Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 January 2014

Ofcom forced to adjust competition rates as BT fiddles figures.

British Telecom’s latest figures would have led to a massive increase in the wholesale broadband throughout the UK, so regulator Ofcom has proposed changing the formula under which it calculates wholesale prices, to adjust for how BT put together its numbers.

The implication is that BT ‘arranged’ it numbers to have a maximum effect on the wholesale broadband price, and Ofcom has refined the formula in order to correct this. The new formula is now out for reviewing from affected stakeholders and you can be sure that other broadband suppliers in the UK will have plenty to say about it.

Ofcom had originally calculated a rate at which to charge for wholesale access, dependent on BT’s Regulatory Financial Statements and prices. As BT has released new version of these for 2013 Ofcom felt it had to issue an amended review.

The 91-page report is some hundred pages shorter than the initial review published in July of last year, which assessed the level of competition within the British broadband market. The focus of the review was to ‘consider the appropriate form of ‘ex ante’ regulation, if any, that should be imposed in the market, to identify any competition problems and impose appropriate remedies.’

BT wholesale pricing as of December 2013 was £5.88 a month for an ADSL or ADSL2+ line, and between £13 and £16 a month for fiber to the cabinet (VDSL) connections with varying upstream speeds.

The tactic of anchor pricing ‘ensures that customers will not be made worse off as a result of BT changing the technology it uses.’ Ofcom’s scheme ignores BT’s 21st Century Network Fiber to the Home upgrade, and assumes that copper wiring will remain the standard.

Ofcom’s new calculation of the charge is set as the Consumer Price Index of inflation (CPI) minus X ‘ where X ranges from -15.2% and -8.7%. That has changed from the July calculation of CPI-X where X ranged from -7% to -1%. That the Ofcom rate has increased so dramatically is perhaps evidence of the need for regulation of the incumbent monopolies that run the core network. It is also proof that anchoring a rate to the prices of the incumbent’s services is open for manipulation.

The European Commission, and the local national regulators, will face similar challenges as all European networks are upgraded. A technology that can greatly increase the speed of networks is vectoring and in order to wholesale this it must be sold as a bitstream, rather than by unbundling the local loop. In order to get the most from vectoring all of the lines in an exchange need to go through the same noise cancellation server as each other, so splitting them into multiple suppliers slows the lines down, because the noise cannot be completely cancelled.

Vodafone already has a bitstream deal from Deutsche Telekom, which gave it access to 50Mbps lines in Germany, that will rise to 100Mbps in the near future. Due to the need for Deutsche Telekom to control the lines in order for its vectoring technology to work, and a similar position will emerge for BT in the UK and new wholesale prices will be needed for this as well as permission to eliminate unbundling from the regulator.