The convoluted history of Carphone Warehouse, which rose from a UK garage to become Europe’s largest independent mobile phone retailer and a significant triple play service provider, has taken another turn with the breakup of its transatlantic joint venture with Best Buy of the US. The immediate implications for pay TV are unclear, but the demerger may leave Carphone Warehouse founder Charles Dunstone more energy and inclination to focus on Talk Talk TV, being chairman of both companies.
But first a recap. Best Buy and Carphone met mid Atlantic amid great celebration in May 2008 by striking a £1.1 billion ($1.7 billion) two pronged joint venture. On the one hand Carphone took part in a profit sharing agreement with Best Buy for mobile phone retailing in the US. In the other part of the deal Best Buy agreed to assault the UK consumer electrical market by opening 100 ‘big box’ megastores in the UK and Europe by 2013, in its belief that the market dominated in the UK case by the likes of Curry’s, PC World and Comet with poor reputations for customer service was there for the taking.
But now both parts of the deal have gone up in smoke. Best Buy did provide better customer service than its rivals, but the problem was precious few people knew about that or indeed about the stores at all. That venture was undone then through poor advertising and planning as well by the teeth of a huge consumer headwind caused by the long lasting recession, which has re-intensified after the lull of 2010. As a result Best Buy is buying Carphone out of the mobile phone joint venture for $1.3 billion and at the same time scrapping the plans for the chain of European megastores.
During this three year plus episode events were also unfolding with regard to Carphone’s broadband and TV business. The story here began in 2003 when Carphone set up Talk Talk, initially as a fixed landline provider but ultimately triple play company offering pay TV, Telco and broadband access services. Meanwhile another ISP, Tiscali, was finding the going in the UK tough and accrued a mounting burden of debt. Carphone rode to the rescue in May 2009 by buying Tiscali for £236 million. This created a second thread in Carphone’s fledgling pay TV business.
The first thread was Talk Talk TV, a UK-based IP based TV and VOD service, operated by Talk Talk. This service is now effectively defunct, to be replaced by the second thread acquired with Tiscali. This thread began as one of the UK’s first IPTV services called Homechoice, available just in the London area from Video Networks, providing access via broadband to Freeview channels as well as VoD. This was purchased by Tiscali in August 2006 to be rebranded as Tiscali TV in March 2007. It then fell into Carphone Warehouse’s hands with its acquisition of Tiscali, and eventually re-emerged in January 2010 under the Talk Talk brand. This was still delivered via a dedicated IP over ADSL line from BT or its own DSLAMs.
But now Carphone, along with BT itself, has decided that the future of IPTV in the UK lies through convergence with Internet TV aligned with the emerging YouView platform to be launched in February 2012. This will comprise a set top box connecting to IP based broadband services delivered either via the Internet or dedicated IP infrastructure. In practice the infrastructure will comprise a combination of CDNs (Content Delivery Networks), backhaul, and broadband access circuits over FTTH, or some variant of ADSL, or more probably VDSL2. YouView is backed by seven entities, four broadcasters, the BBC, ITV, Channel 4, and Five, terrestrial infrastructure company Arqiva, BT, and Talk Talk. The latter two as the only triple play operators here will find themselves locked in battle to deliver the best quality of service. Talk Talk has been preparing for this by hiring Swedish digital TV quality assurance vendor Agama to provide technology and services for its forthcoming YouView based TV service.
For Dunstone there may be a lesson here from the Best Buy debacle (although it was no disaster for him personally). As broadband operators, both Tiscali and Talk Talk were bedeviled by customer service problems, while the Best Buy venture was supposed to gain traction precisely by excelling on that front. It seems Carphone is now determined that Talk Talk TV will deliver great QoE on day one, but Dunstone must avoid the mistake Best Buy did make of failing due diligence in marketing and advertising.