Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 January 2014

WiFi will become dominant partner in US wireless patchwork

Verizon and AT&T have the luxury of relatively plentiful beachfront spectrum plus fiber to help develop new services and revenue streams, but others are less fortunate and have to look for other sources of new capacity and competitive edge. The most important is currently carrier-class WiFi, which is moving rapidly beyond its initial role ‘ to offload less profitable or more network-hogging traffic to a best effort network. Instead, operators are looking to make WiFi and its unlicensed spectrum as ‘3GPP-like’ as possible by controlling them from their main packet cores and building their own networks. One of the most disruptive uses of WiFi, at least before that fully integrated HetNet becomes a reality, is seen when it becomes the primary, rather than the back-up, option in a cellco’s offering.

The US is leading in this respect, and several MVNOs have launched services which rely mainly on low cost, plentiful WiFi and only transfer the user to 3G/4G when there is no good WiFi signal available.

Republic Wireless kicked off the trend in 2012 with a ‘WiFi first’ mobile service and has been emulated by other MVNOs, most recently Scratch Wireless. These start-ups have consumer propositions but much of their steady revenue will come from providing offload services for network owners, as the cellcos look to expand the range of hotspots they can access for this purpose. They all minimize their MVNO fees by motivating users to stay on WiFi whenever possible, but Scratch has gone the furthest by encouraging consumers to stay entirely on WiFi, making this the first totally free wireless service. The user pays $269 for the Motorola Photon Q handset and then there are no other costs unless he or she strays onto cellular, in which case there are day or month passes available for Sprint’s network, but in very unattractive amounts ‘ just 25Mbytes for $1.99 a day, for instance. Most of Scratch’s revenue comes from device sales and some from cellular usage but offload and other non-consumer sources will be important for growth.

Now the big cellcos are also getting interested in WiFi first. T-Mobile already offers first-party WiFi calling on some plans and devices, and Sprint is reported to be planning a similar offering for the Samsung Galaxy S4 mini and the Galaxy Mega, extending to new Android devices in future. The free service will be called WiFi Calling, according to the Android Central blog

In Europe too, the scale of disruption that is possible by using good quality, carrier-controlled WiFi as the primary network is seen most clearly in Free’s impact on the French market. Free’s strategy is heavily based on hotspots and, even more significantly, homespots (access points within the subscriber’s home which have a portion of their capacity unsecured for passers-by to use). These homespots are under the operator’s control to a greater extent than many public hotspots, they can create a dense cloud of capacity at very low cost, and they integrate with the customers’ home services too. One of the biggest changes in the US landscape will come when the alliance of cablecos ‘ Comcast Xfinity, Time Warner Cable, Cox, BrightHouse and Cablevision Optimum ‘ fully harnesses the national network of WiFi hotspots it is creating, and also moves into homespots (as Comcast is already doing).

That will give the cablecos the national wireless network they once planned to build in licensed spectrum, and as well as supporting some form of quad play, will also reduce their dependence on paying MVNO fees, since 3G/4G access can be reserved for occasions when subscribers are out of WiFi coverage. The emergence of standards like Hotspot 2.0, which transfer users seamlessly between cellular and WiFi and automate authentication, will help make such strategies appealing to customers. And another important development was glimpsed this week when Qualcomm invested in homespot pioneer FON (see separate item), and talked about integrating the capabililty on its WiFi chips.

Such moves will help make WiFi a true equal in the mobile patchwork, and in many price-pressured consumer business models, will turn it into the dominant partner. Arguably LTE will become a premium network mainly focused on non-consumer services where quality of service is critical (enterprise, IoT, fixed line video/TV and so on). The cablecos and other non-cellular players know this and will take advantage of the changed balance of power. If licensed spectrum is no longer the most valuable asset in a consumer mobile broadband play, the cellcos will lose their advantage over non-mobile rivals. Hence the rising interest in WiFi, the somewhat dampened enthusiasm for expensive licensed spectrum, and the opportunity for a real shake-up of the US market. Against that backdrop, whether or not Dish or Sprint gets T-Mobile is far less significant to the shape of the US telecoms and media landscape than it would have been two years ago.