Forbes this week wrote an insightful piece, based on the worlds of a columnist in the Wall Street Journal, Peggy Noonan. She quoted from another piece of work, a biography of Steve Jobs, written by Walter Isaacson, where Jobs talks about how he turned around Apple in his second coming, from 1997 to 2011.
The thrust of the argument is that major companies decline because they do a great job, innovate and get close to a monopoly and then the quality of the product becomes less important. The company instead starts valuing the great salesman, because they’re the ones who drive revenues.
So they put the salesmen in charge and this indeed has happened at both IBM and Xerox as the argument says. Although clearly this is Jobs taking a snipe more at Microsoft, which has put a marketing man, Steve Ballmer, in charge, and since his appointment the value of the company has never risen, and yet he’s still in charge.
Forbes then adds its own opinion, saying don’t forget the money men, pointing out that accountants then search the firm high and low to find new and ingenious ways to cut costs or even eliminate paying taxes. The activities of these people serve to dispirit product engineers and designers and harm the company’s ability to add value to its customers. Their activities systematically kill the firm’s future.
Forbes is saying that in this mode the company is playing defense and that at Apple, by leaving the company in the hands of innovators, it was always playing offense. This is a great black and white (no shades of grey) Americanism which comes out of American football, a sport where you do indeed have two teams one for attack and one for defense on the field at separate times. Of course most team sports have one team – Hockey, Basketball, Soccer, Rugby. There are substitutes, who can come on and change the complexion of the game slightly, but mostly it’s the same players working both offense and defense. And it’s the same in most companies. If we believed what they have written, it means no CFO or Sales and Marketing director should ever be a CEO ‘ it would HAVE to be an engineer. This makes no sense.
Almost all companies HAVE a vision, or at least a corporate statement of intent. That’s how most management systems drive large corporations ‘ you align the efforts and personal objectives with some kind of corporate statement of intent ‘ it may be a bad statement, at Apple it was to make great products, at AT&T it might be to offer great customer service, at Microsoft it may be to leverage off other Microsoft stalwart businesses, but it’s how management tends to guide the workforce.
There should then be dynamic tension between the innovators or engineers, who know what’s possible, the accountants who know what’s affordable and the salesman, who knows what the client has asked him for (though surprising them with something entirely new may be the right strategy).
By putting any one of them into the CEO position it can be potentially disastrous. The CFO turned CEO keeps the previous product vision and comes up with some kind of client service proposition to drive the company. And anyway the man who pays the bills is too powerful anyway, and should never be put in charge for long, unless he has something outside of his training to contribute.
A pure salesman put in charge becomes a demagogue, he obscures the vision of the products, and goes on valiant charges where he is happy to ‘dupe’ someone into paying too much in deals which temporarily increase the profits.
But it’s the same with the engineer. He can get obsessed with product quality and never produce one, he can get obsessed with the next product and never fix the one that is the company’s cash cow.
Major companies endure either because their CFO begins to understand the client or the salesman begins to understand the technology, or as in Jobs case, the engineer begins to understand the financial issues ‘ and you have a leader that is no longer one dimensional.
Jobs is right that companies develop bad habits here. If one leader came out of sales, they will look there for their next leader, when in fact he or she may come from anywhere inside the organization and as a result, like HP, they end up having to look outside the company to find a rounded, proven leader.
But Steve Jobs was a great combination of these things. An engineer who understood what was possible, but also understood how to gamble company money, without it damaging the cashflow. He was a great negotiator (buyer) which owed something to a salesman’s skillset, and he was in touch with the customer simply by being a customer ‘ for music, for video, for PCs, and listening to his own instincts. He connected that loop from what he thought the customer might like, to someone who knew that this was, in fact, possible.
The critical issue here is how the process of appointing a successor is built into a company. Jobs has already appointed his successor, someone in his own image. He may be right and he may be wrong. For instance recent revelations (last week’s issue) show us that Jobs had considered launching a phone which used WiFi and bypassed the cellular operators. Had he gone down that route, the iPhone would have been nothing more than a curiosity. But someone on his team, or the process of negotiation, changed his mind. There WAS an effective dynamic tension holding even Steve Jobs in check, even if he personally did not admit to it. Also Apple has a perfectly good CFO, who we are sure talks about financial restraint whenever it is appropriate.
It is the quality of the mix of the team that makes a company innovative ‘ how the CFO relates to the CEO, relates to the director of Sales, and the head of engineering. If any voice is unduly loud, it can drown out the voices of the others. The CEO’s job is to amplify the voice which is currently making the most sense.
When the company needs new products, he lets the engineer speak and pacifies the CFO, when the company has great products and they are not selling he pays attention to the sales process. When the company is running out of cash, he strategizes with the CFO, and lets him speak the loudest.
And if any of that becomes a habit, instead of being thought through, then the company can take on board water and begin to sink and both the Wall Street article and the Forbes piece seem to forget that.