When we look back at when the cracks began to emerge in Apple’s aggressive litigation strategy, we will come back to this week and pinpoint it as the turning point. Motorola has pointed out that a German Court has ruled that Apple’s Ireland based international sales company has infringed on Motorola data packet patents which are essential in order to make a mobile phone. It has simply announced than both an injunction and damages are to be awarded, but detailed neither.
This is the first court anywhere to confirm what everyone should have known all along, that Apple has not paid its dues to make mobile phones and that the iPhone can be pulled off shelves until it makes a deal with Motorola (read Google) for a patent license. Apple managed to get a deal done with Nokia when really Nokia had all the cards up its sleeve and should have settled for far more than monetary recompense in order to let Apple off the hook. Google, with Android at stake will exact a far higher toll.
It is largely understood that the 150 or so patents that are essential to making a mobile phone, fall into a handful of smaller patent holders like Interdigital, which only want to be paid a reasonable fee for royalties, major software players like Microsoft, which takes much the same view, plus most of the companies that Apple has targeted in its various patent cases ‘ Motorola, Samsung, Ericsson and Qualcomm ‘ and until it has patent deals with all of these, there is constant danger that the Apple devices can be pulled off the shelves.
Apple has had the world’s media convinced that the opposite is true and that its meager, and likely indefensible touch control patents were enough to make it immune and make it appear like the ‘wronged’ company. That might work against largely patent empty handset makers like HTC, but it will not work against the big foundering fathers of mobile.
Right now the US press is more focused on a US case ‘ the one between Apple and HTC at the ITC, which should have been resolved by now, but which is proving trickier than it first seemed ‘ the infringement of two patents by Android, in this instance on HTC phones. At issue here are patents which relate to abstracting phone numbers from a web page and using them to make calls (something that all web-aware phones do) and another which relates to providing abstraction layers for real time applications. Both are software patents that would likely hold no sway outside of the US and which have never been tested in court for prior art. If HTC loses, then Samsung and Motorola will simply fill the void any injunctions make (so Apple wins nothing) and if Apple loses, it simply loses. In one outcome the HTC share price falls off a cliff, in both the Apple share price will not improve. Which makes it clear that Apple is not doing this for shareholder value and should stop.
Microsoft could easily provide tit-for-tat patent breaches against Apple, but again these would largely relate to software. But when we get down to the real business of making mobile phones, royalty deals must be cut with Motorola and increasingly with Samsung, and any continuation of Apple’s hostilities will lead to the company’s products being pulled off shelves the world over ‘ even in the US.
Motorola Mobility issued a statement saying, ‘We are pleased with the court’s ruling. Today’s decision validates Motorola Mobility’s efforts to enforce its patents against Apple’s infringement,’ said Scott Offer, senior vice president and general counsel of Motorola Mobility. ‘Motorola Mobility has worked hard over the years to build an industry-leading intellectual property portfolio that is respected by the telecommunications industry, and we are proud to leverage this portfolio to create differentiated innovations that enhance the user experience. We will continue to take all necessary steps to protect our intellectual property, as the Company’s patent portfolio and licensing agreements with companies both in the US and around the world are critical to our business. We have been negotiating with Apple and offering them reasonable licensing terms and conditions since 2007, and will continue our efforts to resolve our global patent dispute as soon as practicable.’
No-one has said when such an injunction may occur, but it could easily be extended to any tablets that have 3G in them, and also have an effect on iPad sales. Will this court outcome be enough to make the Apple management see sense? We doubt it. Apple is set on carrying out its founders aims to ‘kill’ Android and that will be the case until the share price suffers, the CEO is removed, and a new boss who never worked with Steve Jobs, is put in place. Watch out, when the first share price falls occur in Apple, whatever triggers it , the share graph could look a lot like the Netflix share graph, moved forward in time by about 6 months.
Even though this first set back is not on US soil, failure by Apple to settle this case to the satisfaction of Motorola, which will include cancelling all patent infringement cases instigated by Apple, including all patent breaches of Android, will result in iPhones being frozen out completely in Europe.