The number of homes that coax passes in China is twice as many as in the States or Europe ‘ just under 200 million of China’s 300 million to 400 million homes receive analog or digital TV through coax. About 8% to 10% of the 200 million homes passed by coax receive their Internet services through coax. Assuming there is no growth in homes passed, there are 180 million homes that could sign up for broadband by the end of the decade and100 million additions is a reasonable prediction.
However, the situation in China is very different from the US and Europe as explained by Alex Liu, senior manager of business development at Qualcomm Atheros, who lives in Shanghai:
1. Most people live in multiple dwelling units (MDUs), each with 200-300 residences.
2. A cable TV company rather than a telco has run fiber and/or coax to and inside the MDU. Typically it’s fiber to the MDU and coax from the basement of the MDU to each residence. Many MDUs also have a twisted pair of copper wires.
3. Pay TV subscribers pay much less per month than they do in the US and Europe.
4. The cablecos’ DOCSIS is not heavily deployed because of the topology implied by a cable modem termination system (CMTS), which similar to a telcos DSLAM, is located in a cableco’s head end or hub site and used to provide broadband to subscribers. Each CMTS head end costs hundreds of thousands of dollars and supports long runs of active coax with thousands of homes dispersed over a wide area like the suburbs.
5. Consumer expectations for performance is lower, nothing like the 100 Mbps speeds US and European customers will be expecting speeds of 1 Mbps to 10 Mbps is more the order of the day.
Cable TV companies in China and India expect to upgrade their analog and digital networks to two-way by the end of the decade. There is lots of piracy in both countries so cablecos want to upgrade their networks to Internet protocol so piracy can be tracked and reduced through assigning IP addresses.
Qualcomm Atheros, which oversaw the development of HomePlug over powerline, has a modified version called HomePlug Ethernet over Coax (EoC) that is much less expensive for the cablecos to deploy than DOCSIS. It can be used from the fiber termination point to the consumer’s premises.
It is better suited to network architectures like China and India where there are dense clusters of residences. DOCSIS was developed for suburban markets like the US where homes are spread over tens of miles and each head end has to support up to 2,000 homes. In China and India, fiber networks are called ‘deep fiber’ because they are run very near to and even into the MDU. That makes DOCSIS overkill with its emphasis on a large area and connection to several thousand homes as end points.
DOCSIS’ strength in the US, Canada and Europe ‘ the ability to connect to lots of homes that are spread over large areas ‘ becomes a weakness in countries where most middle class people live in MDUs. The coax or fiber goes from the head end directly to an MDU that has 200-300 residences, not several thousand as DOCSIS was designed to support. As a result, EoC is much less expensive to deploy.
Qualcomm Atheros says its HomePlug EoC runs very well at ranges up to one kilometer, about 0.6 of a mile, more than sufficient for MDUs. That makes it more cost effective than DOCSIS, providing 10 times the cost/performance ratio of DOCSIS for MDU applications. It says that products with its 7400 series of HomePlug EoC chips deliver up to 700 Mbps of line rates for up 64 subscribers, with equipment costs as low as $35 per subscriber.
Qualcomm Atheros’ HomePlug EoC chip is physically different for handling coax than the HomePlug AV chips it sells for in-home powerline networking. It calls its Ethernet over Coax chips a new generation of technology.
DOCSIS
Broadcom is far and away the dominant supplier of DOCSIS chips. Qualcomm’s Atheros wants to be the leader in supplying EoC chips. The Oriental Cable Network of Shanghai and Jiangsu Cable Network in neighboring Jiangsu Province are already installing HomePlug Ethernet over Coax to provide 30 Mbps to each home. Their EoC networks already pass millions of residences that could become home network subscribers.
The ‘home grown’ Home Plug technology has moved out of the area it was originally intended for and has become a technology for cablecos’ coax distribution networks.
Qualcomm Atheros says the IEEE 802.3 group that oversees the wireline Ethernet standard is considering a standard that would allow Ethernet over fiber to the neighborhood and Ethernet over coax from there to the home, similar to what it is selling in the BRICs. An architecture like that would be inviting for US cablecos in heavily densely populated areas like New York City. US and European cablecos are using DOCSIS devices that currently top out at 400 Mbps and then only with complex channel bonding. Telcos such as Verizon with FTTH networks can go up to 1 to 3 Gbps, which the cablecos cannot reach unless they too spend billions to run a fiber wire to the home. Verizon spent about $21 billion to run fiber to homes in about 40% of its footprint.
The advantage of Ethernet over coax is that the cablecos could use the same physical network they have in place ‘ fiber to the curb and coax from there to the home. They would only need to supplement the DOCSIS network gear in the head end and in the customer’s home with EoC gear.
DOCSIS also has restraints on upload speeds that EoC will not have. In a world that’s moving to consumer video phone calls, remote health care and uploading videos, uploading speed becomes a buying factor. EoC does not have a restraint on upload speeds. Besides it’s much less expensive to deploy, according to Liu.
He said that US cablecos could activate EoC over the next decade while still operating DOCSIS networks because EoC and DOCSIS can coexist on the same cable and in the same head end facility.
One factor driving EoC technology is that Chinese makers of network gear like Huawei are making EoC gear with chips from Qualcomm Atheros and selling it not only in China but also in places like Brazil and Mexico.