Last week’s OTT World Summit in London highlighted a difference in views over the need for standards in advertising compared with broadcast as a whole, in a hybrid world combining interactive IP video services with one of the three traditional broadcast media of cable, satellite or terrestrial.
In the case of advertising, common global standards were called for to enable delivery of generic or targeted adverts to people irrespective of their device or service platform. On the other hand for broadcasting, operators and countries will want wriggle room to put their own stamp on services. Some standardization is still desirable for hybrid broadcast in order to create economies of scale for smaller device makers to come in, for example, enabling them to target larger multinational markets, but the standard should not be too prescriptive or unwieldy.
The reason for this slight dichotomy is not hard to divine. Advertising is increasingly global and brands want to have as large a target as possible, especially as the audiences become fragmented through targeting and addressability. Furthermore if people register to receive particular categories of advertisement, the impact will be increased if they can be delivered to any device, wherever the recipient is. The whole target audience is likely to be distributed across multiple services and different operators each with their own content, so only a common standard implemented by all will enable adverts to be delivered and inserted within the programming.
ITV, the UK’s leading commercial TV broadcaster, has joined the clamor for targeted advertising standards, arguing that it is already getting too fragmented even within individual countries. Standards would have to address targeting methods and the ways audiences are measured for segmentation purposes. There is also the complication of dealing with differing regulations concerning targeting. In the UK for example adverts inviting a direct purchase cannot be targeted straight at children, which could mean avoiding transmitting them during the day or with content children are likely to be viewing. The surrounding content itself might be timeless and viewed in catch up mode, so the critical factor here is the timing of content consumption.
When it comes to content standards, the original dream was for a universal global standard for delivery. That dream was called Hybrid Broadband Broadcast TV or HbbTV, and is currently exuding strongly from a Central European axis led by France and Germany. But here is the paradox ‘ HbbTV is thriving because it is does not nail everything to the mast, having different profiles allowing varying implementations tailored to specific hybrid requirements. This makes sense because by its nature hybrid TV has many variants that all need to be permissible within a common umbrella standard. Also in HbbTV’s favor was its relatively lightweight design, allowing it be quick off the mark, giving it a good chance of establishing some critical mass.
There is now growing interest not just from Europe’s periphery, but also in some other key countries including Japan, China and the US. It also now enjoys wide vendor support, with just a few notable omissions, such as Ericsson. This may be because Ericsson is channeling its efforts into the Open TV World Forum (OIPF), which has a broader brief to unify IP video standards worldwide, embracing management and control of end to end networks. The hopes of HbbTV can be judged partly by considering the extent of its alignment with the emerging OIPF standards.
To some extent the two are converging, with the bulk of HbbTV being based on the OIPF’s Declarative Application Environment. This provides the browser extensions needed to support TV via the web, catering for differences in the interface such as in screen size and use of pointing devices, enabling spatial navigation within video streams, as well as the ability to control broadcast facilities such as tuners and PVRs (Personal Video Recorders). Crucially for content owners, the OIPF Declarative Application Environment also enables the capabilities of the Internet to be harnessed, such as being able to present information services associated with the content, and integrate with functions such as caller ID and instant messaging.
Most significantly here perhaps is that HbbTV and the OIPF have more or less committed themselves to establishing interoperability between the two, and to adopt common components as far as possible to ‘minimize fragmentation,’ as the OIPF puts it, adding that many HbbTV applications are expected to be ‘trivially portable to OIPF’.
This does not quite go the whole hog, but both camps have recently expressed a desire to move towards fuller cooperation in marketing, certification, compliance, and testing. It looks a fair bet then that at some point HbbTV will be subsumed into the OIPF, and then it will have a good chance of realizing that dream of becoming the global standard for hybrid broadcast.