Back in 2005, as NDS had apparently stolen the contract for supplying DirecTV with DVRs, and as the legal action against EchoStar faltered, TiVo looked to be in trouble. We took a long hard look at TiVo and concluded that either it invented the DVR or it didn’t, and felt that on balance if it hadn’t, then DVRs would be the first major invention to be invented by no-one.
Faultline backed TiVo through the Dish/EchoStar case, and never wavered when it lost this or that ruling regarding its main time warp patents and eventually that deal came through big time into the bottom line of the TiVo accounts. We had even said that once the case with Dish was done, as long as it concluded in TiVo’s favor, the company could begin to charge royalties all around the world.
So it was no surprise when tactically, with Dish on the ropes, TiVo went after the biggest pay TV companies it could find in legal actions against AT&T U-Verse and Verizon’s FiOS Pay TV services. There now appears to be a definitive step in the AT&T case, and the litigants have clearly briefed US papers of its significance. Effectively all that has happened is that District Court Judge David Folsom has made a ruling on the wording of the patent claims construction, which appears to lean heavily in TiVo’s favor.
TiVo shares bumped up 5% immediately, but it’s a subtle move whereby the judge defines how courts should read key disputed terms and passages in the three DVR patents at the heart of the case. Apparently AT&T was hoping that it could convince the judge to move towards a new definition of how the famous 389 patent, which was at the center of the Dish litigation, is observed and he did no such thing.
It has led some close observers to believe that AT&T will almost immediately settle. We’re not so sure. AT&T may have a lot at stake, but it can risk a few days in court we think prior to settling. On the one hand it doesn’t want to end up with $100 million in damages like Dish, and further punitive licensing costs going forwards. AT&T has 3.4 million U-Verse TV customers, and probably around half of them have a DVR, and much the same is true at Verizon, so these two are responsible for about 3 million or so DVRs between them.
It has to be remembered that Dish had only 4 million DVRs despite having almost 14 million customers, so collectively AT&T and Verizon are 75% as big a target as Dish was, and TiVo landed a $500 million final settlement deal from Dish. That was paid as $300 million up front and $33 million a year for six years, leading to speculators to suggest that AT&T and Verizon would pay a similar amount, or perhaps more, as much as $60 million.
Being true to the license terms of Dish, AT&T and Verizon combined might pay $1 per device per month, which sounds about right, but for how long. The suit was brought in August 2009, but there were two years of DVR installs prior to that, so the settlement is more likely to be $17 million a year each for the next 6 years, with a back payment of 4 years of such payments, paid up front, so $68 million. That would make the total settlement around $170 million each, a total of $340 million, if conducted on the same terms as Dish.
There is no way that TiVo can allow those past years to be forgiven, because otherwise other companies it settles with will automatically want the same terms, but it could settle at a lower unit price. Even so we would be surprised to see less than $100 million being added to the TiVo cash pile on the day of a settlement with both AT&T and Verizon, with more to come, enough to make it profitable.
The reason why everyone suddenly thinks that if AT&T settles, Verzion will, is because the same judge has been allocated to both cases.
And with that amount of money at stake, there is still an incentive for AT&T to both pursue the case a little longer or attempt mitigation.
The way it will go after mitigation is through its partners Microsoft and Motorola, and this is where it gets interesting. At the beginning of the year Microsoft sued TiVo over patents, knowing that if AT&T got hit for a royalty from TiVo, AT&T would come after the Mediaroom eco-system to pay for it in reduced prices, and the same applies to Verizon. Both use, among others, Motorola devices and in March Motorola went the same route, and created some trumped up charges against TiVo.
There were those who said that it would end up as a simple patent swap, and we suspect that some level of mitigation might be achieved by Microsoft, which used patents related to an onscreen TV guide, and which are nothing to do with the Time Warp and other patents that TiVo is suing both AT&T and Verizon for. It’s the first time we have ever heard someone other than Rovi claim that it has material patents in the area or EPG.
Can TiVo agree a settlement with AT&T while that case is still outstanding? We don’t think so, TiVo would ask that it is quietly withdrawn, and there may or may not be a price for that, which lowers the payments that AT&T has to pay. However given that these Microsoft patents have never been widely licensed and never seen legal scrutiny, they might be used to target any and every pay TV operator or supplier, but instead Microsoft is solely going after tiny TiVo, in a move that we think will be laughed at legally.
It’s the same for the Motorola patents which claim that Motorola in fact invented the DVR, with patent filings that have been scrutinized in previous TiVo cases and it has found not to have infringed. Why is Motorola not suing Cisco, Technicolor, Pace, Samsung, Humax and NDS, to name but a few, who all build or design devices which are DVRs, if it truly believes that a company that it acquired by default, had invented the DVR. That’s because it doesn’t really believe this, and if a company doesn’t believe its own assertions, then we don’t believe that a court will take it too seriously either.
But it doesn’t end there ‘ Motorola has substantial DVR sales outside of AT&T and Verizon and even had TiVo put its own technology on a set top it made for Comcast, putting all the capability into software, for an existing Motorola device design. So it knows the TiVo technology inside and out and has had help making its DVRs better ‘ from TiVo.
If we were TiVo we might use the counter suit to go after Microsoft and Motorola for all those DVRs they have made or taken money for, and that extends way outside of a mere 3 million US DVRs. TiVo may, in fact, be incensed that these two technology giants tried to bully it on behalf of clients, and in return may want their global pound of flesh. So a settlement needs to happen with Microsoft and Motorola and we don’t think it’s likely that it will be a simple cross license. TiVo has them by the short curly hairs and will ask for further money for any settlement with these two companies.
It’s a tough call. TiVo cannot settle with all Microsoft and Motorola clients directly at once, so the outcome may mean that these two withdraw their suits, but even a withdrawal will not give them any rights to TiVo technology, so that TiVo can continue to pursue Microsoft and Motorola clients around the world. At some point these two will have to license the TiVo technology on behalf of their clients. And so will Cisco, Technicolor, Pace, Samsung, Humax and NDS, to name but a few, but right now they all think they can bully tiny TiVo.
So we see this case as more than a simple settlement matter between AT&T and TiVo and between Verizon and TiVo. If the two operators do cave in this early in the case, then TiVo has more wins under its belt to chase others. If they don’t they are simply stacking up more cost for the future. But either way TiVo may later be chasing down their suppliers, and where you read Motorola, you must now read Google and Google TV, and the likelihood that it too will find itself on the license list that TiVo is chasing.