The Fairytale of New York was a very two sided song, sung by the Pogues, which talked about the dreams and disasters of an Irish couple, who met in New York. And the WiFi Offload Summit held this week in Frankfurt felt similar ‘ there were swearwords under the breath, clear taking of sides and a lot of double speak. We define doublespeak as saying one thing when you mean the opposite. It’s like hypocrisy, but is worst in that you know you are doing it
So it didn’t really surprise us when Doctor Matthias Siebert, billed as Europe and Technology Mobile Access, asked and answered whether WiFi Offload was a fairytale or a Swiss Army Knife, and he concluded that it was closer to being a Fairytale than anything else.
Yes we can see that perhaps he didn’t really mean it, or at least not all of it, and it was supposed to be a clever way of getting the conference off to a controversial start, but it caused a rapid shaking of heads and sighs of disbelief.
Siebert told the audience that he had concluded this after two WiFi trials in Rotterdam and Hamburg, when basically consumers were allowed free WiFi, but knew that it was WiFi and began doing lots of things that they would usually do at home. He made the point that since a number of apps wanted to upgrade, that this was previously set so that it was ONLY a WiFi activity, so it didn’t really count as offload activity, since it was traffic that was never on the cellular network.
Of course this was not a fair use of seamless WiFi, since the trials were not seamless and big signs were put up saying ‘use our free WiFi.’ In that sense it was an experiment that was designed to fail. One attendee leaned over to me and said, ‘Does he know that T-Mobile US is offloading about 28% of its traffic already?’
Siebert perhaps never thought that given that the devices were his devices, DT should have wanted to take care of that traffic. In fact cellular activity went up he reported, so it could hardly be called offload, and WiFi was new activity that his network had never seen, so he distanced himself from it. It is a typical ‘bury your head in the sand and say black is white,’ attitude that the ever cautious Deutsche Telekom is famous for ‘ although we should not expect that the predilections of a DT engineer, make its policy.
But it remains amazing how cellular professionals distance themselves from WiFi networks ‘ they do it automatically, like a knee jerk reaction – and they use terms like Trusted to define the security inside a cellular network and ‘untrusted’ to talk about activity in any other kind of network, especially WiFi, however secure it is or isn’t, and terms like Quality of Experience and yet conveniently forget what kind of experience their consumer is going through when an operator elects on their behalf to force them to burn LTE data, despite blazingly fast free WiFi being available. That consumer experience is a flawed one and yet MNO employees continue to believe that their job is only to protect the part of the experience which they can see and control. The rest of it can go to hell simply because they believe that their network cannot be blamed.
There were immediate many dissenting voices at the show (although not any quite as dissenting perhaps as this article) and in every case there emerged an MNO apologist (supremacist?) from the floor, usually an engineer steeped in 3GPP speak who insists that you ‘know far more about the conditions around the user when you look at the network not the device,’ or some such. Of course everyone in the room except those employed full time by a cellular operator knows that the best place to understand offload is on the device or by talking to its user.
In our own Faultline presentation, when interrupted by someone who began with the lack of QoE in WiFi, we pointed out that a) it was usually perceived as Free, b) consumers mostly prefer it to fading cellular connections and c) the reason we are all here is the congested and unpredictable nature of cellular, we’re trying to fix it, and most times the engineer then sat down ‘ although we noted more muttering under their breath about how we didn’t understand (our speech is summed up our new report ‘WiFi Revisited,’ out next week).
One of the clues for Dr Siebert to digest was in his own presentation, and others are on his web site. He seemed to think it was a good thing that 52% of his customers told him that when they were on WiFi they did different things, like download apps, watch movies, browse the web ‘ well if LTE networks are not for that then what are they for. The other clue is that until recently, in fact last year, Deutsche Telekom’s idea of all you can eat data was 400 MB a month. Today on its web site its Allnet flat plan still offers 200 MB of data a month. But as its LTE service have filled out and it has 1GB, 3GB and 10 GB tiers.
But while Deutsche Telekom is early to LTE it was perhaps late to arrive at high data caps, and it has always been an operator that historically has shortchanged its customers in data caps. And now that it has a brand new LTE network, WiFi offload is anathema to it ‘ until that network is filled with video data three years from now then perhaps its attitude will change yet again. Siebert should have understood about latent demand and bill shock, but he didn’t appear to.
Siebert said that despite the amenity WiFi system in downtown Hamburg burning up 70 GB a day and in Rotterdam some 30 GB a day, in the end the Rotterdam signal was switched off and he said, ‘the WiFi traffic just disappeared,’ although annoyingly consumers now continued to use more data, as if they had somehow been tainted with the free WiFi.
But if respect for the largest operator there and the opening keynote speaker meant that criticism was muted, for the rest of the summit we heard a lot of sense from the likes of Birdstep, Aptilo, the UK’s EE and innovators like Signal Share, an arena specialist in the US that has built its own equipment to bring mass WiFi to the followers of pop groups or major league sports and the Las Vegas casinos.
Lonnie Schilling, CEO of Birdstep was perhaps the only speaker who directly attacked the ideas of Siebert, by referring directly to them ‘ ‘the WiFi traffic of Deutsche Telekom did not disappear,’ he said, ‘the consumers went off somewhere else to find their free WiFi’ taking with them a negative impression of the operator who had cut them off.
He added, ‘Only the handset has the opportunity to understand everything that the customer is doing with the handset, and operators have to tap into that knowledge.’ Schilling went on to talk about the Birdstep philosophy, endorsing a dynamic policy for network selection, based not just on WiFi signal strength (after all a strong WiFi signal may be a stub and have no internet behind it), but also on propagation delay, jitter and overall access point throughput, which are all best calculated on the device.
But Schilling also pointed to a lot of new horizons coming out of the spectrum poor US market, which needs WiFi offload a lot more urgently than the US, ‘We need heuristics, that can point the way to advertising and network capacity planning and location planning. The operations department now needs to know what the handset is doing all the time, not just when it is on their network, he said, ‘if you understand the subscriber’s behavior, for instance see how he responds to a voucher offer at a WiFi venue owned by a retailer, then perhaps you can lower the cost of customer acquisition, and come up with new tariff models that work.’
On a later panel Siebert persisted with his network oriented viewpoint saying that the best data was achieved for this type of thing only through knowing where the consumer went within the entire cellular footprint, not just in one store, but was countered by Schilling reminding him that in cellular dead spots while on a WiFi network, his phone appeared to be doing nothing, when it was very active, and that Siebert’s approach offered absolutely no view of this.
Schilling was not the only person to take on board this message about building a deep awareness of the consumers and many of his points were taken up by Torbj’rn W’rd, CEO of Aptilo, an Ericsson offshoot. Ward speaks with the experience of working with 90 WiFi operators in 60 countries, and with over 30 cellcos and has dealings with TeliaSonera, Telenor, Swisscom and 3 Group in Europe as well as Claro in Latin America.
Aptilo tries to take the technical grief out of managing WiFi customers from a 3GPP infrastructure, and does API translation and OSS integration and service management across both types of network.
Ward spoke of instances where he had seen 50% of the cellular traffic disappear overnight when seamless authentication was added to an existing stable WiFi installation, such as at an airport, and talked about offloading 40,000 GB in a month at an airport, completely contradicting Siebert’s earlier assertions that offloading was a fairytale.
He made the point that the network owners need to look at offloading for all types of devices, not just SIM based handsets, ‘because people take their WiFi only devices out with them and the MNO operator can develop data plans for those.’ His approach involved tunneling back into the cellular core to do authentication using EAP TTLS and also taking the traffic through the core using GTP Tunneling, rather than decrypting it where it was. ‘If you agree with a video vendor to accelerate its product, then you have to have a record of that transaction inside your network, to prove that you carried it through your backhaul, before you can charge for it.’ So Ward was one of many players starting to think about a combined cellular and WiFi network as if it was a single network which is a resource cellular operators can harness.
Siebert had no answer to how to offer services to non-SIM based products like Tablets ‘ to him, and to his purely cellular network, tablets must be invisible (or mythical) , or at least the 80% that do not have SIM connections.
The EE (Everything Everywhere the merger of Orange and T-Mobile in the UK with 27 million customers) contribution was from Graham Cove, the head of WiFi services there, and he talked about his own company being full of people who say ‘We don’t need WiFi, we’ve got LTE.’ But Cove has grown a business out of building and running WiFi services for retailers and one of the latest to sign up is Asda, where 580 stores have signed up to have a single WiFi service coordinated across the entire chain.
Asda is owned by Wal-Mart and he insists they would have thrown him out if he had turned up offering an EE portal and sign on, and said that it was only for EE customers. Instead this is about charging these stores so they can ‘give away’ free WiFi, but helping the retailer get revenue back in turn. He made the point that in most of these stores you cannot get a mobile signal, so this is not offload as such. But if those stores also offered WiFi offload, many cellular services might then be available in stores that often act as virtual Faraday cages.
Cove talked about the value to the retailer coming from knowing that the WiFi was being offered by the store, and in offering them vouchers ‘before’ they leave the store, through WiFi on their phone, to stimulate purchases, rather than handing out paper vouchers at the till. He also said that the WiFi could draw a map of shopping patterns, telling which aisles consumers do not go down, so that traffic plans could help the store become more profitable. In Asda WiFi access is granted when they validate their phone number, and then Asda can use the 750,000 phone numbers they have collected to do active marketing. On subsequent visits the store portal is not invoked and the visit becomes ‘seamless.’
Our own contribution to the show was in the workshop the day before, pointing out the incredibly compelling argument that using some of the 650 million existing broadband lines through WiFi, plus all the commercial hotspots out there, was the only economically viable way of satisfying the mostly video driven data demand over the next 5 years.
And David Nowicki, CMO at Devicescape, echoed that sentiment talking about one client that had 100 plus main macrocell bases stations and 200 plus Small cells, but inside that territory found some 27,000 existing WiFi access points it might make use of, if it wished to.
He continued lighting up the amenity (free municipal) WiFi around the major US towns on maps and showed that 43% of WiFi in San Francisco and 23% of New York was FREE amenity WiFi and that this trend is slowly spreading over Europe and Asia, ‘The major chains begin offering free WiFi and then the minor retailers have follow. And the trend has become more open, less locked down. In Europe over five years we have seen 100% of WiFi being paid for and now it’s under 40%, while in the US it has gone from 40% paid down to 7% in the same time frame.’ Nowicki encouraged operators not to think about the cellular experience any more, but to think about the Smartphone experience. His company pushes the idea of segmenting all users and putting them in varied categories of who to offload from the network and when and on which applications, and believes in being very dynamic with ever-changing offload policies.
All of this has led to perhaps 30 operators globally who are freely offloading cellular activity to WiFi in a truly seamless manner, and this is the first event devoted to that practice, and in that sense so far it is a Fairytale, but now that it has a voice (the next event is to be held in California) then it may well be a fairytale that will come true.
The Fairytale of New York would not have been complete without a New Yorker attending in the form of Arthur Giftakis, VP of Engineering and Network Operations at Towerstream. This company made headlines in around 2004 when it signed up the roof rights for the Empire State building to build a WiMAX wireless broadband network for enterprises in the sky around New York City. Since then it has signed more famous roof rights and spread it wings to Chicago, Boston, Fort Worth, Los Angeles, Miami and San Francisco to name but a few.
It has spent the last few years trying to turn this into a WiFi network and as new equipment has come along to make this possible, the existing backhaul and roof rights have made it an irresistible WiFi offload network for the offloading efforts of one of the tier 1 US network, ‘There are only two but I can’t tell you which one,’ Giftakis said. Showing that at least in the US, even tier 1 networks believe in Fairytales, whereas in the land of Grimm, where Fairytales are supposed to have first come from (Germany) tier one operators are NOT inclined to believe.