Entone Technologies CEO Steve McKay took a strong position against adding Internet-connected features to smart TVs. Entone is a company that focuses on connected home solutions and hybrid TV. McKay was speaking on a panel at CES, along with representatives from Marvell, Qualcomm, Rovi, thePlatform and Vevo, who were also panelists. Notably, there were no TV makers present on the panel.
McKay said TV makers should stick to displays. ‘I have a contrarian and self-serving view on this one,’ said McKay. ‘Your TV should be the best display device you can get with money. It should not have all this other stuff on it.’
McKay said TV makers are looking to add value to the TV set, because the margins on TV manufacturing are so low. ‘They have to find ways to make money and value and get the consumer to see that value,’ he said. ‘So things like Ultra HD is one way of doing that, so is putting intelligence in the TV.’
The problem he pointed to is the fragmentation across smart TVs and their operating systems. McKay relayed to the audience an anecdote about his own house. ‘We have at least two dozen ways to access the same content on Netflix, six of those devices are on TVs, from five different manufacturers,’ he said. ‘The experience across those TVs ‘ it’s all completely different. They all perfectly suit our needs today, the last thing our family needs is another TV, and yet, we are hundreds of firmware versions behind.’ He said some of the TV set makers stop offering updates for content apps for older versions of the sets ‘ older meaning two years or so. ‘Literally we have TVs where the OTT apps are dying,’ he said and added, ‘Smart TVs are a dumb idea.’
A handful of panel speakers agreed that TV sets won’t ever be replaced the same way smartphones, tablets and even net-top boxes are being replaced. That means any smart TV operating system will need to remain relevant for as long as possible. McKay said TV makers today aren’t doing a very good job of it.
Peter Hoddie, VP of the Kinoma Platform at Marvell, said there currently aren’t any incentives for TV makers to treat their operating systems more seriously. ‘There’s some cautionary tales in mobile,’ Hoddie said. ‘For those of us who use Android phones, how up-to-date is your software? The answer for most of us is not terribly, because there isn’t a business model in place for the people making those phones to have incentive to upgrade the software.’
Hoddie said the same is true for TV makers. ‘TV makers will put any app on the television that’s hot right now, to make you buy it,’ he said. ‘They can do it, then in two years when it doesn’t work, they don’t care ‘ because the business model isn’t there.’
Hoddie said if smart TVs are going to succeed, the TV makers will need to use standards to ensure that apps can continue to be updated. ‘If you have the right standards in place, there will be people who have the ability to update your content, even if the manufacturer doesn’t,’ Hoddie said. ‘Whether that’s coming from the cloud, a phone, a gateway, whatever, that isn’t so important as the fact that the TV is open enough, through the standards that it’s adopting and implementing, so that it can continue to receive new content and services.’
Panelists said keeping the smarts in the set-top or net-top box underneath the TV is easier to manage because those can be changed out much more quickly.
‘One typically doesn’t buy a TV every couple of years, more like seven or ten years,’ said Hugo Swart, director of product management at Qualcomm. ‘So the set top could be one way to upgrade its capabilities with the latest technology.’
Ian Greenblatt, VP of strategy and business development at Arris, agreed. ‘In truth, the evolution of set tops mirrors that of mobile telephones,’ he said. ‘We’re only 10 years into thinking about phones as anything more than a two-way radio. It’s not a long time. Set-tops have charted a similar migration from just conditional access, being able to verify ‘yes you are allowed to see this content,’ to much more than that, making sure that your content is available inside and outside the home, fully authenticated in the best possible experience.’
Consumers are finding ways to keep their TVs up-to-date, too. Net-top boxes such as Apple TVs, Rokus, and Chromecasts are actually prolonging the life spans of so-called dumb TVs, because now they can be connected to the Internet with next-generation UIs, for as little as $35.
For service providers, there are also software approaches to keeping the content updated on the TV set, without refreshing the TV or the set-top box. ‘The point is that it is going to take quite a bit of time to replace all of the legacy boxes with the newer boxes that have Internet capabilities,’ said Bob Shallow, SVP of sales and marketing at Rovi. ‘What you’re seeing in the mean-time is an integration of IP services with legacy, QAM-based services, and the need to create a hybrid solution.’
Shallow said Rovi is currently focused on just this problem, creating hybrid services that sit on top of legacy infrastructure but that can use cloud technology to deliver next-generation user experiences. ‘We’re moving these services that have been locked in these legacy back offices into the cloud, so that you can enable more services to these connected TVs,’ Shallow said.
Marty Roberts, thePlatform’s SVP of sales and marketing, agreed that the smarts of any content service should be moved to the cloud, and not rely on fragmented hardware. ‘We see a lot of companies investing in that cloud infrastructure, and that sets them up for all kinds of opportunity,’ he said.