Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 January 2014

IPR bust up led by Cresta in silicon tuner market as volumes swell

US chip designer Cresta Technologies seems to be asking the US International Trade Commission (ITC) to halt the import of the top brands of TV sets into the US, in a patent infringement component war against other chip rivals.

We have been hearing about how the Silicon tuner market will shortly become a $500 million business for the past four years, and the same three or four players still seem to be fighting it out, and now have, for the second time reached for their lawyers.

Cresta Technology, the specialist which acquired XCeive in 2011 is suing both MaxLinear and Silicon Laboratories for patent infringements relating to silicon tuners, as a consequence trying to prevent four unnamed TV manufacturers from importing TVs with these chips inside. We would hazard a guess that Samsung is one of these, and that LG and Vizio are probably among the other three, given that MaxLinear just landed a global tuner deal with Samsung a few months ago. In fact the whole thing might be sour grapes at losing that deal.

The three Cresta patents in question cover technology that enables a single television receiver to process analog or digital television signals in multiple standards, making it possible for a television to work anywhere in the world. The patented technologies also eliminate the need for bulky traditional ‘can’ tuners, thus substantially reducing the cost of developing thin, flat panel televisions.

Cresta’s XCeive acquisition certainly supplied the latter of these patents, having sold products that tuned RF signals of any variety, and passed them to separate components, such as the CPU on a PC, for demodulating. In this way the same tuner can be supplied to devices sold all over the world, and the local flavor (ATSC, DVB-T, ISDB-T) can be loaded in software.

But other companies have also offered such devices including MaxLinear, UK company Mirics (which provided it for Dell PCs) and also Silicon Labs. Microtune that was subsequently sold to Zoran, also sold similar components and today among the larger silicon players ST Micro, NXP and Marvell all sell IC tuners, which can replace the CAN tuners sold in TV sets. We think that the ST Micro technology is licensed from MaxLinear anyway. We wonder if these and Broadcom, with its Full Band Capture technology, will also be targeted later. Silicon Labs on its website lists Samsung, Huawei and LG among its customers.

Creta wants an investigation into the alleged violations and seeks an exclusion order to halt imports. So no TVs for all of the US for a while? We’re fairly sure that would harm the TV manufacturers and their distributors, who are innocent parties here, in which case the ITC won’t agree to it. The company is also seeking a cease and desist order to stop the marketing and sale of the devices within the US. Cresta initially filed the infringement case in the District Court of Delaware a week earlier.

While the companies it is complaining about are both public, in April last year Cresta took on a $13 million round of funding from four venture capital groups Bechtolsheim Ventures, Benhamou Global Ventures, Sofinnova Ventures and AVM Capital, saying that the money would be spent accelerating development of its Smart Tuner ICs for use in Smart TVs. Cresta has design wins for its products at Orion Electric in Japan and Vestel, and Turkish company that supports a number of European TV brands, but none of the top five global TV brands.

Cresta sells something it calls Smart Tuner technology, and says, ‘Our goal is to resolve a situation where others profit unfairly from our inventions and to enable all TV makers to continue to offer great products while respecting the trade protections of the United States.’

In May Cresta came out with its 4th generation of Smart Tuner, the X7 with specialized versions for South America and China. Interestingly South America has now mostly opted for ISDB-T for its digital terrestrial broadcast TV, and this is where MaxLinear holds a huge market share and a number of patents. It once held 70% market share in Japan where ISDB-T was created.

Cresta says that it is the only silicon TV tuner manufacturer that provides a single chip solution for digital TV with a built-in analog demodulator and dual inputs. It may be true that this capability went into more than one chip among its rivals, but as we said, Mirics did something similar in PCs in 2008 and MaxLinear has something analogous to Full Band Capture called Full Spectrum Capture, which can separate it out from the demodulator.

Cresta claims its product is in tens of millions of TVs, and its architecture combines a frequency-agile RF front end with a DSP-based IF processor. That set up is hardly innovative and there is a distinct possibility that eventually these patents will be challenged and found to be obvious. The X7 Smart Tuner includes full broadband tuning from 42 to 1000MHz, CPU calibrated LNA, mixers and channel filters.

Funnily enough the suit emerged on the day that Silicon Labs came out with its annual results, with revenues slightly down for the quarter to $146.2 million, but up for the year, to a record $580.1 million, throwing off quarterly net income of $10.6 million.

Last quarter MaxLinear grew revenue 14% up to $31.8 million based on successes in DOCSIS modems, video gateways and hybrid TV tuners, but it made a loss of $4.9 million, as it is still ramping revenues and still cash rich, with over $83 million in the bank.

Back in October MaxLinear and Silicon Labs had their own settlement over patent infringement actions, which involved cross patent licensing, with a net payment from MaxLinear to Silicon Labs of $1.25 million, which is a likely outcome in this case also.

But you get the impression that Cresta is not doing anywhere near as well as MaxLinear, and resents this and so is throwing its IPR weight around, having been around for some years, perhaps longer than either of the others. TV sets consume about half of all silicon TV tuners with Silicon Labs, NXP, MaxLinear, Sony and Cresta all supplying the market.