Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 January 2012

Chinese GPS offers threats and opportunities for Western chip makers

The launch and public availability of Beidou, China’s alternative to the US-run Global Positioning System (GPS), at the close of 2011, has major implications not just for the fast growing navigation industry, but also for commerce, politics and military power. Meanwhile the current leading makers of GPS receiver chips such as Broadcom, Texas Instruments, Qualcomm, and Cambridge Silicon Radio (CSR), face a threat from indigenous Chinese silicon companies if Beidou becomes a major player in GNSS (Global Navigational Satellite Systems).

Turned on its head however this also represents an opportunity, since these vendors already have expertise in chipsets that combine GPS with other smaller scale satellite positioning systems, especially the European Union’s Galileo, and Russia’s Glonass. By adding Beidou as well to such hybrid GNSS chips, these vendors can enable products such as smartphones and car based navigation systems to determine position and speed more accurately in mountainous terrain or urban canyons.

Until recently China has relied on GPS for military as well as civilian navigation, which means it faced the prospect of having communications blocked in the event of a conflict with the US, or more likely with one of its allies. Similar concerns prompted Russia to develop its Glonass system, while the EU’s Galileo as a civilian only system was also motivated partly to avoid Europe being totally dependent on GPS, which could be affected in the event of US involvement in a major conflict.

China also has long been aware of the importance of having its own independent navigation system, and Beidou has roots going back to the early 1980s, with the first trial operational system called Beidou 1 (literally Compass) launched between 2000 and 2007, eventually comprising four geostationary satellites. Being geostationary made sense at this trial stage, since it enables a service to be established with the minimum number of satellites, four. But it also restricts coverage area, and Beidou 1 only spanned from longitude 70’E to 140’E and from latitude 5’N to 55’N, in other words China and the surrounding region of Asia embracing India, the Far East, Mongolia and southern Siberia.

But now BeiDou-2 has been launched, replacing rather than extending BeiDou-1, although with backwards compatibility for receivers. Beidou 2 will eventually comprise a constellation of 35 satellites, including just five geostationary orbit satellites for that backward compatibility with BeiDou-1. Of the 30 non-geostationary satellites, 27 will be in medium earth orbit and three in inclined geostationary orbit, together providing complete global coverage. It will therefore be the first true GNSS after GPS, although not until 2020. For now Bijou’s ambit is limited to the Asia Pacific region. Meanwhile Galileo and Glonass will not provide full global coverage in the foreseeable future. Both have been beset by financial problems at some stage of their development, with Galileo having been trimmed by various budget cuts.

Beidou faces no such constraints as China has made space a major priority with the recent announcement of acceleration in the overall program, and the intention to put a human on the moon soon after 2020. Indeed Beidou has expanded in scope since its inception, originally intended as purely a military system. China then joined Galileo in 2003, which was purely a civilian system, hoping that this would become an international consortium for consumer and business applications that would act as a counterweight to GPS. But partly probably because the EU’s commitment to Galileo appeared to be wavering in the mid noughties as budgets were cut, but chiefly we suspect because China decided the civilian navigational sector was a market of huge potential for its own businesses, it decided to pull out and focus completely on Beidou. Besides, deploying a GNSS is a costly business even for a country with China’s resources, so it seemed to make sense to concentrate on the one system. Significantly therefore China made big play of Beijou’s commercial potential at the launch of its second version last week. Consumer GPS technology has already proved a great success in the US and Europe, and now China wants some of the action.

Even so the military will have access to the best version of the technology for the time being, with civilian users receiving positional accuracy of 10 meters, and speed measurements down to 0.2 meters per second, which is just over 0.4 miles per hour. The Chinese military will have access to more accurate data.

This level of accuracy for civilian applications is nothing to write home about given the continual advances being made by GPS, which even before the latest so called L5 signals are widely used can deliver accuracies down to 10 cms for consumer applications given the most expensive kit, but more typically 1 to 5 meters. Even the 10 meter accuracy achieved by Beidou requires advanced techniques, probably including differential correction. In the absence of differential correction, GPS itself can achieve accuracy of only 50 to 100 meters, which is clearly useless for many of its current navigational, mapping and guidance applications. There are various sources of these errors, including signal distortion, atmospheric interference, slight drift in the satellite orbits (known as ephemeris error) and our old friend multipath caused by signals bouncing off reflective surfaces in transit and so arriving slightly out of phase.

Differential correction can reduce these errors by a factor of up to 1000 or potentially more by referring to a fixed ground station of known position somewhere in the vicinity of the receiver. The system then compares the calculated position of this fixed station with its actual position, and uses the difference to gauge the error correction to be applied. It is all relatively straightforward physics and math, but requires careful implementation and experience to perfect.

For this reason it will take some years for Beidou to catch up with GPS, which has already improved enormously through improvements in signal transmission and error correction. And GPS is continuing to evolve, with the latest improvement being the L5 signal, which will run at 1176.45 MHz alongside the existing L1 at 1575.42 MHz, and the second civilian signal at 1227.6 MHz. It is called L5 rather than say L3 because this is how the US government has documented this particular frequency. The two key benefits of L5 are an increase in transmitted power, which improves reception in areas with obstacles such as dense trees, and a 10 times increase in the number of pulses or symbols sent per second (known as the chipping rate). The latter also helps increase positional accuracy and speed measurement, while having a third frequency mitigates errors caused by signals bouncing off the ionosphere.

Beidou will be able to exploit these sorts of techniques since it, like the GPS, as well as Galileo, uses the CDMA (code-division multiple access) channel access method, which enables more accurate positioning than the alternative, an FDMA (frequency-division multiple access). As it happens GLONASS is the odd one out using FDMA.

This brings us back to the chip makers, which are already having to develop silicon implementing two or three satellite positioning methods, with GPS, Galileo, and GLONASS an increasingly popular combination. Now Beidou is being added to the mix, and while this will generate development costs it will also bring opportunities for still greater accuracy, particularly for urban locations or rugged terrain. The urban canyon effect reduces the number of satellites within direct line of sight of a receiver. This diminishes positional accuracy, and can enforce use of reflected signals that have taken multiple paths in order to obtain any sort of reading at all. But by using several systems, the effective constellation size is increased, and the receiver has line of sight with more satellites. Given Beidou’s large constellation size there is great potential to combine that with GPS and other systems to obtain greater accuracy, initially in the Asia Pacific region where Beidou will be available first.

In fact the Russian Federal Space Agency, concerned perhaps that GLONASS is slightly less accurate than GPS, is now taking the path of integration and constructive compatibility with its former Cold War foe, while seeking cooperation with Galileo and Beidou as well. The agency has developed a two-signal receiver that supports both GPS and Glonass. This mitigates the weaknesses of both, for while GPS may be more accurate generally, its signal is weak precisely in those northern latitudes for which GLONASS was optimized. The agency is also now seeking compatibility with the Indian Regional Navigational Satellite System (IRNSS), which is under development by the Indian Space Research Organization. Like Beidou, Galileo, and GLONASS, this was motivated by the desire to have a system guaranteed if use of GPS is restricted in the event of a conflict.

This is the pointer for chip makers, which can combine the one existing GNSS – GPS, with one or more of the regional systems to improve accuracy and coverage. Meanwhile the evolution of Beidou as a second genuine GNSS will galvanize China’s own navigational chip industry to become a major competitor.