On the face of it the $14 million investment by broadband wireless chipset maker Qualcomm in FON Wireless of WiFi crowdsourcing fame is relatively small beer. After all it is $1 million less than Qualcomm invested in December 2013 outside its core area in health care technology start-up Practice Fusion.
The deal’s significance for FON is that it signifies its intent to be a major player in the emerging field of Heterogeneous Networks (HetNets) seamlessly combining WiFi and 3G/4G/LTE cellular in a carrier class service.
FON’s business model to date has centered on selling its hotspot device, the $49 Fontera WiFi router, on the premise of giving up some unwanted home WiFi spectrum and Internet broadband bandwidth in return for access to the Homespots of other FON customers. This has proved successful in terms of customer growth, with FON’s worldwide base almost doubling over 2013 from 7 million to 12 million homes which offer this service.
This total was boosted by deals with various operators to gain access to their subscribers’ hot spots. Most notably, FON signed an agreement with AT&T in September 2013, gaining significant traction in the US for the first time, allowing mutual access to each other’s customer base.
AT&T customers can now access FON hotspots around the world through the operator’s WiFi International app, which gives a rather ungenerous 1GB of free WiFi data usage per month. In return, FON’s users will get access to their first big cluster of US hotspots, including about 30,000 in restaurants, hotels and stores.
FON’s model has done well and generated healthy revenue growth while users were grateful just for free access to WiFi away from home, if they were lucky enough to be within range of a FON hot spot. But increasingly users will be demanding more, including added value services but ultimately seamless mobile roaming within HetNets spanning WiFi and cellular.
In the first instance FON seems to have been shoring up its base against crowdsourcing startups attempting to steal its lunch, such as AirBnB, Lyft and Open Garden, by allowing users to share services and content in addition to their WiFi signal and broadband access. This is partly where the Qualcomm deal fits in, since FON will use some of the $14 million to develop a new router based on Qualcomm’s Atheros chipset enabling customers to share music. The chipset itself will meanwhile be optimized for operation in FON networks, supporting the sharing algorithm, and will be pitched at router manufacturers wanting to build FON crowdsourcing capability into their products.
Fonera routers work by splitting the WiFi signal in two, with a private one for the hot spot signal owner and a shared one for other FON members camping as guests. The two signals have different SSIDs (Service Set IDs) so that effectively there are two independent networks, each supporting different sets of devices identified by one of the SSIDs.
When it comes to FON’s HetNet strategy, the deal with Qualcomm over Atheros is only part of the story because successful HetNets also require client cooperation for intelligent routing between WiFi and cellular. FON has been shifting in this direction for some time after gaining traction in Europe with operators seeking to offload data from cellular networks onto WiFi/broadband.
This includes both cellular-only operators and major Telcos that have substantial broadband networks as well. The point is that while the latter may have national coverage for both cellular and broadband, they can only offload directly onto their own broadband infrastructures at the hot spots of their fixed Internet customers. They are therefore interested either in crowdsourcing, but also in the case of larger players in building WiFi networks to complement their cellular service. This was the case for Deutsche Telekom, which in March 2013 reached an announced partnership with FON, initially to give its customers free access to the existing 12,000 plus FON hot spots in Germany, via a service with the not particularly catchy name of WLan To Go. The bigger part of the deal will extend WLan to Go by building public hot spots, which Deutsche Telekom claims will number 2.5 million by the end of 2016, motivated as much for now by cost savings from offloading cellular data traffic to the more cost effective and efficient broadband infrastructure as in attracting customers with a seamless HetNet service.
This reflects the fact that HetNets will depend heavily on software in the client for effective operation, albeit operating in conjunction with the operator’s network as well as increasingly with the WiFi hot spots. A number of vendors such as Stockholm based Birdstep, and Devicescape headquartered in San Bruno, California, have set up their stall as providers of handset software enabling efficient and secure access to HetNets, using the mantra of ‘intelligent network selection’ to describe the process of switching users between WiFi and cellular.
HetNets represent an evolution of cellular services with the WiFi connectivity effectively bolted on. The first step is simply to have hot spots available, whether through crowdsourcing or a dedicated WiFi infrastructure set up and run by an operator, providing access to users in the vicinity via some sign on procedure. The next step is to make the WiFi sign on seamless and this has proved challenging to accomplish in such a way that it is as secure as the cellular part of the service. Most of the operators that have so far partnered with FON have therefore developed their own applications to automate the login process, but for various reasons they have tended to be available only on Android and not Apple iOS devices.
Where iOS is supported the app usually has to be opened first before the WiFi network can be accessed, so some manual intervention has still been required.
The emerging solution allowing ubiquitous access from all devices is to support EAP SIM authentication, which allows subscribers’ devices to connect automatically to WiFi based on credentials on their SIM card, rather than having to download an application. This is based on EAP (Extensible Authentication Protocol), but using the identity and credentials held in the SIM card by referring the authentication to the cellular core network to gain access to the WiFi system, rather than requiring a pre-established password.
This requires three elements, a wireless hotspot, a centralized authentication manager known as a RADIUS server that supports EAP-SIM, and a central database containing the details of each of the mobile operator’s subscribers, called the HLR (Home Location Register). All three must be coordinated for seamless HetNet operation. Quite often, all three elements will be controlled by the same operator, but increasingly roaming agreements will enable users from third parties to be authenticated seamlessly, as HetNets grow.
From a customer’s prospective, EAP-SIM will score highly by providing wide coverage with the highest quality of service available at a given time and place. Instead of having to search for an open SSID and inserting account credentials, handsets are connected to the best network available within signal range. Then from the operator’s business standpoint, EAP-SIM will greatly improve the data offload potential of WiFi networks, since users can be automatically transferred to a hot spot from 3G or 4G networks on the basis of defined policy rules that can take account of factors such as congestion on the respective networks, as well as the user’s device status such as battery life and the demands of the service being used at the time.
FON has yet to tie its credentials to EAP SIMs, although this is expected soon. Meanwhile some of the vendors such as Birdstep support EAP-SIM in their client software and have deployed this with cellular operators. This does raise the issue of data caps, since some FON partners including both AT&T and BT still impose ceilings on WiFi usage. If they are going to allow seamless switching to WiFi they will have to be careful their customers are not hit by punitive bills for exceeding their limit, or they must include separate WiFi limits or merge the caps on both services. The best bet is that these caps will be quickly abolished when on WiFi, in the HetNet era.
This comes back to Quantenna, which has joined the specialist vendors in offering client software for intelligent WiFi offload. As part of its chipset software for the Snapdragon handset SoCs (system on Chips), Qualcomm has developed its Connectivity Engine (CnE) comprising algorithms that enable intelligent management of device connectivity. CnE has two components, Network Socket Request Manager (NSRM) for data management across a HetNet and WiFi Quality Estimation (WQE) for intelligent WiFi offload.
This is not involved in the deal with FON but is part of the story, since together Snapdragon and the Atheros chips will participate in complete HetNets. CnE and similar client software will play a key role in accessing and processing the data to provide a basis for intelligent selection of either WiFi or 4G/LTE according to the operator’s business rules. On the WiFi side it will help the operator balance traffic between guests and hosts, which has been one of the issues facing FON and other crowdsourcing providers. While they all partition customer’s networks they cannot do it flexibly, for example to enable the whole capacity to be made available to people outside when no home users are active.
We can recall Thomas Nogues, Cable Europe Labs Director of Technology Advocacy, criticizing FON at TV Connect 2013 last March for lacking the ability to control and monitor access to a subscriber’s WiFi network by visiting friends or guest subscribers. For this reason Nogues suggested then that FON would not appeal to cable operators, who were therefore building out their own hot spot infrastructures as part of their mobility strategies. Examples include Virgin Media in the London Underground, and Kabel Deutschland in Germany equipping its street cabinets with WiFi equipment for Internet access.
But FON has come some way since Nogues made that speech, notably clinching those deals with AT&T and Deutsche Telekom, the partnership with Qualcomm and not least the continued rapid expansion of its customer base. The partnership with Qualcomm in particular is likely to help rectify the lack of control over customers’ hot spots. It will probably not be long before FON adds another MSO to its customer list beyond Zon of Portugal, which has been on board since 2008.