Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 January 2014

AT&T U-Verse still paying dividends as FiOS runs out of steam

Annual results out from AT&T once again focus on the growth or otherwise of cellular customers and a comparison with Verizon, which most analysts are saying looks the stronger of the two. As always our focus is not to ignore the wireline business, as if it is irrelevant, and AT&T performed here more or less the same as Verizon did last week, with fixed line revenues down by 1.4% while Verizon was down 1.3%. Much the same pattern is going on at AT&T with new lines, in this case U-Verse and in Verizon’s case FiOS ‘ rising, while the older lines are being ravaged by the cable industry.

When we first started writing about this at Faultline there were savage falls in fixed line revenue, but both companies then reversed it towards the end of the Noughties as they established their TV platforms. Today decline has crept in once more for both telcos.

The headline numbers are that revenues for all of AT&T are 1.8% up at $33.16 billion, but that while wireless is up 4.5% at $18.4 billion, wireline is off by 1.4% at $14.7 billion. Net income is massively improved at Wireless up 54% to $3.93 billion, but of course that’s compared with the year when AT&T had to pay out $6 billion in cash and spectrum to T-Mobile, after it failed to get approval to merge with it.

AT&T said that U-verse revenues grew by 27.9% and now it is a $13 billion annualized revenue stream. It added just 194,000 U-Verse TV customers last quarter, 100,000 more than Verizon managed in its results out last week, taking it to 5.5 million in service, up 924,000 for the full year. AT&T also added 630,000 U-Verse internet customers, smashing Verizon’s 126,000 FiOS broadband adds, which resulted in a rise in internet lines across the entire company for Verizon of only 20,000. AT&T also segments off U-Verse broadband adds from its overall broadband number and said only that broadband subs were broadly flat, which means it lost as many ADSL lines as it added U-Verse, so around 630,000. It’s tough to tell exactly if this means that these 630,000 were all offered deals to upgrade, or were upgraded almost without being asked, or if there is a certain amount of losing some low level customers and gaining some new ones.

It’s not too surprising and AT&T has the same number of broadband customers now that it had in 2007, around 16.4 million, and an increasing number, now over 10.4 million on the U-Verse infrastructure. Given that these customers pay almost no premium for U-Verse broadband these days, it won’t affect broadband ARPU that much, although it will push down churn.

Despite most coverage for US financial analysts saying that Verizon is doing a far better job in the cellular market, and we have to applaud its adventures in smartphone video, and the purchase of Intel’s OnCue rights and infrastructure last week, AT&T appears to be sliding ahead in fixed line services and there is a good chance that we will see a change of strategy soon from Verizon, for instance it may begin offering vectored VDSL broadband when AT&T offers it, to ramp up its broadband speeds. The truth is that the 2007 inspired Project Lightspeed from AT&T took fiber much closer to homes that ever before, while FiOS took fiber all the way and was more expensive.

Looking back, hindsight tells us that AT&T’s strategy was better, and now Verizon might start focusing on copper and fiber only to the cabinet, to get itself back into growth.