Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 December 2011

TV panels still needed in connected era by advertisers, broadcasters

The impact of connected TV was a major theme at last week’s Future TV Advertising Forum held in London, with mixed views over its impact and on how to measure viewer engagement. On the one hand connected TV was seen as a huge opportunity for advertising, being the final step in the marriage between broadcasting and the Internet. But when it comes to measurement of advertising consumption or engagement, the online world was deemed to have surprisingly little to offer compared with the existing panel based approach used by BARB (British Audience Research Board) and Nielsen, which is the primary source of US TV audience data.

Of course both BARB and Nielsen are working on measurement of online TV consumption in real time to compliment the panel based approach, and there is clear potential both for synergy between the two sources of information, and obtaining more instant feedback about the impact of a campaign.

But in terms of information quality, it seems that the panel reigns supreme. For one thing it can drill down within a household to examine preferences and responses of individuals while watching the main TV alongside friends or other family members. Any remote measurement technique can only drill down as far as an IP address or other identifier, and so can only elicit individual responses in the case of one-to-one online viewing via PCs, tablets or smart phones.

Of course these opinions may have something to do with Nielsen and co selling hard to prevent other approaches establishing a foothold. For instance it has a system of its own in development that works on a handset or tablets and listens to the music on nearby TV sets, synchronizes it with the TV schedule and this could provide the type of granular details that the panels currently do, with far more confidence. Of course people turning off their phones or leaving them in rooms with the TV on may skew this too. The use of handsets and tablets as remote controls also gives audience measurement a new angle that this debate didn’t touch on.

At the advertising forum, several delegates pointed out that as well as drilling deeper, TV panels were also broader in the information they obtained, gathering a much greater range of data than can ever be obtained via social media for example. It was vital therefore that the panel approach be preserved and even extended in the connected TV world.

But the panel does have to embrace on-demand consumption to a greater extent than before. It was noted at the forum that viewing of catch up content has shifted to the big screen from PCs as more pay TV operators support it, which means that it must be measured accurately. Furthermore because many people watch some on-demand content on the main screen and some elsewhere, both should be included in measurements. Much of this catch up viewing is driven by the scheduled services and is in a sense a back up to them. But this trend does have significant implications for TV advertising. Firstly on demand viewing is usually interactive, so by definition there is a return path that can be exploited to enable response, potentially including click to purchase. Secondly the content has been specifically selected by viewers, which may make them more susceptible to particular advertisements. Thirdly it is worth identifying where the content is being watched, for if it is on a PC, tablet, or perhaps secondary TV, the viewer is more likely to be alone, making targeted campaigns more appropriate.

An overall message from the forum was that advertisers do need to get to grips with the connected TV world, for already viewers are leaving them behind and opportunities are going begging. But the core value of panel measurement must be retained. Nielsen and BARB have trained their customers well.