The knee jerk reactions go on for Netflix. It has come up with a relatively creative way of diluting the effect of having to borrow money, by getting half the money in a convertible loan from an existing investor, but still all the coverage is negative. Major US corporations borrow money in the form of notes and share issues, but Netflix is being forced to borrow money when its share price has lost about 75% of its peak value.
You know that feeling, if every dollar you borrow costs you four times what it would have cost a few months back, and you resent every penny you have to take. The CTO will be kicking himself saying why didn’t we borrow a few hundred million dollars BEFORE we did the price rise. But it’s too late.
But these knee jerk reactions can be self-fulfilling. Every piece of coverage makes this sound like another crisis ‘ one we read asks, ‘Is $400 million enough?’ Of course only time will tell. If Netflix overspends on content for the UK launch, and has a high turnover of incompetent staff, and loses another 1 million US clients instead of growing again next quarter, it may well NOT be enough. But that’s true for any company at any point in time.
Wall Street no longer trusts the fine judgment of the Netflix management team, but since the company is really only following a formula that has worked in the US, both copying it and adjusting it slightly in Latin America, Canada and the UK, how badly wrong can things go? Especially if you consider that in the UK content prices are higher and salaries considerably lower than in the US.
So is $400 million enough? Let’s see, Netflix last quarter had $365 million in bank in cash and short term investments. That had fallen $11 million, down from $376 million in the prior quarter. And it has now just raised another $400 million, so it has access to $765 million in funds.
Last quarter Netflix generated $49.5 million in cash through its operations, somewhat down from the last quarter when it created $86.4 million. This is cash generation after it has spent $539 million on content during the quarter and in the previous quarter it spent a further $612.6 million on content.
Which other companies do you know that can afford to spend at that rate on content ‘ a $2.6 billion annual run rate, and still generate excess cash in their operations. It’s worth pointing out that this is 4 times more spend on content than Netflix spent a year ago ‘ the only way to interpret that is that a) it has better content now than before which will eventually attract even more customers or b) that renegotiations for content have meant that the company is paying more, for the same content. Of course we know it is a bit of each of these reasons.
There are other cash issues for Netflix, it has other spending, about $41.5 million on what you might term capex, mostly acquiring DVDs and buying equipment and property, and it spent another $39.6 million buying its own stock.
So that operational upside of $49.5 million is reduced by both $41.5 million and $39.6 million, a total of $81.1 million leading to an overall small cash burn, which, as we say when netted out with all other items is just $11 million a quarter.
But the cash burn has gone up not because it has lost customers (although that would have been some of the effect) but because it has begun to pay for content for services it has not yet launched ‘ mostly in the UK.
What we have to understand as commentators, is that investors are disappointed because the company was a shooting star, and its price rise may have put paid to that. But it has not destabilized the company to the point where it a) will run out of money and b) it cannot get any further funding. That could happen, but only if we keep publishing unsubstantiated, anti- Netflix, knee jerk pieces like asking ‘Is $400 million enough,’ without even attempting to provide the all too obvious answers ourselves.