arly indications from last week’s Black Friday shopping spree in the US confirm what we had all expected – the tablet market is by no means the overnight sensation many had predicted a year ago, but it has been boosted by the entry of Amazon with its Kindle Fire.
The tablet’s growth may be more gradual than once forecast, but it will have a significant effect on the device ecosystem over the coming few years as vendors fight to influence the defining form factor to replace the conventional PC.
Chromebooks, Ultrabooks and other concepts may clip the slate’s wings in future, but for now it is the touchscreen face of the post-PC market, and the market is firmly divided between Apple and Amazon ‘ premium, brand-driven media accessory versus affordable, content-driven tool. The immediate impact of these two companies gives them a starting base which others will struggle to erode (though in the US, Amazon has a credible contender in the B&N Nook tablets).
Most of the other large-screen tablets are basically iPad wannabes, without even the benefit of significantly lower price tags, but the success of the Fire shows that, if a company is brave enough to do something different, it is possible to go up against Apple, or at least appeal to a separate customer base.
This means that, while Apple may be thwarting Samsung’s holiday tablet hopes in some markets with its lawsuits, it has not (as yet anyway) sued the company it really needs to watch. Both rivals seem, by preliminary calculations, to have had a storming Black Friday after US Thanksgiving, and Amazon may well have answered the question of whether its new Kindle Fire really can expand the tablet sector, which has seen almost all its growth coming from the iPad in recent months.
The Fire and the iPad are very different creatures, but their vendors are fighting aggressively to set their stamp on the portable digital content space, and so early indicators for the Amazon product will be keenly watched in Cupertino. Amazon famously keeps silent about actual unit numbers for its Kindle family, and since devices are not a major part of its revenues it can get away with that, but is quickly issued a statement to say that the Kindle range as a whole quadrupled its Black Friday sales compared to last year.
There are two new ereader models, and price cuts on the older Kindle Keyboard, but clearly the Fire, with its eye-catching $199 price tag, must have made a significant contribution to the success. Amazon’s strategy is to make minimal margins on its devices in order to turn them into impulse purchases, and then get its real revenue from the buyers via their content, apps and services purchases.
The downward price trajectory for the ereaders has been dramatic ‘ from $399 for the first model in 2007, to about $299 for the Kindle 2 and then, last year, an entry level of $139 for the cheapest Kindle 3 (that was the first year with a Wi-Fi only version). Now the ereaders range from $79 to $99 for the new Kindle Touch, well into impulse territory, while the 3G models start at $149. Similar aggressive pricing moves can be expected next year to keep momentum around the Fire. In particular, an affordable 3G version, and a larger screen model, are expected.
“Even before the busy holiday shopping weekend, we’d already sold millions of the new Kindle family,” said Dave Limp, VP of Amazon Kindle, insisting that CEO Jeff Bezos had been correct in his recent comments that many people would buy multiple devices from the range ‘ for different family members or, importantly for Amazon, because some individuals want both an e-ink gadget for reading and a full tablet.
“We knew Kindle Fire and the new e-ink Kindles would be highly desirable gifts this holiday season,” Wendy Fritz, an SVP at Best Buy, told Bloomberg. “If this Black Friday was any indication, they are only getting hotter as we get into the shopping season.”
Apple also had a good Thanksgiving, according to many retailers ‘ indeed, 75% of the firm’s own stores were said to have sold out of its new iPhone 4S on Black Friday. The company has not yet released official figures for the bellwether sales day, but many analysts were positive. “Our checks show demand for iPhones, iPads and Macs is robust and Apple stores enjoyed heavy traffic throughout the holiday weekend,” said Chris Whitmore of Deutsche Bank in a research note. And Gene Munster of Piper Jaffray commented: “Our observations on Black Friday confirmed strong iPad sellthrough at Apple retail stores. Apple stores were selling 68% more iPads per hour on a year-over-year basis, directionally consistent with our estimates of 13.5m units in the December 2011 quarter, up 84% year-over-year.”
So, by the time of the Consumer Electronics Show in January, when the gadget vendors will set out their 2012 stalls, will there be further variations on the tablet theme, for people who do not quite want either an iPad or a Fire? The main hopes rest with the Android brigade, if any of them can break out from Apple’s shadow ‘ Samsung being the most likely, given its promises to harness the more advanced treasures in its stable, such as Super AMOLED or even 3D screens and superfast processors. This could result in slates which are really optimized for high end video or graphics applications and have a noticeably different user experience from that of the iPad.
The other possibility of something completely different is Microsoft, when it belatedly enters the tablet segment with Windows 8. Despite coming up with a distinctive user experience for touchscreens with WP7, the software giant has confined this to small screens, which means it has missed the first wave of the tablet market (except with its non-touch Windows 7 slates, a niche option). It is possible that its timing will prove correct ‘ cede the early adopters to Apple, since they would probably have chosen iPad anyway; move in when there is critical mass in the consumer market and, importantly, enterprise acceptance.
However, a recent survey suggests that Microsoft may actually have miscalculated by leaving tablets so late, partly because it has forced key OEM partners like Samsung and Acer to rely entirely on Android. Among consumers, Microsoft has already missed the peak of demand for a Windows 8 slate, the study by Forrester Research claims, even before the new OS is available. ‘Microsoft has missed the peak of consumer desire for a product they haven’t yet released,’ said analysts in a blog post. In the first quarter of 2011, Forrester asked consumers who were considering buying a tablet which OS they would prefer, and 46% said Windows. That number has now fallen to just 25%, a drop which Forrester thinks should be ‘alarming to Microsoft’.
Whichever tablets end up ruling the roost, they will have a profound impact on the surrounding ecosystem over the coming years. Tablets will cannibalize home TV and PC usage, according to a new study by Orange, and will also deal a blow to PC component makers, particularly in the memory space.
Orange’s survey, carried out by TNS, is specific to the UK, France and Spain, but the cellco said the patterns it reveals are seen in most developed economies. The research found that 35% of tablet owners are consuming on-demand TV, while 40% are watching streamed content, with a knock-on effect on conventional TVs. Orange also blames a 15% decline in PC usage since last year’s survey on the rise of tablet adoption.
Of course, this is good news for an operator looking to lure more customers and data plans with gadgets it can control. It said that, in contrast to TVs and PCs, smartphones are not harmed by the tablet boom because they complement any larger-screened product. So, handsets stimulate use of PCs, TVs and tablets ‘ in the UK, 20% say they are browsing the web more on their PC as a result of mobile media consumption.
“This is the first time we have included tablet usage in the Orange Exposure report and the findings are quite stark in their description of how people are using devices,” said Bruce Hoang, group marketing director of the Orange Advertising Network. “Clearly the ‘one size fits all’ approach for digital content across TV, PC, smartphone and tablet does not work and this has significant implications for content producers and advertisers,” he said.
Meanwhile, DRAM prices fell to a record low this month after PC shipments missed analyst forecasts – but iPad sales reached a record 11.1m. Samsung is successfully offsetting the blows to its memory business by diversifying into chips for tablets, smartphones and servers, said analysts, but other memory makers will have fewer resources to do this. ‘DRAM makers invested too much, and they bet heavily that growth of the computer industry would always continue,’ said Chen Liway, an industry analyst at Polaris Securities in Taipei. ‘That would have been OK if the iPad had never come along.’
The latest forecasts for PCs, including tablets, come from IC Insights, which thinks units will hit 414m this year, up 13% on 2010. Without tablets though, PC unit shipments will be seen to grow by just 1% year-on-year to 353m, meaning that the researchers think the touchscreen tablet space will have increased from 17m units last year to 61m in 2011.