the coming two weeks, mostly hedge fund managers and investors confident enough to go in for traded options, with put options being the trend as (almost) everyone in the investor community expects Netflix to continue to fall.

We have advised Netflix publicly through these pages to stick to its knitting and make announcements which relate entirely to acquiring new content. Consumers seeing such announcements are soothed into continuing to make buying decisions for its streaming service. And for the last two or three weeks this is exactly what Netflix has done, announcing a nice deal with Dreamworks Animation, with no impact on its share price or brand perception, either negative or positive.

But every time its management tries to attend to the issue of its share price with an announcement or a blog ‘ the company falls on its face. It is seen having experienced disastrous share falls due entirely to the announcement of its price rises, and the way they were communicated to customers and investors alike ‘ and everything it says ‘ right up until October 24th, when it announces its results, will be seen as yet more PR disasters.

The latest step was to re-assure users that DVD Online rental would NOT in fact be moved under an entirely new brand name called Qwikster, an announcement which was seen as anti-customers and an attempt to remove itself from its past, by dumping many customers onto a second web site with a strange new name. Analysts immediately speculated that it would later sell off Qwikster, which of course made no sense at all. Selling off Qwikster would have seeded another rival to itself in the online movie market, and that’s the last thing that Netflix needs right now.

The only filing at the SEC since Netflix issued a revised guidance, has been a notice that a hedge fund, called JAT Capital Management has bought another 4 million shares in the company. Other hedge funds are redolent in Netflix stock. They all seem to know that a 60% fall in the value of a growing company is unlikely to be maintained ‘ so long as the company actually hits the revised guidance figures. Let’s hope that it doesn’t fall foul of these revised estimates too.

There are analysts who are saying that Netflix has suffered irreversible brand damage and that this will indeed show in these coming figures. They may be right, but after October 24th it will be certain if they are right or wrong and if the numbers hit, this fuss about Netflix will have to stop and sensible new investors will just see a bargain.

But for Faultline to take an interest, we must talk about the technology and the proliferation of networked video experiences, and the reason we are fascinated by what’s happening to Netflix is that it was seen as unstoppable, and the fastest growing online video source in the world, and just a few weeks later, investors, who clearly didn’t trust its rise to this position, are so quick to bail out that they are threatening the company itself.

Investors could demand the head of the CEO, activist investors might make a position and install themselves on the board and try to direct strategy, or the company could simply run out of money and find debt hard to come by. PR fiascos’ and investor unrest are not to be sneezed at. We applaud the Netflix bravery at making this one price move now, which will likely affect it (positively) for years, but if the result is to have the people thrown out of the company which made such a brave move, it won’t amount to a hill of beans and Netflix could prove short-lived and be up for sale to the highest bidder in a matter of months. Companies like Liberty Media might swoop if such an eventuality was forced on it by investor shortsightedness. We don’t think so but we’ll know on October 24th.