Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 February 2014

Sports programming ‘ The tail that wags the pay TV dog ‘ Part 2

There was a time when televised sport was only shown on Free To Air TV, in some cases with rival stations transmitting the same popular events like major finals and competing for eyeballs by trying to offer the best commentary. It may be that now pay TV has stolen most of the best events, so that they are shown exclusively by one provider in a given market, the quality of commentary has gone down, but the amount of top content available has exploded. Now many games and events that could only be seen by spectators at the ground or perhaps as TV highlights, are now shown live and attract huge audiences that have made pay TV the successful industry it now today.

But this does not mean all pay TV operators feel compelled to bid for premium sports rights. Many are content to play as aggregators or distributors, either never having been in the business of owning sports rights, like Liberty Global’ s Virgin Media in the UK, or having at least backed off significantly, like Orange in France. Liberty Global as a whole has some lesser sports on its books, but has tended to avoid premium events, but even so there was speculation that would change with its takeover of Virgin Media early in 2013. Then CEO Mike Fries emphasised that nothing would change and that Virgin Media would not start bidding against Sky or BT for premium football rights in the UK. There was no need for Liberty Global to take the high risk strategy BT had to in order to get a leg up into pay TV, because it is already successful.

The UK situation highlights the different dynamics of pay TV across the leading European markets, although availability of premium sports has a major role in all cases. In the UK premium sports, at least football rights, has become locked into the fight between Sky and BT over broadband. BT said around 1.5 million of its broadband customers were also subscribers to Sky’s DTH platform and it was clear that its overall broadband growth was being sapped by churn to Sky. This can be seen to some extent in the numbers, for according to broadband research group Point Topic, BT’s broadband base rose from 6.44 million to 6.78 million over the nine months September 2012 to July 2013, while Sky was up from 4.10 million to 4.91 million over that period, about three times the percentage growth rate.

BT Sport was launched in August 2013 in time for the start of the first English Premier League (EPL) season it had rights for and so it is too early to discern clearly what impact that has had, since the last quarter’s figures are yet to come in. The signals are that BT Sport has achieved a slight broadband swing from Sky, since over the third quarter ending September 30 2013, BT rose by 160,000 to 6.94 million for broadband, while Sky’s growth was down to 90,000 reaching 5.02 million. This was after Sky in June 2013 had responded to the imminent arrival of BT Sport and the decision to give it away free for now to BT broadband subscribers, by offering 12 months free broadband to its sports customers. This was very much a reciprocal deal to BT’s bundling of sports with broadband.

In other key European markets broadband is not interwoven into the sports rights battle, which results in very different dynamics. In Germany, where incumbent Deutsche Telekom has about 42% of the broadband market, Sky Deutschland, majority 54.5% owned by 21st Century Fox (formerly News Corp) and so a sibling of BSkyB, has no fixed line presence at all. Yet Sky Deutschland has still been bidding aggressively for premium sports rights and in April 2012 obtained exclusive pay TV rights for all live Bundesliga and 2nd division Bundesliga matches for the seasons 2013/14 through 2016/17, covering all platforms, including those currently held across satellite, cable and web, as well as IPTV and mobile. This cost about $650 million per season and then Sky Deutschland followed up by acquiring nearly all global TV rights to sell Bundesliga games from the 2015-16 season onwards, including North and South America, most of Asia and in key European markets outside Germany, paying around $190 million a season extra for these.

Coming at a time when the Bundesliga was gaining in strength and popularity, marred only by Bayern Munich’s over-dominance, this looked like good business for Sky and appears to have been motivated partly by an ambition to shut out Deutsche Telekom, which owned IPTV Bundesliga rights previously , from premium sports altogether. The underlying objective of this strategy became clear at the end of 2013 when Sky Deutschland secured a carriage deal to distribute its premium pay TV spots channels on Deutsche Telekom’s IPTV service T-Entertain.

This confounded Deutsche Telekom’s strategy of trying to position Entertain, which is distributed directly to its broadband customers, as an alternative to Sky, having already lured some of the latter’s TV customers away. So here we had a major Telco exploiting a dominant broadband position to sell TV but then being thwarted by losing out over sports rights. Deutsche Telekom then had no alternative but to carry Sky’s pay TV programming or risk TV churn.

In France the situation is different again, with Qatari owned Al Jazeera having decided to attack the French language TV market and use its wealth to buy up rights to both Ligue 1 domestic football and the Europe wide Champions League. The main victim here has been Vivendi owned Canal+ as the dominant operator and broadcaster. Firstly Al Jazeera trumped Canal Plus for domestic football by agreeing to pay about $120 million a year to seize rights to two live Ligue one games a week from 2012 to 2016.

Then Al Jazeera did even better by winning the majority of TV rights to UEFA Champions League matches in France for three years from 2012 in a deal worth $240 million, again taking them from Canal+. This is twice what Canal+ was paying for the previous Champions League package and is another case of spending big on premium sports to make a fast entry into a market. Canal+ put a brave face on it by arguing that it was not just a sports and movie channel, but it is clearly a blow to its position, although so far at least there is little sign of subscriber losses. But these are early days as Al Jazeera is only just getting going in sport, having in December 2013 rebranded Jazeera Sport globally as beIN SPORTS. This includes two channels in French showing the football and other sports.

The arrival of Al Jazeera has boosted French football by increasing the value of rights, much as BT has in the UK, also serving to give another twist of the knife into the belly of the country’s public service broadcasting. France T’l’visions has virtually thrown in the towel and announced it is unlikely to acquire rights for the 2014 Fifa World Cup, according to its director of sport Daniel Bilalian. It had been planning to buy the rights and sublicense them, but is now looking ahead to the UEFA Euro 2016 national team tournament instead, taking place in France. Bilalian admitted that France T’l’visions is severely hampered by financial constraints, so it must be hoping Al Jazeera decides not to bid for those Euro 2016 rights.

Orange, which has over 5 million IPTV subs in France, has also stepped back from bidding for major rights and seems to be concentrating on mobile TV for sports, having decided to go with Al Jazeera for the main channels. Orange used to be the Ligue 1 title sponsor, but then in June 2012 decided to close its Orange Sport channels and offer Al Jazeera’s beIN Sport 1 and 2 channels in their place. However Orange did secure exclusive mobile rights to French soccer’s Ligue 1 and Ligue 2 until June 2016, covering smartphones and tablets of up to 13 inches in screen size. This coverage, for which Orange paid about $33 million over the period, is via both WiFi and 3G, as well as the 4G or LTE network, and the content is carried on the Dailymotion online video-sharing platform, of which Orange owns 49%.

Meanwhile in Italy, football in the top Serie A division has been reinvigorated, after a relative decline, by intensified competition over rights between Sky Italia, 100% owned by 21st Century Fox, and commercial broadcaster Mediaset. As a result, Serie A football clubs are currently considering a proposal to sell their TV rights from the 2015-16 to 2020-21 seasons for €5.49 billion (about $7.3 billion), or around $1.2 billion a year. This would be close to the EPL revenue, admittedly for a later period, starting when the current EPL deal ends. It is likely to ensure that Italy’s league remains competitive with its counterparts in the UK, Germany and Spain, with France also knocking on the door.

In the US the sports scene is totally different as far as pay TV operators are concerned, with most of the premium national rights in the hands of the networks such as ESPN and Fox Sports. But there is also a big market for local rights to games involving just teams in a given area in the major sports, and here the major pay TV operators do play.

Some of the deals are substantial and cover a long period, playing a major role financing the big teams. For example Comcast SportsNet has just concluded a deal with the Philadelphia Phillies Major League baseball team, covering 25 years and costing $2.5 billion, or $100 million a year. That is a lot for one club, reflecting the Phillie’s pedigree as top five finishers for each of the last 4 years and is almost three times the $35 million a year for the current deal, also with Comcast, expiring in 2015. The deal virtually ensures that the Phillies will remain in contention for titles and among the league of big spenders.

In some cases US operators are forming partnerships with clubs over broadcasting rather than purchasing rights. DirecTV Sports Networks, comprising three regional sports networks Root Sports Pittsburgh, Root Sports Rocky Mountain, and Root Sports Northwest, has formed such a partnership with baseball club The Seattle Mariners, after having held the TV rights to its games locally. Now The Mariners is taking a majority stake in a joint venture to broadcast its games in the North West Region until the end of the 2030 Major League Baseball season. DirecTV Sports Networks will continue to oversee the day to day management of the Northwest network.

We are seeing then regional deals extending way into the future, ending at a time when all content could well be distributed over the Internet. It signifies that regional rights carve ups, will not be affected by OTT and will still be enforced. But rights are also being delineated by device type and that will play a part on the sports scene. Already ESPN has been attempting to leverage its WatchESPN app to extract higher overall carriage fees from operators, with some success. Both Time Warner Cable and Verizon Communications, which offer the app to their subscribers, pay ESPN 19 cents more per subscriber per month than does Dish Network, which doesn’t support the app, according to papers from a court case involving ESPN and Dish last year. Dish is currently in negotiations with ESPN for a contract renewal. DirecTV has so far refused to pay ESPN’s asking price for streaming video access, but will attempt to negotiate them when its contract with ESPN expires.

It is unlikely that rights will continue to be segregated by device type in quite the same way, as the OTT era evolves. It may be done purely by screen resolution or size, or the distinction between device types may cease altogether as the world moves inexorably towards some form of pay per view model for premium sports.