Samsung and Apple are engaged in the worst kind of break-up ‘ acrimonious, public but with such strong commercial bonds that neither can break free without ruin. Thus, in the same week that that Samsung tried to get the new iPhone banned, it was reported to be ramping up production of the A6 processor, which will feature in the next round of Apple handsets, potentially helping the ‘iPhone 5’ steal back any share lost to Samsung’s Galaxy family.
Aside from Apple lawsuits, Samsung will soon have to face up to the conflicts of interest inherent in the rising importance of its smartphone business. In the past, it has coped well with being a diverse conglomerate whose divisions may have contrasting relationships with other vendors ‘ one competing, one supplying. But that was before Samsung was pushing to be the biggest smartphone maker on the planet, at the expense of some of its own customers. Already it keeps the best advances from its display division for its own handset unit for some time, and while Samsung Mobile has often refused to purchase components from its own stablemates in the past, recently it has become far more reliant on its fellow companies for cutting edge technology, especially in processors and displays. This inevitably creates tensions with other handset customers, even those which have been less aggressive than Apple in trying to put Samsung and Galaxy back in their box.
According to financial analysts, Apple will have spent about $8 billion on Samsung components, including LCD displays, memory chips and processors, this year. It has turned to other vendors for critical parts, such as TSMC for the A6, and LG and Hitachi for iPhone displays, and is said to be investing in others such as Sharp. But it is unlikely to be able to work around Samsung’s huge position in memory chips, and the two firms have close ties on the processor front too. The early iPhones had Samsung apps processors, and even when Apple released its own A4, it was largely based on its partner’s own designs. Even when it became more self-sufficient with the A5, it was still manufactured by Samsung.
The conflicts have been thrown into sharp relief by the A6 processor issue. According to the Korea Times, Taiwan’s TSMC ‘ which was recently introduced as a second supplier for Apple’s in-house designed A6 ‘ has failed to stabilize the chip as yet. This has led Samsung to boost output of the part at its Texas plant, and according to the source: ‘Apple has been in talks with Samsung over shipment of its A6 quad-core processor to be used in the next iPhone. It appears that Apple has concluded that Samsung remains a critical business partner.’
According to the reports, Samsung is making the A6 using its 28-nanometer process technology, and TSMC will produce only small volumes in this generation. “Apple isn’t taking risks. Samsung offers better pricing and capacity commitment for the A6 mobile APs,” an executive from another Apple supplier told Korea Times.
Meanwhile, the legal battles between the two giants are only gathering pace. First, they took a fresh turn when Samsung launched a modified smartphone which works around the patents contested by Apple. According to Associated Press reports, the Korean vendor will remove a feature which a Dutch court judged, in a preliminary ruling which led to an injunction, to violate one of Apple’s patents relating to how pictures are browsed. The Dutch court ruled against three models, the Galaxy S, Galaxy S II and Ace.
Samsung will start selling the modified smartphones in the Netherlands this month, and could adopt a similar approach in other markets where Apple has, or is seeking, a ban. “Some of the technologies that Apple claimed violated their patents can be easily modified with alternative technologies,” a Samsung spokesman told Dow Jones Newswires. This reinforces the vendor’s argument that its own patents are far more fundamental ‘ as is certainly the case on the wireless technology front ‘ than those cited by Apple, many of which relate to design (as in many of the Galaxy Tab complaints). It implies that, so far, it has not deployed its massive arsenal of IPR, in the interests of finding a settlement, but that it is now prepared to do so ‘ and will prove more than a match for Apple. ‘Apple has continued to violate our patent rights and free ride on our technology,’ Samsung said in a statement. ‘We will no longer stand idly by and will steadfastly protect our intellectual property.’
That remains to be seen, but Samsung has certainly taken the gloves off, and has already filed lawsuits in four countries trying to gain a ban on the new iPhone 4S. It has taken action in France, Italy, Japan and Australia ‘ the last of these an important test market, and the first jurisdiction to award a temporary injunction against the Galaxy Tab 10.1. In Japan, the iPhone is a particularly important handset because it has driven the country’s belated conversion to open platform smartphones. Softbank has had the exclusive until now, when it is joined by KDDI as a 4S carrier.
‘The legal battle is lasting longer and is more extensive than originally expected,’ James Song, an analyst at Daewoo Securities, told Bloomberg. ‘This kind of legal saga isn’t good for both companies given their business relationship. The parties will eventually seek to resolve the issue.’ Currently, it is hard to see how.
Both companies, despite their legal posturings, are on a major roll and largely taking business off weaker players rather than one another (although from Apple’s point of view, growth for Samsung is also a bonus for the whole Android platform). This week, both vendors have been engaged in wars of statistics as well as lawyers.
The iPhone 4S may have bored the Apple community, but its pre-orders have broken new records, proving that the phone is not targeted at Apple enthusiasts and reviewers at all, but a whole new, larger market of more price sensitive users. The vendor said it had received one million 4S pre-orders within 24 hours, and achieved a record breaking 4m sales in its first weekend. This easily beat previous iPhones ‘ the previous single-day pre-order record was 600,000, for the iPhone 4 in 2010. In previous years, the iPhone 3GS took three days to hit the 1m mark. The original iPhone took over two months to reach a million, but it only had one carrier in the world, AT&T.
Among the million 4S units, 200,000 were processed by AT&T, making it the most successful iPhone launch for the carrier, despite the loss of its exclusive first to Verizon Wireless and now Sprint too. The two CDMA operators did not provide figures but both claimed to be ‘very pleased’ with their pre-sales.
We can see a mixture of reasons behind the strong success for a mediocre upgrade. One is that Apple has broadened its distribution channels, including new operators like KDDI and Sprint, and has made the pricing more competitive for midrange users and for the growing smartphone bases in emerging economies. Timing is different this time too, with the traditional early summer launch delayed until the fall, with the advantage of hitting the start of the holiday buying season. The delay also meant more customers were eligible for immediate upgrades. And of course, the death of co-founder Steve Jobs and the media storm that engendered put Apple firmly at the forefront of the minds of consumers, even those who would not normally be heavily focused on the firm.
Meanwhile, despite Apple’s best efforts, Samsung’s Galaxy smartphones drove the Korean giant to better than expected profits in the third quarter, having reached a milestone of 30 million units worldwide (for the Galaxy S and S II). Demand for high end handsets (Galaxy, Wave and Omnia) outweighed declining sales in other key business units, notably displays and semiconductors.
Operating profit in the three months to September was KRW4.2 trillion ($3.6bn), more than the KRW3.7 trillion anticipated by analysts, though down on the year-ago figure of KRW4.86 trillion. The figures are preliminary – audited results will be published later in the month and could change the profit figure by KRW200bn up or down. Sales were up 1.9% year-on-year to KRW31 trillion.
‘I’m quite amazed,’ Lee Seung Woo of Shinyoung Securities told Bloomberg. ‘It seems like there was a big surprise on the smartphone side.’
Samsung watchers believe profit at the telecoms unit, whose biggest business is handsets, was up 76% year-on-year to KRW1.99 trillion, on sales up 28% to KRW14.21 trillion. It is estimated that Samsung shipped about 30m smartphones during the third quarter, half of its overall target of 60m for the year. Anticipating strong results, the mobile division chief, JK Shin, said recently that he was confident the firm would hits its target of selling over 300m handsets in 2011.
Profit at the semiconductor division, Samsung’s biggest business by revenue last year, fell 63% to KRW1.26 trillion and sales may have fallen to KRW8.98 trillion from KRW10.66 trillion a year earlier amid weakening demand for memory chips. Samsung has 40% share of the DRAM segment.
Apple suffered a rare disappointment in its own fiscal fourth quarter ‘ though one largely caused by Wall Street’s massively high expectations. The firm missed Street estimates for the first time in six years, with the later than usual iPhone launch seen as the main culprit. This will give Samsung hope of grasping the world number one position in smartphones for the period, if only for one quarter of glory before the iPhone 4S delivers Apple the crown again in Q4.
Apple reported profit of $6.62 billion or $7.05 a share, up healthily from $4.31bn a year earlier but below analyst forecasts of $7.31 a share. This was the first time Apple failed to live up to expectations in 26 quarters, said Bloomberg.
Revenues were $28.3 billion, slightly below the $28.6 billion in the third fiscal quarter and about $1 billion less than analyst forecasts ‘ though up on last year’s $20.3 billion. For its 2011 fiscal year, Apple said its revenues were $108 billion, up 66% year-on-year, and earnings were up 85% to $26 billion. The firm sold 72 million iPhones and 32 million iPads in 12 months.
The iPhone is Apple’s most important product these days and the company’s fortunes track those of its famous handset, which accounted for 39% of total revenue. In Q3, many users delayed purchases until a new model arrived, which happened this year in October instead of the usual summer schedule. This meant that Apple sold 17.07m iPhones in Q3, fewer than the 20m-plus which most analysts had projected despite the ageing nature of the iPhone 4. Many had expected sales to be buoyed to a greater extent by price cuts on the model at AT&T and other carriers.
‘The market was expecting very strong iPhone sales going into the product launch,’ Giri Cherukuri, head trader at Oakbrook Investments, told Bloomberg. ‘It stands to reason that a lot of people were waiting for the new iPhone to come out.’ Apple shares fell 6.3% to $395.50 in extended trading on Tuesday.
However, the pent-up demand should produce a bumper holiday quarter. Apple said this would be its best yet, projecting earnings per share of about $9.30 on sales of about $37 billion, higher than analysts had expected. ‘In our wildest dreams, we couldn’t have gotten off to as great a start as we did with the iPhone 4S,’ CEO Tim Cook said on the earnings call, though he admitted that the fall in demand for older iPhones had been ‘substantial’.
On the call, he once again paid tribute to the recently deceased co-founder Steve Jobs. ‘Steve was a great leader and mentor and inspired everyone at Apple to do extraordinary things,’ he said. ‘His spirit will forever be the foundation of Apple, and we are dedicated to continuing the amazing work that he loved so much.’
China is now Apple’s second largest market, generating $4.5 billion in sales. The iPad continued to dominate the tablet sector, with sales of 11.12 million units, but the form factor is not catching fire as some had expected a year ago ‘ while a record, iPad sales were just below forecasts of 11.5m, which had already been reduced amid uncertain market conditions.
Bloomberg’s analyst survey highlighted the unquestioning attitude towards Apple’s performance, expecting miracles even in quarters with no new products. ‘Shame on me and other investors who got lulled into complacency based on how much they’ve beaten estimates in the past,’ said David Rolfe, chief investment officer at Wedgewood Partners, while another analyst, Trip Chowdhry at Global Equities Research, commented: ‘It’s not the company that missed, it’s the people who follow Apple that are clueless.’
Meanwhile, Samsung’s Android rival HTC also revealed unaudited third quarter figures, boasting a 68% year-on-year rise in net income to NT$18.6m ($615.3 million) on sales up 79% to NT$135.8 million. However, this just missed the firm’s target for 10% sequential growth, with revenues up only 9.2% on the second quarter. HTC is also being driven primarily by strong demand for high profile, highly specified Android smartphones, although it is also the leader in Windows handsets.
But HTC has suffered a setback in its own legal battle with Apple, despite the support of Google and Microsoft for its cause. The US International Trade Commission (ITC) has rejected the Taiwanese company’s patent infringement complaint against Apple, with a preliminary decision by judge Charles Bullock, who found ‘no violation of section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930’ by the four patents in question. He did rule that the patents, which cover power management and phone dialling, are valid. Such judgements are subject to review by a full ITC panel of judges, which will take place in February. HTC initially filed the complaint in May 2010, seeking an injunction against the iPod, iPhone and iPad.
The next ITC rulings on the Apple-HTC case are due on November 13, when the Commission will make a preliminary ruling on alleged Apple violation of two patents owned by S3 Graphics, a company HTC purchased; and then December 6, when the final ruling is due on a July decision that HTC violated two Apple patents. In September HTC used patents it acquired from Google to extend its actions against the iPhone maker in federal court.