Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 October 2011

TV Everywhere brings little joy to operators

To paraphrase the great Irish wit and playwright Oscar Wilde, ‘there is one thing worse than TV Everywhere and that is TV Nowhere’. This seems to sum up the mood among many operators of all dimensions with the widespread view that TV Everywhere is entirely a defensive move against churn with a neutral or even negative impact on ARPU.

At least bigger operators can afford to absorb the costs of TV Everywhere and wait for the putative profits to follow later. But even they seem rather unenthusiastic about the whole business, in large part because of weariness breaking their heads against the brickwall of rights that seems intent on locking premium content inside the home. As for accessing your premium subscription content from another country, forget it.

Take the case of Orange, the France Telecom brand for TV as well as voice and broadband, which in Europe has been rather a pioneer of TV Everywhere, rolling out its content everywhere strategy through 2009 with moves including use of satellite to reach rural customers, and IPTV elsewhere, combined with mobile access. Orange was indeed enthusiastic enough about the idea, with a simple marketing message that it wanted to recreate the disappearing value of the DVD by allowing subscribers to access all their content on all their devices. To an extent Orange has delivered on that promise, but only if all those devices are within the home, so it is more ‘TV Everything’ than’ TV Everywhere’ when it comes to premium content.

This week Orange revealed the struggles it was still having breaking out of the home to deliver the full range of TV Everywhere. Speaking on a webinar panel organized by online magazine Videonet, Orange’s Product Line Director St’phane Eymard indicated that Orange was planning to allow remote access to its services so that people could access their pay TV subscription package wherever they are, but admitted that more content rights renegotiations were needed. Eymard also conceded that at present the aim of TV Everywhere was just to be there and that as yet there was no evidence even of churn reduction, never mind making money directly.

As Simon McGrath, VP and GM Europe at the Platform, the online publishing subsidiary of US cable operator Comcast, pointed out at the same event, no one had much idea how to make money out of VoD 10 years ago. But the difference then was that pay TV operators did not feel compelled to offer VoD in order to survive, or not immediately. A problem now is that smaller pay TV operators with much shallower pockets than Orange are having to deploy TV Everywhere in order to counter the at least perceived threat of cord cutting to OTT rivals. No doubt their fears will have been accentuated by findings such as that from Parks Associates that while around 20% of households state they are very likely to switch TV providers, they would be much more likely to stay loyal given access to free TV Everywhere. Note the word ‘free’ ‘ there is a marked reluctance by consumers to pay for what is considered a second tier TV service, whether from an established operator or upstart OTT provider, as Netflix has discovered to its great cost.

But one thing about TV Everywhere is that it no longer seems to be a stick for OTT upstarts to beat incumbent pay TV operators with. Instead it is adding to the competitive armory with which established operators fight among themselves, since their grip over content rights and consumer subscriptions is preventing serious inroads from alternative OTT providers for now.